
0.cached.png
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
The economy of the United States is at a critical juncture. On the one hand, we have great comparative advantages: our historical embrace of change, our dynamic society, our flexible labor markets, our willingness to take risk and the sheer size of our economy and our economic infrastructure. These strengths are particularly relevant in a time of great change, which we have today with globalization and the new technologies.
On the other hand, the United States also faces complex and consequential challenges.
To start, over the past three years, the fiscal position of the U.S. government has decayed dramatically. In 2001 the Congressional Budget Office projected a $5.6 trillion 10-year surplus. Now Goldman Sachs and most independent analysts project a 10-year deficit of $5 trillion to $5.5 trillion. Adjusting for methodological differences, that represents a deterioration in the 10-year fiscal position of the U.S. government of roughly $9 trillion. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that the 2001 and 2003 tax cuts--if made permanent--will cost roughly $4 trillion over the next 10 years, which puts them at the heart of this long-term fiscal threat.
Read More on News
Fiscal stimulus was an appropriate policy in 2001. But temporary tax cuts, aimed toward people who live week to week and are likely to spend most of any unexpected disposable income, could have achieved all the stimulus we wanted at far less cost, and avoided the great preponderance of the long-term fiscal morass we now face. Moreover, while 10-year numbers are highly unreliable, the likelihood is as great that the deficit will be higher as lower. Beyond 10 years, which is as far as federal budget projections go, the fiscal situation will become all the more difficult with every passing year, as America's post-world-war baby boomers' retirements accelerate.
Some suggest that stronger economic growth than mainstream forecasts project will restore fiscal health. That hope is a highly imprudent basis for fiscal policy--especially since those deficits seriously threaten to undermine growth. Virtually all mainstream economists agree that sustained long-term deficits will crowd out private investment, increase interest rates, reduce productivity and reduce growth. Even more dangerously, if the markets begin to fear long-term fiscal disarray, interest rates for long-term debt could rise sharply, with serious consequences for our economy. Those effects would be exacerbated if foreign providers of the capital inflows, now so critical to us, add to this fear a concern about our currency because of our large current account deficits.
Interest rates have not been materially affected so far, because private-sector demand for capital in the last few years has been so limited. But a change in the private demand for capital--or a change in market psychology--could well turn these risks into reality. Also, the evidence of the early 1990s strongly suggests that prolonged deficits could have serious adverse effects on U.S. business and consumer confidence more generally. A dramatic change in fiscal policy--requiring both parties to come together to make difficult choices--is imperative.
Our enormous current account deficits are a parallel risk. They are now heavily financed by foreign central banks that buy dollars and invest in U.S. Treasury securities in order to promote their exports. This, in effect, is a subsidy that makes imported goods cheaper for us. The risk is that their concerns about our twin budget and current account deficits come to outweigh their desire to push exports. If this happens, our currency could suffer a sharp decline that could further contribute to greatly increasing interest rates. The United States should pursue a strong dollar based on sound policy.
The most effective way to reduce this risk of sharp currency re-adjustments is to re-establish sound fiscal policy, which can engender confidence in U.S. economic policy and in the long-term prospects for the U.S. economy. Even then, the dollar is a complicated issue for policymakers, investors and business people. As to policy, our currency should never be used as an instrument of trade strategy, and we should encourage other countries to move as soon as they are ready toward flexible exchange rates.
Let me now just briefly list a number of other challenges and risks facing the United States. Very high levels of consumer debt at the very least make our economy more vulnerable to significant interest-rate increases. Geopolitical issues, such as Iraq, terrorism and nuclear proliferation--which are serious risks in any case--can have greatly varying impact on our national security and our economy depending on how well they are handled. Antagonism toward the United States has increased greatly around the world, which can impede our ability to marshal international support for our economic and national-security objectives and can adversely affect American business abroad. Our global leadership needs to be exercised with a spirit of mutual respect and genuine partnership.
To return to the domestic front, we must reform the health-care system in the face of rapid increases in health-care costs and declining coverage. In energy policy, the prospects for longer-term upward pressure on oil prices from insufficient supply and geopolitical risk are great enough to call for conservation and alternative sources of energy.
Finally, we face a historic competitive challenge from large numbers of well-educated workers in low-wage environments, especially China and India, now connected to the United States by real-time technology that eradicates distance as a factor in locating many kinds of businesses. This phenomenon greatly increases the political difficulty of maintaining trade liberalization. The right policy in my judgment is continued liberalization inextricably intertwined with help for those who are dislocated by trade and coupled with a powerful program to promote American competitiveness, including greatly improved public education and greatly increased investment in basic research and certain kinds of infrastructure. Fiscal discipline is critical here, too, to provide interest rates low enough to promote high levels of private investment and to provide the resources to fund these requisites for success.
To meet these challenges--and others, like tort reform--we must change direction on many fronts. The outcome of the election does not alter economic reality, and that reality is likely to creep up on policymakers and create increasingly strong pressure for change. At some point, the difficulties could even grow so great as to force change.
Ours is a resilient political system and a resilient society, and our past success in meeting our challenges augurs well for the future economic well-being of the United States. But there are no guarantees, and there is much work to do.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines