
...
By Billie Melissa
Contributing Entertainment Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When Bradley Cooper arrived on the scene as a director with A Star is Born in 2018, his efforts were met with the expected mixed reactions; some were excited to see what this new chapter in his career would bring, while others pondered whether it was an attempt at more chances to win an Oscar.
Even after A Star is Born landed a Certified Fresh rating from critics on Rotten Tomatoes and an Oscar win for Lady Gaga, Mark Ronson, Anthony Rossomando, and Andrew Wyatt for their efforts on the original song, "Shallow", Cooper was still met with unusual scrutiny.
His sophomore effort, Maestro – a sweeping love story following legendary conductor and composer Leonard Bernstein, and his wife, actress Felicia Montealegre Cohn Bernstein – found itself a victim of similar frostiness, leading to an audience panning on Rotten Tomatoes.
Read More on Movies
What A Star is Born and Maestro showed was not only Cooper's respect for the medium, but a promising future beyond being the leading man, opening the door to an exciting new chapter for him and his career.
Whether Cooper would direct a film where he allows himself to disappear fully behind the camera was a question on people's lips. Could he make it work without himself as a jack of all trades to sell it?
Enter, Is This Thing On?

...
Cooper shows us a new shade of his directorial chops, joining Will Arnett and Mark Chappell to pen an unlikely story from English comedian, presenter, and actor John Bishop, whose unconventional path to comedy was the seed of inspiration.
Led by Will Arnett as Alex Novak, we follow the separation between him and his wife, Tess, played by Laura Dern.
There's no grand build-up that shows us why the two wish to part ways. We get thrown into the fray alongside them, as Arnett moves out of their plush home to a much smaller apartment in the city. Finding his feet in this new chapter, one fateful night, Alex doesn't have the fee to see the show at the Comedy Cellar, so he signs up to participate as a last-ditch effort to get in.
Awaiting him inside is a life-altering evening that gives him a new lease of life beyond his heartbreak, where he'll go on a journey of catharsis and healing through performance and the community that comes with it.
In his previous films, Cooper has had – quite literally – huge stages to play with. From Glastonbury Festival in A Star is Born to Ely Cathedral in Maestro, he has had the luxury of grandeur to capture audiences' attention, but Is This Thing On? challenges him to tackle intimacy.
With a single mic and a stage barely six feet wide in a basement in New York, Cooper has to get in close. We squeeze ourselves in among the punters and watch as Alex transforms his life in the most unlikely of places.
Stripped back and alive, Cooper's direction is vibrant. It feels reminiscent of his collaborations with David O. Russell, mirroring the frenetic energy of Silver Linings Playbook, with layered dialogue and chaotic families supporting the liveliness.
Cooper puts himself in a small role, playing a friend to Alex, and every time he's on screen, he looks as though he's having the time of his life. With brilliant lines to play with, he delivers comedic relief. With this small but impactful role to focus on, we witness Cooper hone his directorial voice, which particularly shines through Arnett and Dern's magnetic performances.

...
It's been a long while since we've seen Laura Dern front and center in this way. She's had fantastically nuanced supporting roles in recent Best Picture nominees, Noah Baumbach's Marriage Story, a role for which she scored her first Oscar, and Greta Gerwig's Little Women, but we've not seen Dern take the reins like we do in Is This Thing On? for a while.
She's funny and whip-smart, with a fantastic script to aid her. Her chemistry and banter with Will Arnett keep us leaning in and rooting for them. The comedy doesn't detract from her arc, either, which provides a touching commentary on reconnecting with your dreams and finding new meaning in them in adulthood.
Meanwhile, Arnett is on equal footing, digging into all the delicious layers of playing a man finding himself again when his identity as a husband disappears overnight. He has to fall in love with life and himself again, and we get to go on that journey alongside him.
Is This Thing On? perfects the fine line between comedy and tragedy, finding the bitter in the sweet and the sweet in the bitter, a compliment to the script that doesn't lean too hard either way, and instead leaves room for the actors and Cooper to find the tone.
Hitting theaters just before Christmas, it makes for a perfect end-of-year watch. It's life-affirming, heartfelt, and hilarious.Is This Thing On? reminds us that there is a possibility to restore the relationships we feel slipping through our fingers if we meet our friends and family where they're at, and allow them to flourish in new ways, as well as giving ourselves the same grace.
Is This Thing On? Release Date
Is This Thing On? hits theaters on December 19, 2025.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines