
...

By Sean O'Driscoll
Senior Crime and Courts Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Conservative Supreme Court Chief Justice, John Roberts, had to speak out after President Donald Trump crossed too many red lines, a former federal prosecutor has said.
Why It Matters
Chief Justice Roberts has sided with Trump in key rulings, most notably the July, 2024 Supreme Court decision that granted Trump broad immunity from prosecution.
Read More
Judge Floats Contempt Charges in ‘Interesting’ Interaction with Trump’s DOJ3 min read

Supreme Court Justice John Roberts Faces MAGA Backlash Over Trump Statement3 min read

Donald Trump Responds to Surprise Rebuke From Justice John Roberts5 min read

However, Roberts' March 18 statement criticising attempts to impeach federal judges signals a new boldness in Robert's criticism of Trump's policies.
Newsweek sought email comment from the offices of Chief Justice Roberts and Attorney General Pam Bondi on Wednesday.

...
What To Know
On March 18, Roberts released a statement through the Supreme Court communications office in which he criticized attempts to impeach judges.
His statement came hours after President Donald Trump urged the removal of a judge, James Boasberg, who put a temporary restraining order in place on Saturday to prevent the deportation of men that the Trump administration states are associates of a Venezuelan street gang.
Roberts said in a statement, "For more than two centuries, it has been established that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision. The normal appellate review process exists for that purpose."
Former federal prosecutor, Joyce Vance, wrote in her legal blog, Civil Discourse, on Tuesday that Roberts was showing great unease with Trump's public statements.
"That seems to be the redline [sic] for the chief justice, the threat of using impeachment in a way the Constitution does not intend," Vance wrote.
"Impeachment is meant as a way to remove a judge who would otherwise have lifetime tenure from the bench if they commit 'high crimes or misdemeanors,' she wrote, quoting from the U.S constitution.
A Past Judicial Impeachment
Vance wrote that Judge Alcee Hasting "was convicted by the Senate after being impeached for soliciting a $150,000 bribe in return for reducing the sentences of two mob-connected felons."
"Impeachment is not meant for a judge who enters a temporary restraining order that the president doesn't like. It's yet another indicator of the Trump administration's abject disregard for the rule of law."
"Every day we need to go through the painful ritual of waking up and reminding ourselves that none of this is normal, that we are living in an America dangerously close to a slide into tyranny," she added.
What People Are Saying
Greg Germain, a law professor at Syracuse University in New York, told Newsweek that Roberts had a duty to speak out.
"I think Roberts, as the chief justice, has a duty to protect the integrity of the judiciary by speaking out against the politicization of the judiciary. Under the Constitution, judges can only be impeached and removed by Congress for high crimes and misdemeanors, not for their rulings."
"Federal judges have life tenure during good behavior to protect them against political influence. If a judge's rulings are wrong, you appeal, you don't impeach," Germain said.
The American Bar Association said in a statement that it "stands firmly" with Roberts in "rejecting inappropriate calls for judicial impeachment."
"Targeting judges personally or threatening to remove them because they rule a certain way has never been acceptable."
"Such efforts are intended to intimidate judges and our courts and weaken public trust and confidence in our judicial system," the ABA added.
What Happens Next
On March 17, Boasberg ordered the Justice Department to provide information on when the Trump administration deported alleged members of a Venezuelan criminal gang at the weekend.
Baosberg received a detailed response on March 18.
He is now reviewing those answers to determine if Trump's immigration officials are in violation of Boasberg's Saturday temporary restraining order, which was put in place to prevent the Venezuelan men's deportation.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines