Shannon Ullman

By Shannon Ullman

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Carnival changed how cruisers earn and keep status in September 2026, replacing a system based on days sailed with one tied to spending. For longtime passengers, the change means more than learning a new points system. It can mean having to requalify for recognition they spent years earning.

“For many cruisers, reaching a certain loyalty level was a point of pride,” Doug Parker, executive producer of Cruise Radio and Cruise News Today tells Newsweek. “Now, maintaining that status requires meeting new spending requirements. That hasn't sat well with some of Carnival's most loyal customers.”

But elite status isn’t getting harder across the board. Royal Caribbean Group now lets passengers direct newly earned loyalty points to a preferred sister brand, while Princess still counts completed cruises or cruise days. Understanding what’s changing—and which benefits you actually use—can help you decide whether staying loyal makes sense.

Read More on Business

What Does Carnival’s Loyalty Overhaul Mean for Cruisers?

Carnival Rewards replaced the VIFP Club on Sept. 1, 2026. The program separates redeemable points, which can go toward future cruises and eligible onboard experiences, from Status Qualifying Stars, which determine your tier.

Members earn three stars per dollar on eligible Carnival purchases. Platinum requires 50,000 stars and Diamond requires 100,000. The first qualification window runs through Dec. 31, 2028; subsequent qualification windows generally last two years. Casino activity and the Carnival Rewards Mastercard provide additional ways to earn stars.

That gives travelers who spend more a different route to status than those who accumulate nights on inexpensive fares. Redeemable points may offer more immediate value to occasional cruisers, while lifetime days sailed still count toward separate milestone recognition.

Parker says a recurring complaint from longtime Carnival passengers is that the new program makes loyalty feel temporary.

“At the end of the day, it's becoming less about how long you've been loyal to a brand and more about how much money you spend with it,” he says.

Existing members do have transition protections. Guests who earned VIFP Diamond by Aug. 31, 2026, receive lifetime Carnival Rewards Diamond status after enrolling. Those who held VIFP Platinum receive Platinum through Dec. 31, 2028, after enrolling, plus a 10,000-star boost at the start of each new two-year earning cycle. That boost provides Gold status and a head start toward a higher tier. Eligible former Platinum and Diamond members must enroll before the end of 2028 to receive the full transition treatment, subject to Carnival’s data-retention policies.

Before booking another cruise to pursue status, check that you’ve enrolled and confirm the tier and qualification dates shown in your account.

Are Cruise Elite Tiers Becoming Harder to Earn?

The changes vary by line. Earning a tier, keeping it and having another cruise line recognize it are three separate questions.

The growing number of options also creates more homework for passengers.

“Passengers now have to pay closer attention to spending requirements, expiration dates and how benefits transfer between brands,” Parker says.

Cross-brand recognition can make trying another line more appealing, but Parker cautions that it doesn’t necessarily make the trip affordable. A Norwegian passenger who receives recognition on Regent still has to decide whether a luxury cruise fits their budget.

“Just because someone has earned status with Norwegian doesn't necessarily mean they're ready to spend considerably more to sail with Regent,” he says.

Can Status Matching Make Switching Cruise Lines Worthwhile?

Parker says some frustrated Carnival passengers are treating the overhaul as a reason to explore competing brands, particularly those offering status matching.

MSC, for example, accepts applications to match eligible status from other cruise lines and hotel programs to a comparable Voyagers Club tier. Approval can give a traveler benefits on their first MSC sailing instead of requiring them to start at the entry level. Check the applicable terms and confirm your approved tier before counting on specific perks.

“For occasional cruisers, that can provide more immediate value than spending years working toward a higher loyalty tier,” Parker says.

Within Royal Caribbean Group, status matching and Points Choice serve different purposes. Matching provides corresponding tier recognition across Royal Caribbean, Celebrity and Silversea. Points Choice lets eligible members decide which participating program receives points earned from an eligible sailing. Requests must be submitted before the cruise or within 14 days after it ends.

Neither option guarantees identical benefits across brands. Compare what the receiving line actually offers at your recognized tier.

Is Cruise Loyalty Still Worth It?

For travelers who cruise once or twice a year, Parker recommends choosing the itinerary, onboard experience and overall value first.

“The loyalty perks should be a bonus rather than the deciding factor,” he says.

For frequent cruisers, the calculation depends more on what the benefits replace. Parker says much of loyalty’s financial value comes from reducing onboard expenses, rather than simply lowering the fare. Laundry, dining and internet benefits are most useful when they cover something you would otherwise buy.

Convenience matters, too, but it can be less predictable. Parker says he has seen sailings with so many upper-tier members that lines couldn’t accommodate everyone with priority boarding.

“It's a reminder that the benefits advertised on paper don't always translate into the same experience onboard,” he says.

There’s also value in familiarity. Parker points to Carnival passengers who look forward to Guy’s Burger Joint or the Alchemy Bar: Enjoying a familiar shipboard experience can be a reason to return, even without a compelling loyalty discount.

Before booking, check your current tier, any qualification or expiration dates and whether the sailing will help you advance or renew. Then compare the full trip cost with a similar cruise on another line, including the extras you expect to purchase.

If staying loyal costs $200 more, ask whether the benefits you’ll use—and the experience you prefer—are worth that difference.

Newsweek has reached out to Carnival Cruise Line for comment.

Contact Newsweek editor on this story: Catherine Clark.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines