Gypsy Rose Blanchard arrives at An Evening With Lifetime: Conversations On Controversies FYC Event at The Grove on May 01, 2024 in Los Angeles, California.

...

Lydia Patrick

By Lydia Patrick

Life & Trends Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Gypsy Rose Blanchard has addressed criticism after some viewers accused her of making light of her mother’s murder in a TikTok video.

Blanchard, 34, appeared in a TikTok collaboration with influencer Natalie Reynolds, 23, that sparked a wave of negative reactions online.

They took part in the “we listen and we don’t judge” challenge —a trend in which creators share uncomfortable, embarrassing, or controversial confessions while the other person responds with the repeated refrain, “we listen and we don’t judge,” signaling they won’t shame the speaker.

Read More on Entertainment

The video shared on March 21 from Reynold's account, @nataliireynoldss, garnered 13.8 million views.

In the clip, some viewers said the tone was inappropriate given Blanchard’s widely known criminal case, which centered on the killing of her mother, Clauddine “Dee Dee” Blanchard, after years of medical abuse that authorities and commentators have described as consistent with Munchausen syndrome by proxy.

Gypsy Rose Blanchard arrives at An Evening With Lifetime: Conversations On Controversies FYC Event at The Grove on May 01, 2024 in Los Angeles, California.

...

Newsweek reached out to Natalie Reynolds for comment via email.

What Happened In the TikTok

Reynolds begins with a confession that prompted immediate criticism in comment sections and reposts: “One time, I dared a homeless woman $20 to jump into a lake, and then she said she couldn’t swim, and I ran away laughing.” The two then repeat: “We don’t judge. We don’t judge.”

A moment later, Blanchard appears to reference her incarceration and the crime that made her case famous, saying: “I went to prison for eight and a half years," she said and then signaled an "X" sign with her hands.

"Oh my god," Reynolds said. Blanchard interjected: "Hey, we listen and we don't judge."

The rest of the video continues in a similar vein, mixing shock-humor confessions and personal admissions. Reynolds says: “I really like to cup my hand and fart in my hand because I like to smell my fart because I just think it smells really good. Even when I, like, fart in the bed sheets, I like to lift up the bed sheets and smell my fart.”

Blanchard says: “I wear wigs because I bleached my hair off,” and later, Reynolds said: “One time, I faked being pregnant because I didn’t want my ex to leave me.”

Blanchard said: “I used to wipe my bottom with bath towels instead of toilet paper.” Blanchard responds: “What? Like, that’s crazy.” Reynolds replies: “Sounds like you’re judging me right now.” Blanchard ends the segment by saying: “I’m done. I’m not playing this anymore. It’s just a game.”

Why People Were Upset

The backlash centered on what critics perceived as flippancy around her mom's death.

One user wrote, “We listen and we call a judge."

Another said, “The fact she jokes about it doesn’t seem right to me.” A third added, “There’s absolutely nothing funny in this, this is actually so freaking wrong,” while a user named Javi echoed that sentiment in a separate comment.

Blanchard’s Response: 'People Misunderstood'

"The video was supposed to reflect accountability and growth. I was in no way joking about my crime. The intentions behind it was to showcase my continued acceptance of my past with the acknowledgment that I am not perfect," Blanchard told Newsweek.

In a follow-up video message shared from her TikTok @gypsyrose_blanchard727, Blanchard suggested viewers misread the intention of the challenge and said it was meant to reflect accountability rather than mockery.

Blanchard explained to Newsweek that the video began on a serious note before shifting into a lighter tone, explaining that both she and Natalie ended the trend with more humorous comments on unrelated topics. She said she was “deeply saddened” that the video was misunderstood and apologized to anyone who took offense.

"I apologize to anyone who took offense. I don’t normally express things so bluntly, and I think that the video came off as a little too abrasive that it completely missed the mark on what our intentions were for what viewers would take from the video again this video was solely about accountability and growth as individuals that we are not our past mistakes and continue to push forward with positivity," she said.

Reynolds’ Reaction: 'I Regret Absolutely NOTHING'

Reynolds also posted a response framed as an apology, but quickly pivoted to defiance.

She said: “I’m here to apologize for the horrible video I posted with Gypsy Rose… and I regret absolutely NOTHING we said in that video.” Reynolds went on to argue that the pair were “taking accountability” and told critics to move on: “You guys need to learn to move on and accept that everybody makes mistakes nobody’s perfect and Gypsy already did her time in jail.”

She concluded by claiming, “Y’all were begging for her to get out and now that she’s finally out y’all still wanna find another problem with it… you guys are so jealous of Gypsy and I because we’re both celebrities and living our best lives… goodbye.”

Background: Blanchard’s Case and Public Profile

Blanchard became internationally known after authorities said she helped arrange the killing of her mother in 2015, following years in which Dee Dee Blanchard allegedly subjected her daughter to extensive medical procedures and presented her as seriously ill.

Gypsy Rose Blanchard pleaded guilty to second‑degree murder for her role in the killing of her mother in 2016 and received a 10-year sentence. She was released on parole on December 28, 2023, after serving about eight years of her sentence

Her then‑boyfriend, Nicholas Godejohn, was convicted of first‑degree murder for carrying out the stabbing and was sentenced to life in prison without parole, where he remains incarcerated.

Blanchard served prison time and has remained a focus of documentaries, dramatizations, and ongoing public debate about coercion, abuse, culpability, and internet-driven celebrity.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines