10
Loading video...
By Megan Cartwright
Associate News Editor
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The White House marked Labor Day 2026 with a video celebrating American workers—but the 38-second social media clip showed automated machinery and robots instead of people, amid the ongoing national debate over AI, automation, and job security.
The imagery struck critics as "tone-deaf," particularly as anxiety over automation and its impact on jobs remains widespread. For some viewers, a holiday intended to honor American laborers instead appeared to celebrate the machines increasingly capable of replacing them.
Newsweek contacted the White House via email on Tuesday for comment and is awaiting a response.
Read More on News
Why It Matters
Labor Day is meant to honor the American workforce. But the White House's choice to center its holiday message on an automated production line sparked a broader debate over who—or what—keeps the country running.
The reaction comes as automation and artificial intelligence continue to reshape workplaces, fueling concerns about job security and the future of work.
A Video Without Workers
The White House's video, which was posted to social media platforms including X and Instagram, followed a custom "The White House" pen as it moved through an automated factory line. The clip ended with what appeared to be President Donald Trump signing a document.
...
"This Labor Day, we celebrate the workers and products that are proudly MADE IN AMERICA," the White House wrote in the caption.
Yet there was a conspicuous omission: No human workers appeared in the manufacturing sequence.
The International Federation of Robotics reports that 542,000 industrial robots were installed worldwide in 2024—more than double the number a decade earlier—while the U.S. had about 307 robots per 10,000 manufacturing employees, among the highest rates globally.
At the same time, the World Economic Forum estimates that three in four industrial jobs are expected to evolve, with about 40 percent of future industrial skills classified as new or emerging, highlighting that the central issue may be less mass replacement than the security of workers whose tasks and skills are changing.
Recent research summarized by the International Federation of Robotics likewise finds that robots can displace particular tasks while also raising productivity, creating new tasks and supporting employment—making retraining and worker transition crucial to whether automation improves or undermines job security
The Backlash
Critics quickly seized on the irony.
"There isn't a single American worker in this video," wrote Christopher Hale, a 2020 congressional nominee in Tennessee and former Obama-Biden White House campaign staffer, in a post that had been viewed more than 425,000 times.
A community note attached to the clip pointed out that it showed "a fully automated assembly line producing pens, with no human workers visible." The note also said many viewers believed the footage appeared to be AI-generated.
Others took a more sarcastic approach.
"There are zero real humans featured and 99% of the video is done with AI," X user @bygeno wrote in a message with over 35,700 views and 4,800 likes. "What a tone deaf video to be posted on Labor Day."
Different Shoes, Same Debate
A follow-up White House post put people back at the center of the Labor Day message—at least indirectly.
The post showed work boots at a construction site alongside the caption: "Different shoes. Same American determination. America wouldn't be America without the people who keep it moving."
Praise From Supporters
Despite criticism, the White House drew praise from supporters of the administration too.
Senior adviser to the United States Agency for Global Media Kari Lake called the shoe clip "pure BRILLIANCE," writing that it showed "The American worker in one video." She praised: "God Bless the men and women who built this country and keep things going."
At the time of publication, Lake's remarks garnered 42,000 views and 1,800 likes.
Yet workers faced tangible economic challenges over the holiday weekend.
A Sour Note at the Pump
The Labor Day weekend saw fuel prices reaching record levels for the holiday.
The national average for regular gasoline climbed to $4.15 a gallon, according to AAA—the highest Labor Day price on record and the first time the holiday weekend average had topped $4. While still below the all-time national record of $5.02 a gallon set in June 2022, the increase represented a significant burden for drivers heading into the final major travel weekend of the summer.
Diesel prices were even higher. The national average reached a record $5.85 a gallon on Friday before rising another 5 cents by Monday, adding further pressure for motorists and businesses that depend on diesel-powered transportation.
In addition, as the White House celebrated American workers and products made in the United States, high fuel costs were adding to the everyday expenses faced by many of those same workers.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: John Fitzpatrick and James Debens
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines