
...

By Alex J. Rouhandeh
National Political Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The first election since President Donald Trump’s resounding 2024 comeback couldn’t have gone much worse for Republicans.
Democrats won the New Jersey and Virginia governorships by wide margins, while carrying the down ballot. The party maintained control of three liberal judgeships in Pennsylvania, won a redistricting ballot measure in California, and flipped two Public Service Commission seats in the swing state of Georgia. On top of this, a Democratic Socialist now serves as mayor of Trump’s hometown city of New York.
These results hold weight, as they offer the first major referendum on Trump’s performance. They also raise longer-term concerns about the Republican Party’s ability to maintain the MAGA coalition and turnout the party’s base when their charismatic leader’s name won’t appear on the ballot come the 2026 midterms and beyond.
Read More on News
“On Tuesday, Americans across the country resoundingly rejected Trump and his billionaire-first agenda that has failed to lower costs for working families,” Kendall Witmer, rapid response director for the Democratic National Committee, told Newsweek. “In just 10 months, Trump has destroyed the economy and failed to deliver on key promises he made in order to piece together a coalition in 2024, leading to major fractures among his supporters. The Republican agenda is deeply unpopular among the majority of Americans and their voters failed to show up for them, signaling disaster for the midterms and 2028.”
While much can be debated over the potential effects that the president’s popularity had on these races, one thing is certain — Republicans turned out at a far lower rate than they did with Trump atop the ballot. This trend is evident in the two governors' races.

...
Presidential elections juice turnout. As of data gathered Thursday by the AP, over 1.9 million people turned out for Virginia Democratic candidate Abigail Spanberger, compared to the over 2.3 million people who turned out for Harris, a roughly 22 percent drop. However, just over 1.4 million people turned out for Winsome Earle-Sears compared to the nearly 2.1 million people who came out for Donald Trump, a nearly 45 percent drop.
The same was true in New Jersey. Over 2.2 million people turned out for Harris compared to 1.8 million-plus people who backed Democratic candidate Mikie Sherrill, a 22 percent shift. In turn, nearly 1.4 million people showed up for Jack Ciattarelli compared to the almost 2 million people who came out for Donald Trump, a 42 percent fall off.
Democrats argue that Republicans who are not Trump cannot replicate the coalition he turns out. They see the 2024 coalition as a band of disparate factions whose sole link is to the current president, whose charisma and lack of adherence to traditional ideologies hold them together. Example one is Silicon Valley tech executives, who favor economic deregulation and H-1B visas, and MAGA Republicans in the heartland, who favor a minimum wage hike and oppose immigration.
Republicans disagree with this analysis, however. They argue that Trump has achieved historic successes and that the complete fulfillment of his agenda will come with time, putting future down-ballot candidates in a position to further his vision —a vision that conservatives may realize could be hampered if they don’t turn out in 2026.
"President Trump is restoring freedom and prosperity for every American,” Kiersten Pels, national press secretary for the Republican National Committee, told Newsweek. “Republicans are united behind his America First agenda, and voters know the stakes. With Democrats in control of Congress, we’d see nothing but witch hunts, impeachment stunts, and partisan chaos. Maintaining a Republican Congress in 2026 will give President Trump the full four years he needs to finish the work he began for the American people.”
Trump has played a significant role in mediating the end of eight conflicts across the globe, including the deadly war between Israel and Hamas that has been a lightning rod in U.S. politics. He’s brought illegal border crossings down to historic lows and has successfully leveraged tariffs to cut new trade deals. However, voters often blame the president for the problems most immediately before them.
Republicans, including Vice President JD Vance, argue it will take time for voters to see the effects of Trump’s policies on affordability, but point to interest rate cuts and the record-performing stock market as signs their efforts are working. They stress not to overinterpret the outcomes of elections in “blue states.”
Vance, in a Twitter statement, conceded "our coalition is ‘lower propensity’ and that means we have to do better at turning out voters than we have in the past.” If the party does not figure out how to stimulate that coalition without Trump on the ballot, then 2026 could look very much like 2025. And once again, that election will be shaped by Trump’s effect on Democratic and Republican turnout. Come 2028, though, that role will be filled by someone else.
Trump has all but anointed Vance and Secretary of State/National Security Advisor Marco Rubio as his two preferred successors. Vance, a son of Appalachia who once worked for Silicon Valley investor Peter Thiel’s venture capital firm, could be the man to keep MAGA and big tech together. Rubio, on the other hand, holds significant credibility amongst the Republican old guard and could attract a greater number of Hispanic voters with his deep record on Latin American affairs and ability to win over deficit hawks.
However, neither man may have the ability to harness the magic of Trump to turn out the kind of voters he has been able to rally. Policy and messaging shifts may be essential for the GOP to win without Trump atop the ticket. Ultimately, no politician has yet been able to disprove that the president is one of a kind. And those who have tried to replicate The Donald in swing states have more often than not fallen to their Democratic competitor.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines