Growler crash s&r operation

...

Hugh CameronChristopher Roberts

By Hugh Cameron and Christopher Roberts

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The official tributes to Lieutenant Commander Lyndsay P. "Miley" Evans and Lieutenant Serena N. "Dug" Wileman, two Navy personnel killed when their combat jet crashed near Mount Rainier last week, were full of praise.

"More than just names and ranks, they were role models, trailblazers, and women whose influence touched countless people on the flight deck and well beyond," the Navy's Carrier Strike Group 2 and Carrier Air Wing 3 said in a statement.

President Joe Biden said the pair, both from California, were "among our nation's finest."

Read More on News

Online, however, some of the responses were less complimentary. Many of them consisted simply of three letters: "DEI"—the abbreviation for diversity, equity and inclusion. Comments on an NBC Facebook post reporting on the two fatalities featured frequent uses of the term. One user wrote, "2 women...DEI strikes again." On X, formerly Twitter, a user shared an article about the pilots and added, "Don't have much confidence in this DEI military."

The implication was clear: Whatever else was to blame for the crash of the EA-18G Growler—which is still being investigated—one culprit was the military's hiring policy, which these social media users believed allowed female pilots to attain positions for which they were not suited.

Growler crash s&r operation

...

This claim, one expert said, is not borne out by the available evidence and is the sort of preconception that leads to aviation being one of the most male-dominated industries in the U.S., with women accounting for about 6 percent of the total workforce.

"It's unfortunate for young women to see these unfounded perceptions," Captain Erin Jackson of the International Society of Women Airline Pilots told Newsweek. "Because many female pilots already feel as though they are under a microscope."

While the data is nuanced, some studies suggest the opposite may be true, and that male pilots are more likely to be involved in an accident or crash.

America's Female Pilots

In the U.S., military efforts to recruit female pilots began in earnest in World War II with the formation of the Women Airforce Service Pilots (WASP) program. More than 1,000 women were trained to fly military aircraft, performing essential duties such as ferrying them to airfields and towing targets.

Nevertheless, the postwar era saw limited opportunities for women in military aviation until 1975, when Chief of Staff of the Air Force General David C. Jones announced a test program that would allow women to enter pilot training. The initiative was part of a broader effort to staff an all-volunteer force following the end of the military draft. The first class of female pilots, known as USAF UPT Class 77-08, earned their silver wings on September 2, 1977.

The real turning point for female pilots came in 1993, when Secretary of Defense Les Aspin directed the military to open combat missions to women, overturning the previous exclusion policy. Jeannie Leavitt became the first female fighter pilot in the U.S. Air Force in 1993. Later, she became the first woman to command a USAF combat fighter wing.

The Crash That Changed Everything

Among the pilots to take advantage of the new policy was Kara Hultgreen, the first female carrier-based fighter pilot in the U.S. Navy. Tragically, she also became the first female fighter pilot in the U.S. military to die in a crash. On October 25, 1994, her F-14 Tomcat plunged into the sea during a final approach to the USS Abraham Lincoln off the coast of San Diego.

Approaching the carrier, Hultgreen found herself overshooting the centerline of the landing deck. She attempted to correct by applying the rudder, which disrupted airflow to the port engine, causing it to suffer a compressor stall. She aborted the approach and applied full afterburner on the remaining engine, worsening the situation by causing the Tomcat to roll even further to the left.

The aircraft was now uncontrollable and her radar intercept officer—the crew member sitting in the back of the two-seat cockpit—ejected safely. Hultgreen's ejection seat fired a split second later, but by that time the Tomcat was rolling onto its back. She was ejected downward into the water and killed instantly. Her body was recovered 19 days later, and she was buried with full military honors at Arlington National Cemetery.

The Diversity Backlash

Though the accident lasted only seconds, its effects lingered for much longer. Critics questioned Hultgreen's suitability as a combat jet pilot. They scrutinized her training record, which showed her failing her first carrier qualification attempt. Navy officials said at the time that about 25 percent of pilots failed their first attempt.

In a 1995 letter to Republican Senator Strom Thurmond, Elaine Donnelly, the president of the Center for Military Readiness, wrote: "In their haste to get women into combat billets as soon as possible, Navy leaders have denied unit commanders the tools they need to make integration workable. Lt. Kara Hultgreen was an F-14 pilot with limited abilities who, had she been a male, would arguably never have graduated to the fleet."

The Navy responded by producing records showing that Hultgreen was an above-average pilot, and that engine failure, not pilot error, was to blame. A fellow F-14 pilot later said the squadron's male executive officer, when faced with the same flight issues in a simulator, crashed 97 percent of the time.

Lloyd Austin

...

Still, doubts among critics about the fairness and suitability of military hiring programs persisted. The Navy, other arms of the military and the Department of Defense, however, repeatedly stressed their commitment to improving gender diversity.

In 2023, Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin made this clear at an event marking the 75th anniversary of the Women's Armed Services Integration Act, which allowed women to serve as regular members of the Army, Navy, Air Force and Marine Corps. Austin said greater female participation was essential to maintain American military primacy.

"The only way to make that happen is by drawing on the talents of all of our people, and not just men—who happen to represent less than half of the U.S. population," he said.

What the Data Says About Female Pilots

Most studies, including data from the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), do not specifically focus on crashes by the pilots' gender, but earlier studies by aviation safety organizations and research bodies have painted a picture, albeit a complex one, of the relationship between aircraft accidents and pilot gender.

One 2013 study looked at accident rates among Army helicopter pilots. The study, titled "Women in Combat Arms: A Study of the Global War on Terror," was written by Army Major Seneca Peña-Collazo while he was at the School of Advanced Military Studies at the Army's Command and General Staff College at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas.

The study found that female helicopter pilots had fewer accidents than their male counterparts. It found that women, who made up 10 percent of Army helicopter pilots, were involved in 3 percent of the accidents. The data indicated that accidents involving two-seat AH-64 Apache attack helicopters during the study period involved all-male crews.

The paper didn't suggest a reason for the disparity. However, studies into civilian general aviation—in other words, privately owned aircraft—may offer some clues.

A 2001 study conducted by researchers at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and published in Aviation Space and Environmental Medicine examined NTSB reports on general aviation crashes of airplanes and helicopters between 1983 and 1997.

The study found that most crashes involved some form of pilot error—95 percent for women and 88 percent for men. Loss of control on landing or takeoff was the most common crash circumstance for both sexes, leading to 59 percent of female pilots' crashes and 36 percent of males'. Mechanical failure, running out of fuel, and landing with the gear up were more common among males, while stalling was more frequent among females.

The most common pilot error—mishandling aircraft controls—was more frequent among female pilots (81 percent) than males (48 percent).

Male pilots flying private aircraft in the U.S. were reportedly more likely to crash due to inattention or flawed decision-making, such as flying in bad weather or with known mechanical issues, while female pilots were more prone to crashes from mishandling the aircraft.

The study also found that while female pilots were more likely to lose control of an aircraft, they tended to be more cautious than their male counterparts.

A 1986 study published in Applied Ergonomics that used data from the NTSB—again relating to general aviation—had similar findings. It found that male pilots were 60 percent more likely to have an accident than female pilots. Additionally, male pilots were twice as likely to be involved in fatal accidents.

A 2011 paper published in Accident Analysis and Prevention that focused specifically on aircraft accidents caused by pilot error also came to similar conclusions.

By examining accidents by the pilots' gender and controlling for the level of experience each pilot had, it found no statistically significant difference in the likelihood that errors by male or female pilots would lead to a crash. The study concluded that there was "no evidence" to support the notion that accidents caused by pilot error could be tied to the pilots' gender.

"The percentages of accidents and incidents match almost completely with the percentages of female vs male pilots," Jackson told Newsweek. "Aviation is one of the most highly regulated industries. It doesn't matter the gender or race of an individual, they will receive the highest quality of training and will be required to meet the same exact FAA standards as the next pilot."

Growler

...

Still, the stereotypes persist, forming part of the aviation industry's "culture," which the Federal Aviation Administration's Women in Aviation Advisory Board has urged Congress to address.

According to Jackson, the only way to challenge these preconceptions and the dearth of women piloting U.S. aircraft is to increase the visibility of women in aviation.

The captain said: "A big part of it is, 'You can't be what you can't see.' There are so few of us sitting in these seats that it's so rare that a young girl will see a female pilot and be impacted and inspired to be a pilot herself.

"My own personal story is that when I was a little girl, I was always fascinated with the sky, airplanes, and weather. When I was 13 years old, I got to ride in the Goodyear Blimp, and one of the pilots was a woman. That was the first time it clicked for me that it was something I could actually do."

Do you have a story we should be covering? Do you have any questions about this article? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.

Update 10/23/24, 12:24 p.m. ET: This article was updated to include comments from the International Society of Women Airline Pilots.

Update 10/24/24, 05:59 a.m. ET: This article was updated to include additional context.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines