10
Loading video...

By Emily Suttle-Braun
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
I was in the room in Denver last week when protesters shouted down House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries during his conversation with Jessica Tarlov at the What's Next conference, and I left feeling pretty disturbed.
This was 10 days after Democrats won the House and the Senate, at a conference about what we do with those majorities. A young woman stood up and said she was scared for her future and wanted to know when Democrats would deliver the Green New Deal and Medicare for All. Then a man called Jeffries a liar, a traitor and an oligarch in the middle of an answer about health care and kept yelling while security walked him out. Another accused him of taking private equity money instead of fighting for the people.
On Wednesday, House Democrats overwhelmingly nominated Jeffries for speaker, 251 to 11, and nobody ran against him. My mind is still in Denver, because I think this kind of infighting is going to cost us in 2028.
Read More on Opinion

...
This isn't a defense of Jeffries. Nobody is entitled to that job, and if you have issues with his record, push on them. There is a place for protest, including uncomfortable protest. That young woman was holding him accountable. Plenty of the voters who just gave us Congress share her fear, and they weren't all moderates.
Interrupting his answer to call him a traitor is something else entirely. Our Constitution defines treason as levying war against the United States or giving aid and comfort to its enemies. Without evidence, I don't see what throwing that word at Jeffries accomplishes beyond embarrassing him and Tarlov. I'm increasingly concerned that we're confusing confrontation with courage and public humiliation with accountability.
If you want to see courage, look at Tarlov. She’s spent years going into hostile territory on Fox News' The Five, making the case for Democrats to people who don't agree with her, and in March the president called in to her own show to say it would be better without her. That's difficult, often thankless work and, frankly, we need more people willing to do it.
We just had a blue tsunami, the likes of which I personally have never witnessed. Democrats now hold a majority of governorships for the first time since 2010, and we won Congress because progressives, moderates and independents who don't agree with each other on much all voted the same way.
2028 will be the first open Democratic primary since 2020, it's going to be crowded, and I can already see people treating the next two years as an audition. If the way to stand out is to be the loudest person calling other Democrats traitors, we'll end up with purity tests and a nominee who's been torn apart by our own side before the general election even starts.
This kind of brawling with family on the front lawn is exactly the kind of dysfunction Republicans can benefit from. Within a day, the clip from Denver was running on Fox News, Breitbart and the Daily Wire. We'll keep handing them footage for the next two years if this is how we handle disagreement.
I'm all for challenging leadership, but what are we actually accomplishing? Are we changing minds, building power or moving policy, or just performing outrage for people who already agree with us? The things that move a member of Congress are pretty boring: co-sponsor lists, organized constituents and a primary challenger, if it comes to that. Jeffries has promised to reverse the Medicaid cuts, extend the Affordable Care Act tax credits and ban congressional stock trading. Hold him to it.
Eleven Democrats voted against him. Seven incoming members said in a statement they'd seen "meaningful progress" in their talks with Jeffries but there's still work to do on Medicare for All, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, campaign finance and Gaza. That's how you hold a leader accountable, and nobody had to call anyone a traitor to do it.
I also worry that when political movements become consumed with attacking their own, they leave less time and energy for confronting the institutions and abuses of power that allow authoritarianism to grow. Imagine what we could accomplish if we didn't have to be consumed by corruption and could conceive of a legislative agenda that supports the poorest, hungriest and most vulnerable in our country. In January, Democrats get the committee gavels and subpoena power to do that. I'd rather we spend the next two years using them.
There has to be room for disagreement without turning everyone into an enemy. We're going to need a much bigger coalition than the people who agree with us on everything if we want to repair the damage of the last decade. A broad coalition just won us Congress. The House Democrats just aligned behind a leader. If we spend the next two years shouting at each other instead of delivering, we just hand Republicans their comeback in 2028.
Emily Suttle-Braun is founder and CEO of Mend Political.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines