
...

By Kate Plummer
Senior US News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Donald Trump's reported negative comment about Milwaukee could cost him the presidential election, according to analysts.
Speaking to Newsweek, political experts assessed the political ramifications of reports claiming the former president called the Wisconsin city "horrible" during a closed-door meeting with GOP lawmakers at the U.S. Capitol on Thursday.
The meeting was a precursor to the Republican National Convention, set to take place in Milwaukee from July 15 to 18, where Trump is expected to be chosen as the party's nominee. According to Jake Sherman, a founder of online political news daily Punchbowl News, the Republican attacked the convention's location, saying, "Milwaukee, where we are having our convention, is a horrible city."
Read More on Politics
Steven Cheung, Trump's spokesperson, denied the report on X, formerly Twitter. He wrote: "Wrong. Total bull****. He never said it like how it's been falsely characterized as. He was talking about how terrible crime and voter fraud are."

...
Nevertheless, experts suggested that the reports could alienate voters, which may be damaging given polls ahead of the presidential election are so tight. Christopher Phelps, a professor of modern American history at the University of Nottingham in the U.K, told Newsweek that the alleged comment could particularly affect undecided, centrist and independent voters.
"When it comes down to a struggle for every last vote, as the race is in states like Wisconsin, Michigan, and Pennsylvania, it's never a great idea to condemn a whole city that many call home," Phelps said. "To be honest, Donald Trump's Wisconsin core base won't care—they're mostly rural and they've swallowed far more controversial comments from him. But undecided voters, centrist voters, and independent voters in Wisconsin might take affront, particularly if it reminds them of concerns about Trump's stability and judgment."
However, he added that voters will probably primarily vote on other issues.
"It's probably not advisable to make too much of a stray comment made five months before the election, though," he said. "Mostly voters in November will be making their choices based on issues such as the economy, immigration policy, abortion, and democracy and rule of law."
Wisconsin is a key battleground state that could prove crucial to the result of November's election. Trump won an upset victory in Wisconsin in 2016, carrying the state by less than 1 percent. In 2020, Biden won Wisconsin with 49.4 percent of the vote to Trump's 48.8. Democrats had won all seven previous presidential elections in Wisconsin up to 2016.
As a result of the Electoral College system, which awards each state a certain number of electoral votes based on population, battleground states will play a key role in determining the result of the election. So far, different polls have suggested different outcomes in Wisconsin and every vote matters.
With that in mind, Mark Shanahan, who teaches American politics at the University of Surrey in the U.K., said Trump had let "his mouth run long before his political brain engaged."
He told Newsweek: "Wisconsin is one of the battleground states that Joe Biden won by 49.4 percent to 48.8 percent of the vote in 2020. While the rural counties break Republican, urban areas lean Democrat and the State has tended to vote blue in recent times. However, Trump won it narrowly in 2016 and the choice of Milwaukee to host the Republican National Convention was undoubtedly made to swing a very purple state red. By letting his mouth run long before his political brain engaged, Trump may well have lost the 20,000 or so Cheesehead votes he needs to win Wisconsin's 10 Electoral College votes."
Following the fallout, a number of Trump's Republican allies have defended Trump, with some saying the remarks were taken out of context.
When asked about the reported incident by host Sean Hannity, Speaker of the House and Trump ally Mike Johnson said: "No, I didn't hear it, and I was sitting right next to him."
On X, formerly Twitter, Wisconsin Representative Bryan Steil wrote: "I was in the room. President Trump did not say this. There is no better place than Wisconsin in July."
Representative Scott Fitzgerald told Matt Smith, the political director of WISN, an ABC affiliate in Milwaukee, that Trump made the comment, but he said it was in response to a question about electoral integrity.
"What he was talking about was the elections in Milwaukee. They're concerned about them," Fitzgerald said.
But these defenses have not quelled the political fallout.
Todd Landman, Professor of Political Science at Nottingham University in the U.K. said Trump had made "a strategic error" that "will alienate voters."
"In a presidential race as close as this one, it is a strategic error for Mr. Trump to [allegedly] describe Milwaukee as a 'horrible city,'" he told Newsweek. "Wisconsin is a key battleground state, where every vote counts and to disparage the city in this way will alienate voters. Coming on the back of his comments in his recent rally that 'I don't care about you, I just want your vote,' the campaign needs to control its candidate from making such remarks or it risks losing crucial votes to win."
In response to a request for further comment, Cheung asked Newsweek if it had attended the meeting. He then sent Newsweek links to three tweets from Republican figures denying that Trump made the comments.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines