10

Loading video...

Amanda Greenwood

By Amanda Greenwood

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A tiny object hurtling around the Sun is becoming the focus of an unusual scientific debate, with researchers proposing explanations ranging from an extremely fast-spinning asteroid to a "dark comet" and even a long-lost Soviet spacecraft.

The object, known as 1998 KY26, was discovered by astronomer Tom Gehrels on May 28, 1998, during a routine observing session for the University of Arizona's Spacewatch project at Kitt Peak in Arizona. Early radar and telescope observations led scientists to estimate it was about 30 meters across and spun on its axis once every 10.7 minutes.

More recent observations, however, have changed that picture. Research led by Toni Santana-Ros, an astronomer at the University of Alicante who is also affiliated with the University of Barcelona's Institute of Cosmos Sciences (ICCUB), found that 1998 KY26 is only about 11 meters across, and completes a rotation roughly every 5.35 minutes, making it both smaller and faster-spinning than was previously believed.

Read More on News

Newsweek has reached out to Santana-Ros for comment.

The mystery is being fueled by another unusual finding: something appears to be giving 1998 KY26 a tiny extra push as it travels through space. Usually, escaping gas and dust can push a comet in this way, but astronomers haven’t detected the telltale cloud or tail they would normally expect.

Those observations, combined with new research questioning whether the object could contain ice, have fueled conflicting ideas over what 1998 KY26 actually is.

Theory One: A Dark Comet

One of the most intriguing explanations is that 1998 KY26 belongs to a relatively recently recognized group of objects known as “dark comets.”

In simple terms, a normal comet contains ice that warms as it approaches the Sun. The ice turns into gas and escapes, carrying dust with it, producing the classic fuzzy cloud and tail usually seen with comets. As explained above, the escaping material can also give the comet a tiny extra push, changing the speed and direction of its movement through space.

Starfield with Comet Lovejoy

...

Dark comets appear to receive this extra push, but without displaying an obvious tail or cloud.

A study led by Bryce T. Bolin examined 1998 KY26 using two powerful telescopes in Hawaii, Keck I and Gemini North. He found that something was giving the object an unusual extra push, but found no evidence of the dust cloud normally associated with a comet.

Bolin and his colleagues said that its unusual motion might be because it’s spinning so fast that small pieces of material are being flung from its surface, giving the object a small extra push as it travels through space.

Newsweek has reached out to Bolin for comment.

Theory Two: The Lost Soviet Phobos 1 Probe

A far more controversial possibility is that 1998 KY26 isn’t a natural object at all.

Abraham Loeb, an astronomer at Harvard University, and researchers Adam Hibberd and Adam Crowl have investigated whether it could actually be Phobos 1, a Soviet probe launched toward Mars in July 1988.

Phobos 1 stopped communicating with Earth after an incorrect command was sent to the spacecraft roughly two months after launch. The researchers compared the paths of Phobos 1 and 1998 KY26 and found that they could potentially be the same object, or at least be linked in some way.

Loeb exclusively told Newsweek that he saw three particularly interesting clues.

"The orbit of 1998 KY26 is very close to that of the Russian probe Phobos 1," he said, adding that another clue is the object's unexplained motion. "1998 KY26 showed a non-gravitational push away from the Sun with no detectable shedding of gas or dust as expected from the rocket effect of a comet."

Loeb said his team found the acceleration and changes in brightness could instead be explained by sunlight reflecting from Phobos 1 and its solar panels.

However, the Phobos 1 proposal remains a hypothesis, rather than confirmation that the object is definitely the missing Soviet spacecraft.

Theory Three: A Tiny, Fast-Spinning Asteroid

View of asteroid 243 Ida taken about 3-1/2 minutes before the Galileo spacecraft made its closest approach to the asteroid in 1993

...

There is also a much more conventional possibility: 1998 KY26 is simply just an unusual asteroid.

Santana-Ros combined observations from powerful telescopes with radar data to produce a much clearer picture of the object. This helped establish that it rotates once in approximately 5.35 minutes.

That speed matters.

A loosely assembled asteroid made from rocks and debris could struggle to remain intact while spinning so quickly, meaning KY26 may instead be a strong, compact piece of rock.

Bolin's study also supports the asteroid theory. As mentioned earlier, observations from the Keck and Gemini telescopes suggested that 1998 KY26 has a surface similar to a type of asteroid known as an Xe-type.

The team's proposed explanation is that its extraordinary rotation could be throwing material from its surface, potentially explaining the mysterious extra push.

Theory Four: A Dried-Out Object That's Lost Its Ice

The latest twist comes from research by Korbin Hansen and Masatoshi Hirabayashi at Georgia Tech.

Their work asked a straightforward question: Could 1998 KY26 actually keep enough water ice inside itself to behave like a dark comet?

The researchers constructed a three-dimensional computer model showing how heat from the Sun could move through the tiny object's surface and interior as it travels around the Sun.

The results indicated that the object is simply too warm for buried water ice to survive for long periods. If it once contained ice, the research suggests that the water would’ve escaped into space over time, leaving behind a water-depleted rocky body.

While this doesn’t establish what is causing the unexplained acceleration, it does raise questions about whether escaping water vapor could explain the mysterious extra push affecting 1998 KY26.

Newsweek has also contacted Hansen for comment.

Why Is Everyone Talking About It Now?

The renewed interest is largely the result of several developments arriving together.

New observations have transformed astronomers' picture of KY26, revealing that it’s far smaller, faster-spinning, and more reflective than earlier estimates suggested.

The Bolin team's observations have given researchers new information about its composition and lack of visible dust, while Hansen's newly published work raises fresh questions over whether buried water ice can survive at all.

At the same time, the provocative Phobos 1 hypothesis has given scientists a radically different explanation to test.

Most importantly, humans are eventually expected to get a much closer look.

This picture taken on August 31, 2014 shows the new asteroid explorer "Hayabusa-2" during the space probe's unveiling for the press by JAXA, at Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) facility in Sagamihara, suburban Tokyo.

...

Japan's space agency, JAXA, has sent its Hayabusa2 spacecraft on an “extended mission” to 1998 KY26, with a rendezvous scheduled for 2031. Hayabusa2 previously visited the asteroid Ryugu, collected samples there, and returned them to Earth in 2020 before embarking on its extended journey. JAXA describes 1998 KY26 as its new target destination and specifically notes that it’s “rapidly rotating.”

Loeb predicts the visit could settle the dispute in dramatic fashion.

"My alternative prediction is that when they land on it and study the properties of what they regard to be a mysterious iceberg that has invisible gas coming from it, they will find out instead the label: 'Made in the U.S.S.R.' on it," he told Newsweek.

That’s very much Loeb's prediction, rather than the current scientific conclusion. For now, observations favor interpretations involving an unusual natural object, and the exact explanation for its motion remains under investigation.

But unlike many astronomical mysteries that can only be studied from millions of miles away, scientists already have a spacecraft heading toward this one. If Hayabusa2 successfully reaches 1998 KY26 in 2031, the tiny object should finally have much less room to hide its identity.

Newsweek’s reporters and editors used Martyn, our AI assistant, to produce this story. Learn more about Martyn here.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Tobias Meyjes and Emma Lee-Sang

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines