10
Loading video...

By Katherine Fung
Senior Writer
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A Supreme Court petition filed by former President Donald Trump in his final days in the White House may come back to haunt him as the high court considers Special Counsel Jack Smith's own request in Trump's federal election interference case.
Trump's attorneys asked the Supreme Court on Wednesday to reject Smith's request to fast-track a ruling on whether or not Trump's presidential immunity claim would protect him from prosecution, arguing that the justices should not rule on the matter before the Court of Appeals makes its decision because it would eliminate arguments that may have been raised during consideration by lower courts.
His lawyers noted that the Supreme Court only grants certiorari "before judgement" if a case shows "such imperative public importance as to justify deviation from normal appellate practice and to require immediate determination in this Court" and that Smith "provides virtually no explanation" of how the immunity claim would fall under those exceptions.
Read More
Exclusive: Dean Phillips on Stimulus Checks, Weed and the Risk of Joe Biden37 min read

John Fetterman Now Embraced by Conservatives3 min read

Joe Rogan Mocked for Botching Joe Biden Takedown3 min read

Former federal prosecutor and elected state attorney Michael McAuliffe told Newsweek that although the standards that the Supreme Court uses to decide whether or not to hear a case are stringent, there have been a growing number of cases that the justices have accepted to hear under those standards, including one that Trump's own administration successfully petitioned.
"The Trump administration even used the cert. before judgment vehicle to successfully seek the Court's intervention in a death penalty case in the last days of the Trump presidency," McAuliffe said. "The procedure for the Court to invoke jurisdiction prior to a court of appeals decision is no longer the extreme rarity, akin to seeing the snow leopard in the wild."
Nine days before Joe Biden was inaugurated as president, the Department of Justice under the Trump administration filed a petition to the Supreme Court, asking it to hear the case of Dustin John Higgs, who was facing a death sentence for the murders of three women in Maryland in 1996.
Higgs had contracted COVID a few weeks prior to his scheduled execution and his attorneys had raised concern that the virus caused lung damage that would lead to him feeling "a sensation of drowning akin to waterboarding" during the execution. It was postponed by a federal judge on January 12, 2021. However, the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case before judgement from an appeals court three days later, and subsequently ruled 6-3 to let it proceed. Higgs was executed by lethal injection on January 16, 2021.
Higgs' execution was highly controversial. A petition demanding that Higgs' life be spared amassed over 1.5 million signatures before the Supreme Court's decision. He was the thirteenth and last person executed by the federal government during the Trump administration and remains the most recent person executed by the U.S. government. There is currently a moratorium on federal executions in place.

...
"If you think Smith doesn't have a good case for #SCOTUS granting certiorari 'before judgment' on Trump's immunity, here's the Court in 2021 granting *Trump's* request for cert. before judgment for no other reason than to clear the way for one last execution before he left office," legal commentator Steve Vladek wrote in a post on X, formerly Twitter.
Former federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani told Newsweek that although granting certiorari before judgment is rare for the Supreme Court, there is "plenty of precedent," including Higgs, and the justices have also become increasingly willing to skip the court of appeals in recent years.
Rahmani said while Higgs is not binding on Trump, Smith should point out to the Supreme Court that even the Trump administration had previously asked for their case to be fast-tracked.
"Smith should note that Trump's own Department of Justice has requested expedited appeals," he said. "That's something that may sway the Justices."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines