
...
By Billie Melissa
Contributing Entertainment Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
When you touch beloved stories that were once award-winners in their heyday, it's fair for a film to come under scrutiny when it doesn't live up to the 100% Certified Fresh Rotten Tomatoes score of its predecessor.
John Patton Ford – who had his own critical success with his feature debut, "Emily the Criminal" – takes on Robert Hamer's "Kind Hearts and Coronets", which once starred Dennis Price, Valerie Hobson, Joan Greenwood, and Alec Guinness. Titled "How to Make a Killing," and starring Glen Powell, Margaret Qualley, Jessica Henwick, and Ed Harris, Ford brings the story to modern-day New Jersey/New York, following Powell as Becket Redfellow, who's in line for a fortune – if he can kill off the family members ahead of him.
Opening in a prison cell – oddly in New Jersey, despite federal death row being in Indiana – we learn Becket is four hours from execution. His crime? Well, the rest of the film will tell you how he got there. The first fall of "How to Make a Killing" is that it's tonally confused. If you're starting the film in a man's final hours, it's bizarre that you'd try to crack a joke about cheesecake, despite the aesthetic and circumstances suggesting it's anything but funny. It's an issue that persists throughout the film, which switches between comedy and old-fashioned drama jarringly, taking audiences out of the narrative with its dull narration and switching back and forth between the cell and the story at hand.
Read More on Movies
The Glen Powell we're used to seeing on screen in films like "Hit Man," "Twisters," and "Anyone But You" is suave, charismatic, and smart, but somehow John Patton Ford manages to make him dull, dreary, and confused. Enter Margaret Qualley as Julia. A woman he's supposed to have chemistry with, but watching the two of them go back and forth feels awkward. She's manipulative and cold, bored with her own wealthy lifestyle and getting off on messing around in his affairs. Qualley's speech – penned by John Patton Ford – doesn't match her performance, nor the film's aesthetic, feeling sometimes like it's from another time, while existing in the present all at once.

...
Its lack of cohesion between aesthetic and story makes it boring, awkward, and clunky, which is a shame as the final sequence with Ed Harris is pretty well crafted, and acted, and makes you wonder what a full film of putting Glen Powell and Ed Harris head to head in a room could lead to.
There are a few more innocent parties. Zach Woods and Topher Grace are a welcome respite from the boredom. Their scenes make sense, and their characters don't feel one foot in the past and one foot in the present, like everyone else. They seem to understand the film they're in and elevate it for their brief sequences.
Powell's sporadic interactions with Jessica Henwick as Ruth – a woman whose function is to remind him that he doesn't need a fortune to be happy – feel contrived and awkward. Their chemistry never manifests either, which feels like a directorial issue, as we've seen Powell's potential to make even the thinnest connections electric on screen.

...
Unfortunately, "How to Make a Killing" feels as though it's trying to do too much, and ultimately delivers on none of its promises. For as much as it wants to be gritty, it wants to be light, and as much as it wants to be funny, it wants to be serious. It's also a shame to see John Patton Ford, who was praised and celebrated by formerly incarcerated people for his efforts to ground "Emily the Criminal" in reality, take a huge step back in his approach to the justice system. While it's a small part of the narrative, Becket Redfellow's death sentence is nonsensical. Its approach to the whole thing is fantastical, logistically inaccurate, and – honestly – insensitive.
Luckily, "How to Make a Killing" – like "Kind Hearts and Coronets" – is only 105 minutes. It doesn't outstay its welcome, but it's an odd feeling to long for a film led by such talent to be over in a flash. Watch its predecessor instead.
‘How to Make a Killing’ Release Date
"How to Make a Killing" is in theaters from February 20, 2026.
Is ‘How to Make a Killing’ Available to Stream?
"How to Make a Killing" is not yet available to stream in the United States.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines