
...


By Dan Gooding and Jenna deJong
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Elon Musk has called for impeaching federal judges who have blocked President Donald Trump's executive orders, a move that has sparked debate over the limits of judicial oversight and the separation of powers.
The push comes amid increasing tensions between the White House and the judiciary, as courts have issued rulings that temporarily halt major Trump policies.
Why It Matters
The demand for judicial impeachments represents an unprecedented escalation in the ongoing battle between the Trump administration and the federal courts. Impeachment of federal judges has been historically rare and reserved for cases involving criminal misconduct or ethical violations, not policy disagreements.
Read More
White House Reacts to ‘Constitutional Crisis’ Claims6 min read

Elon Musk Calls for Impeachment of Judges After DOGE Legal Blows4 min read

Donald Trump Facing Defeat in Birthright Citizenship Battle—Legal Analyst4 min read

Critics warn that such efforts could threaten the judiciary's independence and the constitutional system of checks and balances.
Did Elon Musk Call For Impeachment Inquiries Into Judges?
Musk has been vocal about his dissatisfaction with judicial rulings against Trump's policies. While his comments on social media have called for immediate impeachments, no formal inquiry has been launched as a direct result of his statements.
However, his rhetoric has influenced Republican lawmakers, such as Representative Derrick Van Orden, who introduced a resolution targeting Judge Paul Engelmayer, Reuters reported. Legal experts argue that Musk's calls could set a precedent for using impeachment as a political tool rather than a constitutional check on misconduct.

...
What To Know
The impeachment calls follow a series of legal setbacks for the Trump administration. Federal judges have recently ruled against executive actions restricting access to Treasury Department data, freezing federal funding, and limiting transgender health care access for minors.
Musk, who leads the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), expressed frustration over the rulings, posting on X, formerly Twitter, on February 12: "There needs to be an immediate wave of judicial impeachments, not just one."
In one ruling, Engelmayer temporarily blocked DOGE's access to Treasury Department systems, citing concerns over improper access to sensitive financial data. The ruling immediately sparked backlash from Musk, who called Engelmayer "a corrupt judge protecting corruption" and stated, "He needs to be impeached NOW!"
Van Orden formally introduced a resolution to impeach Engelmayer, citing judicial misconduct and abuse of power. However, impeachment requires a majority vote in the House of Representatives and a two-thirds vote in the Senate, making its success unlikely given the chamber's current composition.
What People Are Saying
Elon Musk posted on X on February 11: "We must impeach judges who are grossly undermining the will of the people and destroying America. It is the only way."
Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of Berkeley Law, told Newsweek: "It is outrageous to call for impeachment of judges because one doesn't like their rulings. It denies the very notion of an independent judiciary. A judge can be impeached only for treason, bribery, or high crimes and misdemeanors.
"None have been committed by these judges. But the House can impeach by a majority vote, and the Senate can remove by a two-thirds vote for whatever it deems meets this constitutional standard."
**Marin Levy, a law professor at Duke University, told Newsweek: "**Congress—and Congress alone—has the authority to impeach an Article III judge. But impeachment is meant to be used only in the case of serious offenses and not if someone is simply unhappy with the outcome of a case.
"Specifically, the Constitution sets out that judges may be impeached for engaging in 'treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.' And it is important to stress how rare impeachment has been. In the country's history, there have been thousands of Article III judges [but] only 15 have been impeached by Congress. Those who were impeached were charged with grave misconduct, including accepting bribes and abuse of the contempt power."
White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said at a press briefing on February 20: "Today marks one month of President Trump's return...and there is no denying this administration is off to a historic start. The president has already signed 73 executive orders. That is more than double the number signed by [former President] Joe Biden and more than quadruple the number signed by [former President] Barack Obama over the same period."
What Happens Next
Despite calls for impeachment, judicial removals remain rare. According to the Federal Judicial Center, of the 15 federal judges impeached in U.S. history, only eight were convicted by the Senate. Given these historical precedents and the current political landscape, the chances of successfully removing a judge over policy disagreements remain slim.
The ongoing legal battles over Trump's executive orders are expected to continue, with further court challenges and appeals likely. Meanwhile, critics warn that continued attacks on the judiciary could have lasting effects on public trust in the legal system.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines