10

Loading video...

Peter AitkenGabe Whisnant

By Peter Aitken and Gabe Whisnant

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


United States Attorney General Pam Bondi filed an emergency appeal Friday for a stay or court-ordered pause on any criminal contempt of court proceedings for disobeying Judge James Boasberg's order to turn back planes carrying deportees to El Salvador.

On Friday night, a D.C. Circuit Court halted Judge Boasberg's plan for contempt-related proceedings against the Trump administration in the case involving deportations of Venezuelans to an El Salvador prison.

The district judges wrote, "The purpose of this administrative stay is to give the court sufficient opportunity to consider the emergency motion for a stay pending appeal or a writ of mandamus and should not be construed in any way as a ruling on the merits of that motion."

Read More

Trump Admin Declares China ‘Lab Leak’ the True Origins of COVID-195 min read

Trump Admin Declares China ‘Lab Leak’ the True Origins of COVID-19

Steve Bannon Issues Warning Against Donald Trump’s Tax Cuts for Wealthy4 min read

Steve Bannon Issues Warning Against Donald Trump’s Tax Cuts for Wealthy

Trump Admin Releases Previously Classified Kennedy Files: What to Know3 min read

Trump Admin Releases Previously Classified Kennedy Files: What to Know

Why It Matters

Boasberg was appointed as an associate judge on the Superior Court of the District of Columbia in 2002 by President George W. Bush and was later elevated to his current post by President Barack Obama.

Boasberg has remained locked in a legal standoff with the Trump administration over its use of the 1798 Alien Enemies Act, which President Donald Trump invoked to justify mass deportations, sending many people to a megaprison in El Salvador. The dispute has raised questions about presidential authority and the extent to which judicial rulings can limit that authority.

The Trump administration recently argued that it cannot comply with court orders that demand any movement of individuals to or from El Salvador as it infringes on the country's sovereignty, including in the case of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a man mistakenly deported from Maryland.

What To Know

Boasberg wrote on Wednesday that he found probable cause to hold the Trump administration in criminal contempt of court for its use of the 1798 Alien Enemies Act. In his March 15, 2025, ruling, he ordered the administration to stop deportations and to return those who were on flights out of the country. However, administration officials claimed the planes had landed before his ruling took effect.

Boasberg then ordered the administration to provide clear details about the timeline of the deportation operations, including the exact times the planes took off, left U.S. airspace, whether they landed in other countries before their final destinations, and the time of their final arrival.

The administration has insisted that it did not violate the order, but matters took a turn after the Supreme Court ruled that individuals targeted under the Alien Enemies Act have the right to a hearing in federal court before being removed.

Boasberg then wrote that the administration's "actions on that day demonstrate a willful disregard for its Order, sufficient for the Court to conclude that probable cause exists to find the Government in criminal contempt."

In the 27-page appeal Bondi wrote and filed with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, she said: "The District Court cannot constitutionally compel the executive branch to prosecute itself or transfer its prosecutorial powers."

"The district court issued an order to show cause regarding compliance with its TROs [Temporary Restraining Order] and held a hearing on April 3," Bondi wrote. "As the government explained, it had fully complied with the TROs by (i) not removing the named plaintiffs, and (ii) not removing any other class member from United States territory after the second TRO issued."

Pam Bondi speaks florida

...

Bondi repeated the administration's dilemma of attempting to force the president to "persuade or force a foreign sovereign to accede to the court's demand," claiming that the order "unconstitutionally" seeks to compel this action, arguing the court's orders "function like injunctions and are appealable as such."

"Worse, the district court is putting the Executive Branch to these unconstitutional choices to cure a nonexistent case of criminal contempt," Bondi said. "Defendants fully complied with the TROs the district court issued, and certainly did not flout any clear, unambiguous command."

Bondi argued that this amounted to an order of "one of two actions": Either asserting "custody" over an individual already in foreign sovereign custody, or aid the court in efforts to "effectuate a contempt prosecution," and that the order would force the Executive Branch to "prosecute itself," which would potentially violate separation of power.

"The court instructed the government to investigate and identify senior officials responsible for decision-making with respect to the AEA removals—then prosecute them for purportedly disobeying the court's TRO," Bondi wrote.

"Recognizing that the Attorney General is unlikely to prosecute a criminal referral, the court indicated its intent to appoint a private attorney to prosecute the criminal contempt charges. That entire process egregiously intrudes on the Executive Branch's exclusive prosecutorial powers."

One of Bondi's main arguments focuses on the "ambiguous" meaning of "remove" in the original orders, saying that the court has changed its stance from "legal removal (i.e., transferring custody) not physical removal (i.e., removing from U.S. territory," insisting that such a stance is "legally wrong" and "contempt cannot lie based on a supposedly wrong reading of a facially ambiguous order."

"This Court should immediately stay the district court's order and prevent further grave encroachments on the separation of powers," Bondi wrote.

She also appealed to the court to "grant mandamus relief," meaning effectively the higher court would overrule its junior component and end the proceedings outright.

What People Are Saying

The Department of Justice told Newsweek Wednesday: "The Supreme Court ruled that Judge Boasberg has no right to seize control of the President's authority to conduct foreign policy — he should have never issued his order. His underhanded attempt to maintain power over this case is a judicial power grab that the Department of Justice will fight by all means necessary."

Former federal attorney Joyce Vance wrote on Wednesday: "There are a lot of twists and turns ahead. The government is unlikely to agree to prosecute the contempt, but it is almost certain to delay announcing a decision for as long as possible (unless Trump demands it) in order to keep other proceedings from beginning. It's an interesting question—who exactly the judge would hold in contempt?

"It's not clear who gave the order that kept the planes in the air after the judge ordered they be turned around. If the government is smart, it will cure the contempt to avoid that inquiry."

What Happens Next

The appellate court will issue its ruling, which will determine whether the contempt hearing proceeds or is ended immediately. The fight could continue up to the Supreme Court, where the Justices would then weigh in on a delineation of judicial versus executive powers and the limits therein.

Update 4/18/25, 1:41 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.

Update 4/18/25, 7:44 p.m. ET: This article was updated with additional information.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines