10

Loading video...

Amanda Castro

By Amanda Castro

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) on Tuesday broadened its newly announced settlement with President Donald Trump over the leak of his tax returns, issuing an order that shields Trump, his family members and his companies from any past or pending IRS examinations.

The one‑page directive, signed by acting Attorney General Todd Blanche and posted on the DOJ’s website, declares government agencies “forever barred and precluded” from pursuing claims tied to the tax returns filed before the settlement’s effective date.

The expansion goes well beyond the nine‑page agreement unveiled Monday, which created a nearly $1.8 billion Anti‑Weaponization Fund but made no mention of Trump’s long‑running disputes with the IRS. The new order effectively folds those audits into the settlement, granting a sweeping release from federal tax liability for Trump and a wide circle of related individuals, trusts and business entities.

Read More on News

President Donald Trump speaks at a healthcare affordability event in the South Court Auditorium of the White House in Washington, D.C., on Monday. (Photo by Kent Nishimura/AFP via Getty Images)

...

Why Did Trump Sue the IRS?

Trump sued the IRS and the U.S. Treasury Department for $10 billion, alleging the agencies failed to protect his confidential tax information. The lawsuit stemmed from the actions of Charles Littlejohn, a former IRS contractor who admitted to leaking Trump’s tax returns—along with those of thousands of wealthy Americans—to news organizations. Littlejohn later pleaded guilty and was sentenced to five years in prison, but Trump argued that the government bore responsibility for failing to prevent the breach.

Trump, his two oldest sons and the Trump Organization claimed the unauthorized disclosures caused ongoing harm, asserting that each view of a published article containing the leaked data constituted a separate statutory violation. The suit sought massive damages and accused federal agencies of negligence in safeguarding sensitive taxpayer information. The case never reached a courtroom fight as Trump withdrew the lawsuit after reaching an agreement with the DOJ, which created the $1.776 billion Anti‑Weaponization Fund intended to compensate people who say they were improperly targeted by the government.

IRS Settlement With Trump: What It Entails

The announcement came just hours after Trump withdrew his $10 billion lawsuit against the IRS over the leak of his tax returns. In exchange for dropping the case, Trump, Donald Trump Jr., Eric Trump and the Trump Organization will receive a formal apology from the government—but no direct payout. Trump also agreed to abandon separate claims seeking compensation for the FBI’s 2022 search of Mar‑a‑Lago and the investigation into his 2016 campaign’s ties to Russia.

Blanche, formerly Trump’s personal lawyer, said the fund was designed to “make right the wrongs that were previously done,” framing it as a safeguard against future “weaponization” of federal law enforcement.

How the Fund Will Operate

The DOJ set the fund’s value at $1.776 billion, a symbolic nod to the nation’s founding. Blanche’s memo outlining the program spans just over a page and leaves major questions unanswered: It does not define “weaponization,” specify how claims will be evaluated or detail how much money will actually be distributed. A five‑member commission appointed by Blanche will oversee the fund, though Trump can remove any member at will. Claims will be accepted until December 15, 2028, weeks before Trump’s term is set to end.

The money will come from a special DOJ account that allows the department to settle claims without congressional approval—an authority that is already drawing scrutiny on Capitol Hill.

Expert Analysis: What Tax Professionals Say About the DOJ’s Sweeping IRS Bar

Sherman Standberry, one of the country’s most sought‑after CPAs and the CEO of My CPA Coach, told Newsweek the Justice Department’s order barring the IRS from examining any of Trump’s past tax returns is “highly unusual” and unlike anything he has seen in federal tax administration.

Standberry said the prohibition appears tied to the privacy‑breach claims at the center of Trump’s lawsuit, but emphasized that the scope of the release is unprecedented. “I have never seen a blanket release of this magnitude that prohibits the IRS from enforcement actions on prior‑year tax returns,” he said.

From a practical standpoint, Standberry said that the order sharply limits the IRS’ ability to enforce compliance for Trump‑related entities going forward. While the agency can still audit returns filed after the agreement, he said the IRS may be constrained because “tax returns are correlated,” and prior‑year losses or deductions often carry forward. If the tax agency cannot examine the earlier years, its ability to challenge later filings may be weakened.

Standberry also warned that shielding a taxpayer from future examinations could erode public trust. “Protections like these can make the system appear unfair on the surface,” he said, though he added that the settlement also reflects the seriousness of the underlying privacy breach. “No taxpayers should have their sensitive data leaked.”

He said the agreement raises long‑term risks for how future administrations might handle politically sensitive audits, creating “a precedent of IRS protection and room for misuse.” For business owners, he drew a sharp distinction between a routine audit closure—which does not prevent future scrutiny—and a legally binding prohibition like the one Trump received, which “prohibits the IRS from auditing a return for almost any reason.”

Ultimately, Standberry said the case underscores a deeper issue: taxpayer privacy. “Had the IRS protected taxpayer data, this settlement would never have been reached,” he said. “Barring a taxpayer from enforcement essentially releases them from further scrutiny of private data.”

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines