...
By Anna Rahmanan
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
It took Donald Trump and Nicki Minaj until January 2026 to meet. They had spent much of the previous two decades becoming famous in parallel: two children of Queens who made themselves larger than life, developed armies of devoted followers and discovered that offending people was often as profitable as pleasing them.
When they finally came together at a Treasury Department event in Washington, they held hands onstage and we all ogled. Minaj declared herself the president's biggest fan and he, in turn…admired her fingernails. An illustrative meeting, indeed.
The moment was perfect tabloid fodder, sure, but also revealed something about the state of our culture.
Read More on Analysis
For all their extraordinary success, Trump and Minaj belong to moments that, to many, have largely passed. Both remain famous, commanding loyal audiences and generating excitement and headlines no matter what they do. Yet their ability to determine what comes next, especially in light of the result of the midterms, is a more doubtful proposition.
Their alliance raises an awkward question for a president who once seemed to have an instinctive understanding of America's appetite for novelty: has Trump become so established that even his celebrity endorsements are beginning to look nostalgic?
The Peculiar Afterlife of Cultural Dominance
Let's begin by acknowledging Minaj's stature. With 224 million Instagram followers—roughly 63 million more than fellow rapper Cardi B—she still commands an enormous audience, even three years after her last No. 1 album.
But popularity and cultural leadership are different accomplishments. The former measures how many people are still watching while the latter concerns who decides what they will watch next.
Minaj once helped establish the vocabulary of contemporary female rap, from the exaggerated voices to the theatrical alter egos and everything in-between. Her influence survives in a generation of performers who grew up with her music, sure, but her most recognizable innovations are now part of the genre's established repertoire. She remains a star in a musical world she helped create, while newer artists increasingly determine its direction.
Trump faces a similar distinction, albeit in the political world. His 2024 presidential victory demonstrated extraordinary political resilience but the methods that once made him seem so unconventional have now become, at the very least in the U.S., familiar. Trump demonstrated that a politician could insult opponents, disregard traditional standards of decorum and treat controversy as a political asset and, as other personalities learned the lesson, what once distinguished him from the establishment has become a recognizable style within it.
Related Story
Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s Revenge
Related Story
Trump Is Preparing to Cut a Pregnancy Safety Net That Barely Exists
Related Story
Trump’s Cuban Revolution Is Stuck in Limbo
He once pioneered a new political culture; now he is one of its many practitioners, albeit still the commander in chief.
The November 3 midterms offered a more immediate measure of Trump's waning influence: he campaigned for Republican candidates, and they lost.
The difficulty for both celebrities is that their influence has been so thoroughly absorbed by their respective professions that they can no longer claim exclusive ownership of it.
When the Rebels Become a Heritage Act
What happens when two cultural figures who have become passé decide to join forces? In the case of Trump and Minaj, the result is a curious revival of the very provocations that once made them famous.
The partnership has even produced talk of a White House job. On October 30, Trump called the suggestion of making Minaj his press secretary "a good idea" and said he would think about it. He then suggested the interviewer, Benny Johnson, might be suitable, too. Whether a serious prospect or another publicity-generating joke, the exchange was entirely in character for both.
The alliance between the president and the rapper has a coherent logic as both have cultivated audiences for whom attacks from outsiders reinforce loyalty. Both also understand that public disapproval can become a form of publicity.
But a provocation loses some of its disruptive power when the audience knows precisely what to expect (and comes to expect it of everyone).
There is also something faintly touching about watching two professional provocateurs congratulate each other on their courage. Whether their combined celebrity can attract anyone new is a rather different question.
Rebellion, it turns out, can become a heritage industry.
The Limits of the Encore
The midterms offered a useful test of how far Trump's appeal could travel beyond his own name on the ballot. The results suggest that even a president with an extraordinary gift for attracting attention cannot necessarily lend that gift to someone else.
Perhaps the next test for Trump and Minaj is whether their alliance can reach people who have yet to become admirers. For now, their reunion has supplied a curious spectacle: two people who helped invent the present, looking increasingly comfortable in the past.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines