
0.cached.png
By David Ansen
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Sensational subjects are a dime a dozen in television movies. Rare as gold is the hot topic that actually gets transformed into a great movie. The Boys of St. Vincent, a three-hour film made in Canada, is as intense, as psychologically complex, as artful as any film you'll see on a big or little screen this year. And none of the networks, which pride themselves on controversial topics, would touch it. (A&E will broadcast it in two parts on Feb. 19 and 20.) It deals with the sexual and physical abuse of young boys in a Catholic orphanage in St. John's, Newfoundland. It's a fiction, but its unmistakable resemblance to actual events in Newfoundland could not have pleased the church. The original Canadian broadcast in 1992 was blacked out in Ontario and parts of Quebec. (A similar case was being tried, and it was argued that the movie might influence the outcome.) One of the subjects of this harrowing work is how the Catholic Church, conspiring with government officials, covers up the crimes of its offending priests. Above all, the institution must be protected, even at the expense of the children who suffer inside the orphanage walls.
Director John N. Smith's movie, which he wrote with Des Walsh and Sam Grana, starts in 1975. Presiding over St. Vincent's is the young, stiffly handsome Brother Lavin (Henry Czerny), who has singled out the beautiful 10-year-old Kevin Reevey (Johnny Morina) to be his special boy. After Kevin attempts to escape, we discover (in one of several scenes unfortunately truncated for American viewers) just how aberrant is the love Brother Lavin feels toward his charge, and how quickly that love can turn to rage. When Kevin refuses to call him Mama, he beats him savagely with his belt. He's not the only molester: there's the odious, pudgy Brother Glackin, perched like a vulture on the boys' cots at night. Part One bears an inevitable resemblance to a Dickensian horror film, but it handles its explosive subject with tact and understatement. When a janitor discovers the battered Kevin, he alerts the police, and the ugly secrets of St. Vincent's begin to leak out. But St. Vincent's has powerful protectors, and a need to hush things up if they want to get a grant for a new hockey rink. Though Lavin and some other guilty brothers are removed, they are never charged with any crimes.
""The Boys of St. Vincent'' gets the blood boiling, but it's much more than an expose. In the more complex, even more powerful Part Two, the story is picked up 15 years later. The case is reopened and Lavin, now married and the father of two boys, is brought back to face charges. The children are now in their 20s, their psychic wounds unhealed, their lives deformed. An American TV movie would focus on the courtroom drama, the triumph of delayed justice. Smith goes after deeper, harsher truths; for one boy, reliving the experience at the trial proves fatal. And we are forced to look at the monstrous Lavin in a different light. Earlier we viewed him through the children's eyes; now we have the shock of seeing him as he sees himself. Czerny's portrait of this twisted, angry man is one of the most complex depictions of evil on film. We don't forgive him, but we gain a shred of comprehension. You may find yourself holding your breath through much of ""The Boys of St. Vincent.'' It's a shock to see this level of emotional honesty on TV.
Read More on News
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines