The Investigation of Lucy Letby. Lucy Letby in The Investigation of Lucy Letby. Cr. Courtesy of Netflix © 2026

...

H. Alan Scott

By H. Alan Scott

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The Investigation of Lucy Letby. Lucy Letby in The Investigation of Lucy Letby. Cr. Courtesy of Netflix © 2026

...

The true crime genre has long relied on an understanding with the viewer: we accept a certain level of artifice in exchange for the truth. We tolerate shadowy silhouettes, distorted voices, and stilted dramatic reenactments. We understand these are necessary tools to protect the living while honoring the dead. But in Netflix's The Investigation of Lucy Letby, that understanding has been broken. For the first time, I found myself watching a grieving mother and asking a question that should never surface in a documentary: "Is this person real?"

The answer is a chilling "no." A small disclaimer next to "Sarah" and "Maise"—two pivotal figures in the narrative—reads: "Digitally Anonymized." Because the real individuals understandably wished to remain private, the production used AI-generated "humans" to deliver their testimony.

Read More on Entertainment

On paper, the logic is sound. In practice, it is deeply unsettling. "Sarah," a mother recounting the birth and subsequent murder of her daughter, appears to be overcome with emotion. She buries her face in her hands, yet the performance is hollow—she cries, but there are no tears. Meanwhile, "Maise," a friend of Letby, appears in doctored "friendship" photos alongside the real convicted killer. The closer you look, the more the illusion unravels. They are talking FaceTuned images—avatars trapped in the uncanny valley, mimicking sorrow without any of the soul.

The Investigation of Lucy Letby. Cr. Courtesy of Netflix © 2026

...

SUBSCRIBE TO THE PARTING SHOT WITH H. ALAN SCOTT ON APPLE PODCASTS OR SPOTIFY AND THE FOR THE CULTURE NEWSLETTER.

Netflix defended the decision to Esquire, stating the technology was used "to protect the anonymity of the contributors at their request." While protecting anonymity is a cornerstone of documentary journalism, that principle does not justify this particular execution. For decades, documentaries have navigated these challenges with integrity—from the creative shadows of Forensic Files to the admittedly odd 1980s era of Unsolved Mysteries, where real people played themselves in reenactments. (Who would agree to do that?) We have always processed the truth through a filter. We never needed a deepfake to feel the weight of a story.

By embracing this technology, Netflix has positioned "Sarah" and "Maise" as digital pioneers for the future of storytelling. But this is a dangerous frontier. When we replace a human face with an algorithm, we aren't just protecting anonymity—we are sanitizing the reality of their pain. We are asking the audience to build an empathetic connection with someone who is not actually a person, which ultimately cheapens their story, and ultimately the entire point of the documentary.

I am not an anti-AI alarmist. Used thoughtfully, AI can be a transformative asset to creative work. But when we manufacture fake humans to tell the story of murdered infants, the technology becomes an offensive distraction. Instead of honoring the victims and grappling with the incomprehensible horror of Letby's crimes, we are left debating the ethics of a visual effect. In the pursuit of making the documentary more "immersive," Netflix has achieved the opposite: they have made a tragedy feel artificial.

Make sure you're subscribed to the Parting Shot Podcast and the For the Culture newsletter for all the latest in entertainment and pop culture.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines