A happy father getting congratulations from his young kids.

...

Daniella Gray

By Daniella Gray

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A dad of three has sparked debate online after explaining why he ditched what he believed was "gentle parenting" in favor of a firmer, consequence‑based approach at home.

In a detailed post on Threads, Vivek (@therealvivekiyer) wrote that he had stopped using "100% of ‘gentle parenting’ tactics" and returned to a structured, three‑tier system of consequences, arguing that "a house without clear, firm boundaries creates anxious, entitled children."

Vivek’s system is built around calm, predictable consequences. Tier one starts with a clear warning and two choices. Tier two introduces a logical consequence tied directly to the behavior.

Read More on Family & Parenting

View on Threads

Tier three adds repair work and a bigger loss of privilege, such as chores or a screen‑free evening. Alongside this, his family follows five non‑negotiable house rules, including listening the first time and using "kind hands and a kind voice."

Vivek also outlined what he stopped doing—bribes, empty threats, long lectures during meltdowns and endless negotiating—while stressing that he did not abandon empathy. "You’re not in trouble for the feeling. The consequence is for the action," is one of the phrases he now uses consistently.

The 40-year-old, who has two sons and a daughter with his partner Sim, told Newsweek the confusion between gentle and permissive parenting played a major role in his shift.

"Lots of parents…think being gentle means you never say no or you let your kids do whatever they want," Vivek said. "That’s actually permissive parenting. Gentle parenting is supposed to be about respecting your children while still having rules and boundaries, but, somewhere along the way, I think I got confused, too. I was trying so hard to be kind and understanding that I forgot my kids also need me to be the parent in charge."

The turning point came during a seemingly small moment at home. After repeatedly asking his child to stop jumping on the couch, explaining the danger "nicely and firmly" multiple times, nothing changed.

"I said it probably 10 times," Vivek said. "And my child just looked at me and kept jumping, like I wasn’t even there. In that moment, I realized my child didn’t actually believe I would do anything about it. I had taught my child that my words didn’t really matter because nothing would happen if they ignored me."

Since introducing clearer boundaries, Vivek said the change has been noticeable. His children listen more quickly, mornings are calmer, and bedtime battles have eased. "Kids actually feel safer when they know the rules don’t move," he added. "Our whole house feels more peaceful."

The post quickly went viral, drawing thousands of comments. Although Vivek initially described his approach as scrapping "gentle parenting," many Threads users pointed out that what he was describing was closer to permissive parenting.

Vivek later acknowledged the mistake, writing: "There was indeed a typo…I really did mean I stopped ‘permissive parenting,’ not ‘gentle parenting’."

Many parents also said they felt seen and relieved, telling Vivek his honesty gave them permission to be firmer without guilt.

Others pushed back, accusing him of misunderstanding gentle parenting or becoming too strict.

"Some people said I’m giving up on gentle parenting too quickly or that I’m being too strict now," Vivek said. "Some people said I never understood gentle parenting in the first place. A few people were quite mean about it, to be honest. That part was hard to read."

Stock image: a happy father gets congratulations from his young kids.

...

Dr. Aaron Montgomery, a clinical psychologist and founder of a Newport Beach‑based child and family practice, told Newsweek that confusion between gentle and permissive parenting is common because both emphasize warmth, but differ in how much structure they provide.

Montgomery explained that validating a child’s emotions does not require removing limits. "A parent can say, ‘I understand how you feel’ and still maintain a limit or boundary for the child," Montgomery said. "When provided together, these support the development of self-regulation."

By contrast, permissive parenting keeps the warmth but relaxes expectations—often out of guilt or a desire to avoid conflict. Over time, this can reduce a child’s frustration tolerance and increase emotional escalation, leaving parents more exhausted and more likely to further loosen boundaries.

"Children don’t benefit from an absence of stress," Montgomery added. "They benefit from learning how to function effectively within stressful situations. That’s how resilience, internal control and self‑discipline develop."

For Vivek, he is learning to pay attention to what his kids really want. When they are overwhelmed, tired or scared, he slows down and focuses on emotional support instead. He added: "Being a good parent means being strong when kids need structure, but also being flexible when kids need something else."

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines