
...
By Sophie Clark
Live News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
President Donald Trump's former lawyer Jay Sekulow has been named as a defendant in a lawsuit alleging that the defendants misled the police in the 2022 murder investigation of an employee of Sekulow's.
Linda Clary Umberger, the mother of John Umberger, has accused Sekulow, his son, Jordan Sekulow, and the legal organization they run, of covering up his death. John Umberger was killed by gang members who had targeted gay nightlife spaces in New York City.
According to the mother's complaint, Sekulow and his son did not want to be associated with hiring a gay man at their organization the American Center for Law and Justice, Inc (ACLJ).
Read More on News
Attorney Michael Bowe, who represents Jay Sekulow and Jordan Sekulow told Newsweek: "The complaint's allegations against ACLJ are demonstrably untrue."

...
Why It Matters
The Sekulows are accused of trying to hide that they hired a gay man to run operations for their nonprofit from a townhouse in New York City.
Clary Umberger is accusing her son's former employer of impeding the New York Police Department (NYPD) investigation and inflicting "unnecessary pain and suffering on John's heirs and loved ones."
She has also accused them of failing in their duty of care to protect her son, who died on company property, concealing his death and interfering with insurance.
She is asking for a total of $23 million in damages from the Defendants for the three counts she has accused them of: Negligence, Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress, and Tortious Interference With Contract.

...
What To Know
John Umberger was drugged and murdered in 2022. His killers, Jayqwan Hamilton, 37, and Robert DeMaio, 36, were found guilty of his murder in February, 2025. They were sentenced to 40 years to life in prison on May 21, 2025.
In 2022, Jay Sekulow employed John Umberger as the Director of Diplomacy and Political Programs for the ACLJ.
Sekulow was and is also the President and Chief Executive Officer of Christian Advocates Serving Evangelism (CASE). According to the suit, ACLJ and CASE are intertwined organizations.
The ACLJ has taken up a number of cases focused on anti-abortion causes, school prayer, and religious freedom for Christians.
The suit alleges that John was working for ACLJ in Washington, D.C., at the time, but was sent to New York on assignment to expand the organizations connections in the city. He was told to stay in a recently purchased townhouse, which the suit accuses the defendants of knowing was not fully fitted for security.
The townhouse, per the suit, cost $16.5 million and was intended as a base for the ACLJ in New York.
On the night of May 28, 2022, John Umberger was drugged at 'The Q,' a popular LGBTQ+ club. He was then brought back to the townhouse where he was robbed and where he eventually died due to the substances used to incapacitate him, as uncovered by the NYPD investigation into his death.
Clary Umberger alleges in her suit that she received a call from Jordan Sekulow, ACLJ's Executive Director, on June 1, 2022, telling her that John's body had been found but there was "no foul play." She alleges he told her, "It was as if John was sitting on his bed to tie his shoes and died."
According to Clary Umberger, she then received a call from the NYPD, who indicated that Jordan had been asked not to call her at that time. The suit then states: "The statements made by Jordan Sekulow indicate that he had been aware of John's death" and "had an opportunity to do some initial investigation."
The suit further states that the "Defendants in fact knew about John's death prior to June 1, 2022" and that Clary Umberger "subsequently learned that John's company health insurance had been canceled by Defendants on May 31, 2022, then reinstated on June 1, and then canceled again later that day."
"That sequence suggests that Defendants learned of John's death by May 31 and acted to cancel his insurance, only to realize that they should wait until it was "official." "
The suit makes several other allegations against the defendants, saying they had hidden the whereabouts of Umberger's laptop, that they had insisted Umberger had gone out in Brooklyn the night he died despite evidence to the contrary, and that the NYPD told Clary Umberger the defendants had been "extremely uncooperative, and that their conduct had impeded the investigation of John's death."
Jay Sekulow led Trump's legal team during his first impeachment and has a history of legal activism against LGBTQ+ causes, including sending an amicus brief to the Supreme Court in 2002 to argue against the landmark gay sex case Lawrence v. Texas, which decriminalized same-sex intimacy.
Rich Schoenstein, one of Clary Umberger's lawyer's told Newsweek that this case was brought three years after John Umberger's murder because "we were awaiting the conviction and sentencing of the two perpetrators before commencing civil litigation."
What People Are Saying
Linda Clary Umberger's lawsuit: "In all, the actions of Defendants ranged from unhelpful to hostile. It appears from their conduct that Defendants were primarily interested in keeping the matter quiet, not wishing to draw public attention to the fact that they had spent $16.5 million – presumably raised from donors – to purchase New York City real estate and not wishing to draw public attention to the fact that they had employed a gay man who had been murdered. They were hoping the matter would be quickly and quietly resolved."
Rich Schoenstein, one of Linda Clary Umberger's lawyers, told Newsweek: "The litigation speaks for itself, and we intend to pursue the matter vigorously in court."
Michael Bowe, an attorney who represents Jay and Jordan Sekulow, told Newsweek: "The murder of John Umberger was tragic and a huge loss of a very talented and good young man who ACLJ was honored to have as a colleague. The complaint's allegations against ACLJ are demonstrably untrue, which will become clear as the case proceeds."
What Happens Next
The case states that the Defendants have 20 days to answer the Complaint and to serve a copy of their answer.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines