
...
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Christmas Eve in America, and the best gift at many gas stations is the sign out front: prices that feel almost retro by recent standards. AAA says the national average slipped back under three dollars this month and hovered there this week—about $2.85 on December 22 and $2.86 on December 23. It’s a curious backdrop for a country that, on paper, is humming: economic growth running at a 4.3 percent in the third quarter, the fastest in two years and well ahead of expectations. And yet the national mood is closer to a sigh than a cheer. The Conference Board’s consumer-confidence gauge has slid for months, landing at 89.1 in December, with its "expectations" index stuck around 70—below the Board’s own recession-warning line at 80. The disconnect—cheap gas, strong growth, sour sentiment—raises a question: if the "Trump boom" is real, why aren't so many Americans feeling it? The answer lies in how those gains are spread across the economy, and it might not be where you think.
Common Knowledge
The administration of President Donald Trump says tariffs plus an investment surge equal a roaring economy. "Get ready for Trump’s 5% economy," said Larry Kudlow, the Fox Business host and former Trump economic adviser. White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett called the latest growth report "fantastic."
Read More on News
Skeptics on the right warn of political blowback. National Review’s Noah Rothman has said that "Trump’s tariffs are consigning the GOP to an epochal electoral disaster," pointing to a steady erosion in the president’s numbers.
From Trump opponents, the pushback is even blunter. Dean Baker, senior economist at the Center for Economic and Policy Research, called Trump’s victory laps "utterly divorced from reality," noting that plenty of households still feel squeezed. And the polling is chilly: an AP-NORC survey this month found only about three in 10 Americans approving of Trump’s handling of the economy—down from about four in 10 in March.
Uncommon Knowledge
What’s actually happening—and why doesn’t it feel better? The economy grew at its fastest since 2023’s lull. That alone would usually lift spirits. But confidence has sagged for five straight months, and the nonpartisan Conference Board flags worries about jobs, prices and, unusually, trade policy. People don’t trust the good news because the costs they live with every day—rents, car payments, grocery bills—still feel high, and they’re not sure their paychecks are stretching far enough.
Here's the twist. A surprisingly large share of this year’s growth has come from a narrow slice of the economy: the new internet. Think data-center construction, racks of specialized chips, cloud software, and the plumbing that makes artificial intelligence possible. Barron’s totted up those categories and found them punching well above their weight—roughly 14 percent of the third quarter’s real GDP gain, even though they make up a far smaller slice of overall output. Harvard’s Jason Furman, a former chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President Barack Obama, has made a similar point: strip out data-center and information-processing investment and growth earlier in the year looks close to flat. In other words, a handful of server farms and software budgets are doing work that, in past cycles, was spread across factories, malls and office parks.
Trump’s tariffs are the signature of his second term, and the White House credits them for a sturdier mix of growth. Independent modelers see a trade-off: the Penn Wharton Budget Model describes a minimum 10 percent tariff on nearly all imports, with higher rates for dozens of countries, and shows that—over time—this acts like a sales tax on imports, nudging up prices even as it steers investment homeward. That's why consumer surveys now list "tariffs" alongside inflation and jobs as top worries.
Households are undeniably stretched, a situation Democrats have exploited by making "affordability" a central election pitch. The New York Fed reports that a little more than 4 percent of household debt is now somewhere in delinquency, with elevated stress in auto loans for lower-income borrowers. Mortgage rates have eased from their peak but are at 6.21 percent on the standard 30-year fixed as of December 18—much higher than the easy-money era. Even with gas cheaper for the holidays, a lot of budgets still feel one surprise away from wobble.
Inflation is complicated. The CPI release—delayed and stitched around an October data gap after the 43-day shutdown—put headline inflation at 2.7 percent in November, with core cooling. That’s relief, but still above the Fed’s 2 percent target, and not yet enough to erase 2021–22’s jump in household budgets.
This is all reflected in polling. AP-NORC’s December polling shows only a minority giving Trump good grades on the economy, lower than when he returned to office. That doesn’t mean voters deny the data; it means they’re judging by kitchen-table math. The result is the paradox of the season: the economy can grow impressively while the president’s economic marks sink. On Christmas Eve, the "boom" and the "gloom" are both true, depending on where you look and who you ask.
If you’re enjoying Uncommon Knowledge, please share. If you have suggestions for future editions or feedback, email subscriber.feedback@newsweek.com. We want to hear your voice.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines