Elon Musk and Sam Altman

...

Theo Burman

By Theo Burman

Live News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Elon Musk will have to face court claims of running a "years-long harassment campaign" against OpenAI after a judge refused his request to dismiss.

US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ruled on Tuesday that Musk would face allegations of weaponized legal claims and continued social media attacks against his former business colleague-turned-rival Sam Altman, and the artificial intelligence company that they co-founded together, which produces ChatGPT.

Musk asked for the counterclaim, which was filed in April, to be dismissed, as the latest stage in a legal battle between Musk and Altman over the management of OpenAI, which Musk departed from in 2019.

Read More on News

Newsweek has approached Musk and Altman for comment by email outside of working hours.

Why It Matters

Musk and Altman are not on good terms. After co-founding OpenAI in 2015, Musk left the company, citing disagreements over the organization's direction. Since then, Musk has leaned hard into developing his own generative artificial intelligence, such as Grok, which is managed by xAI.

This means that his former colleague is now a rival in the AI space; OpenAI claim that this competition is the motivation behind Musk's regular attacks on Altman and his management of the company.

What To Know

In an order from the district court in the Northern District of California, Gonzalez Rogers ruled that OpenAI's counterclaim that Musk's frequent discussion of Altman and OpenAI is an "unfair and fraudulent business practice... as well as tortious interference with
prospective economic advantage" would be heard in court.

The ruling came despite Musk's legal team requesting that the counterclaims be dismissed.

Musk regularly criticizes Altman and his management of OpenAI on his social media site X, branding him as "Scam Altman" and claiming that he "lies as easily as he breathes".

Elon Musk and Sam Altman

...

The legal battle has been ongoing since February 2024 when Musk filed a lawsuit alleging he had secured a commitment from Altman and Brockman to maintain OpenAI as a nonprofit entity. This lead to OpenAI releasing Musk's emails showing the past support for transforming the organization into a for-profit company.

Musk dropped that lawsuit in June 2024 without explanation. In August 2024, he then filed a federal suit against OpenAI and accused the creators of ChatGPT, including founders Altman and Brockman, of being a "textbook tale of altruism versus greed."

In November last year, he added Microsoft as a defendant. OpenAI described the accusations as "baseless," telling the BBC: "Elon's third attempt in less than a year to reframe his claims is even more baseless and overreaching than the previous ones."

What People Are Saying

Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers said in the ruling's documents: "Having carefully considered the papers submitted and the pleadings in this action, and for the reasons set forth below, the Court hereby denies plaintiffs' motion to dismiss the
counterclaims and grants defendants' motions to dismiss the re-pled claims in the SAC without leave to amend."

Elon Musk said on X in July: "Altman cannot be trusted. He inverted the mission of OpenAI from a non-profit, open source AI company to a closed source, maximum-profit AI company. Deception."

Sam Altman told CNBC on Friday, in reference to Musk: "You know, I don't think about him that much. I thought he was just tweeting all day about how much OpenAI sucks, and our model is bad, and, you know, [we're] not going to be a good company and all that.

What Happens Next

A trial in a federal court in California is scheduled for March.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines