10

Loading video...

Anna Commander

By Anna Commander

News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


New York Judge Maxwell Wiley dismissed Daniel Penny's manslaughter charge on Friday, which legal analyst and attorney Jonathan Turley says is "precisely" what Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg was hoping for.

Penny, a 26-year-old former U.S. Marine, faced manslaughter and criminal negligent homicide charges in the death of Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old homeless man who performed as a street artist. In May 2023, Neely, who was Black, was placed in a chokehold by the veteran from Long Island, who is white, after yelling at other passengers about being hungry in a crowded subway car in New York City.

Witnesses said Neely proclaimed that he didn't care if he lived or died and that he wanted to return to jail. Penny and some others said they heard him say he was also ready to kill. Penny, who was already on the train when Neely boarded, approached him from behind and put him in a chokehold. Several minutes of the altercation were caught on bystander video and was a key piece of evidence in the trial.

Read More on U.S.

The jury can now only consider the criminally negligent homicide charge, per the judge's instructions. The negligent homicide charge carries a maximum of four years in prison.

Prosecutors say that Penny's chokehold is what ultimately killed Neely. However, Penny's defense team's pathologist said that Neely died from a combination of using synthetic marijuana, schizophrenia, the altercation with Penny and a genetic condition.

Penny's lawyers also urge that he was protecting citizens in the subway from Neely.

Daniel Penny

...

In a Friday post to X, formerly Twitter, Turley, a professor at George Washington University Law School, wrote, "So now the judge has dismissed the first count on second-degree manslaughter and is allowing the jury to consider the second count after the weekend. This is precisely what Bragg was hoping for in setting up a possible compromise verdict..."

Turley, in his opinion, added that this case would not have been tried outside New York City. Turley said that he's "hopeful" that there could be jurors unwilling to find Penny guilty on the lesser charge but "the treatment of Penny will leave chilling message for New York thinking of protecting others in New York."

Concluding his thread on X, the legal analyst said: "Bragg often seems to be driven more by cable news than the criminal code. He has made clear that citizens acting to protect others can expect little support from his office."

Newsweek has reached out to the Manhattan district attorney's office via email for comment on Friday.

In a follow up email to Newsweek on Friday afternoon, Turley said, "The judge had the discretion to declare a hung jury. However, after dismissing the first count, the jury can now render a compromise verdict. It is a very different case now than the one that was tried before them. It is a second bite at the apple for Bragg."

Meanwhile, Penny's lawyers previously told Newsweek: "Waiting as a jury deliberates is never easy when your client's freedom hangs in the balance. Despite the anxiety inherent in the deliberation process, we remain confident that the jury, having heard the evidence, will return a full acquittal."

The case has elicited nationwide attention and conservatives like Meghan McCain, daughter to late Republican Senator John McCain, and House Speaker Mike Johnson have sided with Penny.

Johnson, a Louisiana Republican, posted to X on Friday about the case saying in part, "Daniel Penny's actions were heroic & protected the lives of people on that train." He added: "Good to see this charge dismissed. Pray the second one is as well."

Meanwhile, Representative Ritchie Torres, a New York Democrat, previously said in 2023 on X that "there was no justification for choking him to death," speaking about Neely.

"Daniel Penny has been charged with manslaughter and should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law," Torres also wrote.

Update 12/6/24 5:11 p.m. ET: This story was updated with additional background.

Update 12/6/24 6:04 p.m. ET: This story was updated with additional information.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines