10
Loading video...

By Sean O'Driscoll
Senior Crime and Courts Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
It was "arbitrary and capricious" of the U.S. government to exempt genetically modified crops from safety regulations, a federal judge has ruled.
The ruling by San Francisco-based James Donato is a major setback for the multibillion genetically modified crop industry, which had lobbied to be excluded from the rules.
The case was taken against agriculture secretary, Tom Vilsack by the National Family Farm Coalition and others opposed to genetically modified crops.
Read More
The FDA Just Quietly Gutted Protections for Human Subjects in Research | Opinion6 min read

New Fake Meat ‘Mold’ Burger Might Be on the Horizon3 min read

Global Pesticide Ban Is Only Way To Stop Us From a Health Epidemic Nightmare | Opinion5 min read


...
Newsweek sought email comment from the Department of Agriculture on Friday.
Donato, who was nominated by President Barack Obama, demolished the Agriculture Department's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service's (APHIS) 'final rule', which mandated that genetically modified crops were exempt from rules that state that all new crops must be tested to make sure they do not become weeds that spread to other farms.
Donato ruled that the "undisputed evidence" establishes that some of the farmers taking the case, namely Peter Baumer, Darvin Bentlage, and Jonathan Krohn, are organic or non-GE [Genetically Engineered] farmers and, if the rules aren't changed, "the risk that those members' farms will experience incidents of transgenic contamination increases beyond a reasonable probability."
"Specifically, one farmer says that his non-GE farm is near several GE farms, which will require measures to stave off contamination and the others anticipate incurring greater costs for non-GE seeds," Donato noted.
In his ruling, Donato said that such harms were "sufficiently concrete to establish injury-in-fact" in another case involving the genetically engineered company, Monsanto.
"The same goes in this lawsuit," he ruled.
Donato said that the Department of Agriculture should have incorporated its noxious weed authority into plans to govern genetically modified crops, to assess if any genetically modified crops were spreading as weeds to other farms.
"The final rule is vacated as of the date of this order and is remanded to APHIS for reconsideration consistent with this order," he wrote.
He added that summary judgment is granted to plaintiffs on the claim "that it was arbitrary and capricious for APHIS to not incorporate its noxious-weed authority in the final rule."
Reviewing the history of the case, he stated that in 2004, the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service announced it would revisit regulations governing genetically engineered organisms.
That concluded in a final rule the agency adopted in May 2020.
"Plaintiffs, who are nonprofit and public-interest groups organized around concerns for farmers, crops, food safety, and the environment, object to the final rule. In plaintiffs' view, the final rule effectively abandoned federal government regulation of GE organisms, leaving GE crop developers and agribusinesses to their own devices without adequate safety and other oversight," Donato noted.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines