
...

By Michileen Martin
Contributing Entertainment Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The premiere of "Daredevil: Born Again" gut-punches fans with a major death in the first 15 minutes, but we don't think that demise was exactly what it seemed to be. To go on further means getting into big spoiler territory, so consider yourself warned.
Read More: Foggy Nelson Returning For 'Daredevil: Born Again' Season 2
This article contains heavy spoilers for "Daredevil: Born Again."
Read More on Comics
The short version of our theory: Foggy Nelson isn't dead, he's in witness protection, and - rather than his rampage being an act of vengeance - Bullseye was hired to murder Foggy.

...
Let's break it down.
We Know Foggy Isn't Dead
We know that, in most likelihood, Foggy (Elden Henson) isn't dead because Marvel TV chief Brad Winderbaum recently confirmed that both Foggy and Karen (Deborah Ann Woll) will return for Season 2. So, assuming Henson's appearances aren't all flashbacks and that he won't be playing a zombie, his character is still alive.
Foggy's Return Won't Be Mystical
Notice how no one in the "Daredevil: Born Again" two episode premiere brings up The Blip? That's because this is the world of Daredevil, which needs to stay more grounded in reality than the rest of Marvel Studios's offerings.
So Foggy won't come back from the Hulk snapping his fingers or from Doctor Strange casting a spell. The explanation that he was medically resuscitated and then ushered into the witness protection program is one that's much more Daredevil-correct.
And it's already happened in the comics. In "The Devil, Inside and Out," Matt Murdock is helpless as he hears Foggy dying, and then later his best friend is found alive and well in witness protection.
If He's In Witness Protection, It's Because He Knows Something
If Bullseye's (Wilson Bethel) attack was nothing more than settling a score with Daredevil (Charlie Cox), then once Foggy is revived there's no reason to put him in witness protection. His attacker was not only under lock and key but, considering Matt threw him off a roof, in no condition to threaten anyone.
So if we assume we're right about Foggy being resuscitated and put in witness protection, it only makes sense if there's someone else Foggy's being protected from; meaning Bullseye was hired to kill him by a third party.
Dumb Benny and Red Hook
Here's where things get interesting.
Before Bullseye's attack, Foggy is chatting up Kirsten (Nikki M. James) and one of the subjects is his client Dumb Benny. Foggy is convinced Benny will walk. Their discussion is interrupted by a call from Benny, which Matt hears with his enhanced senses. When Matt asks Foggy about it, one of the first things Foggy says is, "After that thing in Red Hook, [Benny] said he was getting threats, so I stashed him."
Not long after Foggy's "death," we hear another discussion about Red Hook. We don't get details, but two of the crime bosses Vanessa Fisk (Ayelet Zurer) handles have a disagreement over something that happened in Red Hook. It's smoothed out once Vanessa reminds everyone Red Hook is exempt from "any taxes, tolls, or other payments."
So whatever Benny did in Red Hook, it was probably the same thing the two crime bosses were arguing about. Foggy seemed confident Benny was going to walk, which could mean he was going to spill any information he had about Red Hook. That might be enough to put out a hit on Benny and his lawyers.
Whether we're right about our theory or not, we'll learn soon enough. The next episode of "Daredevil: Born Again" streams Tuesday, March 11 on Disney+.
More Comics:
'Daredevil: Born Again' Stars Reveal One Line Saved Tense Scene
'She-Hulk' Star Loves How Show Predicted Toxic Fan Responses
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines