
...

By Jordan King
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Donald Trump’s Religious Liberty Commission has descended into chaos, leaving a Catholic activist ousted from the commission after multiple heated exchanges about Israel and antisemitism.
Carrie Prejean Boller, a model and former beauty pageant titleholder turned conservative activist, was removed from the White House Religious Liberty Commission on Wednesday, after a fiery hearing on Monday.
During the hearing, which focused on antisemitism, Boller clashed with several people, including a rabbi and Seth Dillon, CEO of conservative satirical site The Babylon Bee, who was speaking out against what he argued was growing antisemitism on the right.
Read More on News
Boller repeatedly pressed the question of whether anti-Zionism is always antisemitism and defended conservative podcaster Candace Owens, who has long been accused of antisemitism
Chair of the commission Texas Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick said on Wednesday in a post on X that he made the decision to remove Boller because “no member of the commission has the right to hijack a hearing for their own personal and political agenda on any issue.”
Boller questioned Patrick’s authority to do this, saying that Trump was the one who appointed her.
“Unless and until I receive written notice from the President of the United States requesting my removal, I will continue to defend religious freedom for all religions on this Commission,” she said in an open letter posted to X.
Conservative influencer Laura Loomer, who celebrated Boller’s removal, said in a post on X: “I can confirm that the White House directed Dan Patrick to remove Carrie Prejean Boller from the White House Religious Liberty Commission. Dan Patrick was asked by the White House to remove her.”
Newsweek has contacted Patrick and the White House, via email outside of normal working hours, for comment. It also contacted The Babylon Bee, via online contact form outside of normal working hours, for comment on behalf of Dillon, as well as Boller, via direct message on social media.
What Is the Religious Liberty Commission?
The Religious Liberty Commission is a new federal advisory panel created by President Trump in May 2025 to focus on religious freedom in the United States, based in the Department of Justice and is chaired by Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick.
Its tasked with studying the roots and current threats to religious liberty, boosting awareness of religious pluralism, and recommending policies to protect Americans’ right to practice their faith.
It also advises the White House Faith Office and the Domestic Policy Council on religious liberty issues.
Hearings have included religious liberty issues in public education and the military with he most recent one on Monday, its fifth, focusing on the “Religious Liberty Implications of Anti-Semitism.”

...
What Happened In The Antisemitism Hearing?
The hearing heard first-hand accounts from college students and witnesses who said universities failed to protect Jewish students during multiple pro-Palestine protests.
Boller began by addressing Yitzchok Frankel, a UCLA law student who had spoken about his experiences, which she said she takes “very seriously.”
She went on to say that the demonstrators he was talking about were “protesting the killing of tens of thousands of Palestinian civilians in Gaza.”
“I need to ask you,” she said, “in a country built on religious liberty in the First Amendment, do you believe that someone can stand firmly against antisemitism, including what you experienced, and at the same time condemn the mass killing of Palestinians in Gaza, or reject political Zionism or not support the political state of Israel?”
“In my view,” she went on, “the United States cannot and must not make loyalty to a particular theology about Israel a litmus test for protected speech or moral legitimacy.”
Frankel argued that people are using Palestinian civilian death, which he said is “horrible,” as a “prop.”
“You want to protest Israel, great, 100 percent, go ahead and do it,” he said, “they can protest, they can’t block Jews and you can’t assist them in doing it.”
When she later asked if “anti-Zionism is the same as antisemitism,” Frankel answered: “Yes.”
Rabbi Ari Berman came in at this point, saying: “Undoubtably anti-Zionism is antisemitism. And one does not have to support the specific policies of the government of Israel but to not support the right of Israel to exist [is] absolutely antisemitism.”
When Rabbi Berman was finished speaking, Boller said, to the sound of boos form the crowd: “Well as you know I’m a Catholic and Catholics do not embrace Zionism, just so you know, so are all Catholics antisemitic?”
Patrick interrupted at this point, the first of many times he did afterwards, saying: “This is not a commission on defending religions or calling out any theology.”
Boller pushed back, saying she “wants to be clear what the definition of antisemitism is” before clashing again with the American Jewish activist Shabbos Kestenbaum and asking him to “condemn what Israel has done in Gaza.”
Patrick tried to interrupt at his point again but both Boller and Kestenbaum continued arguing until Patrick slammed his hammer down multiple times telling them to “have coffee” to discuss the topic.
The Main Clash
Things came to a head during part two of the commission, when Seth Dillon spoke out against conservative podcasters Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson.
Boller said she does not believe that Owens is an “antisemite” and the two clashed over the phrase “Christ is King” with Dillon arguing that “the phrase can be abused" adding that Owens has said "way worse than that."
"Do you think that anything Candace has said is antisemitic?" Dillon asked. "No," Boller answered. "I listen to her daily and I haven't heard one thing out of her mouth that is antisemitic."
They then started to talk about a Hamptons meeting that took place before Charlie Kirk was assassinated on September 10 last year, which has become a major topic of discussion among conservatives in the wake of Kirk's death, over whether it was an "intervention" from pro-Israel figures or not.
Newsweek has covered this in detail here.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines