Getty Images. Newsweek/Illustration

Andrew Stanton

By Andrew Stanton

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Democratic primaries for critical Senate races are starting to heat up as the party aims to win a majority in this year's midterms.

The party’s moderate and progressive divides are on display in the Maine race between Governor Janet Mills and progressive Graham Platner to take on GOP Senator Susan Collins. Candidates are also starting to launch attacks in Michigan’s primary between Representative Haley Stevens, state Senator Mallory McMorrow and progressive candidate Abdul El-Sayed. Meanwhile, in Texas, Representative Jasmine Crockett and state Representative James Talarico are facing off in an increasingly messy primary.

Newsweek reached out to Democratic candidates in the Maine, Michigan and Texas primaries for comment.

Read More on Politics

Why It Matters

Democrats are hopeful about the chances of a “blue wave” this November as the party in the White House typically loses seats in the midterms. Still, the Senate is tricky for Democrats due to only a handful of truly competitive seats up this year. Democrats will need to hold a strong coalition in states that backed GOP President Donald Trump in 2024, including states that gave him double-digit victories, to have a chance at winning a majority.

Messy primaries could complicate their general election prospects. Candidates vying for their parties’ nominations could inflict damage on their party’s eventual nominees, and competitive primaries do take up resources that could otherwise be spent on the general election.

Democrats Already Facing Tough Senate Math

Republicans currently hold a 53-47 majority in the Senate, so Democrats must flip three seats for a tie and four for a true majority. That is viewed as an uphill battle due to the challenging Senate map they are facing—and messy primaries could make that even more difficult.

Maine is one of Democrats’ top pick-up opportunities; it gave former Vice President Kamala Harris a 7-point win in 2024. But Collins has proved to be a formidable opponent in the past as her bipartisan credentials have boosted her popularity in the state for decades. But Democrats believe polarization and growing discontent with the senator leave her in her most vulnerable position yet.

North Carolina, where GOP Senator Thom Tillis is retiring, represents another strong pick-up opportunity for Democrats; it backed Trump by only three points. Former Governor Roy Cooper is running on the Democratic side, while former GOP Chair Michael Whatley is running as a Republican.

Democrats are defending two seats in the Trump-won states of Georgia and Michigan, where Democratic Senator Gary Peters opted to retire.

If they win all of those races, they would still only hold 49 seats, meaning they must also flip two double-digit Trump states such as Alaska, Iowa, Ohio and Texas. Democrats have largely coalesced behind former Senator Sherrod Brown in Ohio and former Representative Mary Peltola in Alaska, and the Iowa primary has remained lowkey so far.

But the Texas race has become perhaps the most heated Democratic primary of the cycle so far.

Getty Images. Newsweek/Illustration

National Divides on Display in Maine

Centrist Democrats have rallied behind Mills who has won by comfortable margins in the past, but progressives have argued Platner may be a more inspiring candidate. Age has also been a factor as Mills would be 79 when taking office if she wins in November.

The two candidates have traded barbs, with Platner comparing Mills to incumbent Senator Collins in a social media post in January. He responded to Mills saying Collins has been “refusing to stand up to this president” in January.

“Governor, you could have signed LD 1971 into law last June. Instead, you delayed until a few weeks ago and it won't be enforced for months. You could have protected Mainers against ICE. But you didn't. That's not leadership. That's just Susan Collins with a D next to her name,” Platner wrote on X.

That law would prevent law enforcement in Maine from taking part in immigration operations.

Mills’ campaign responded to Platner in a statement to Portland-based news station WGME.

"While Governor Mills is fighting to protect Maine from the reckless and dangerous actions of ICE, another candidate is attempting to mislead voters to score political points during such an urgent moment for our state,” her campaign said.

However, Dan Shea, professor of political science at Maine's Colby College, told Newsweek Maine’s political culture “leans against overly negative campaigning.”

“My guess is that it worked against Sara Gideon in her race against Collins six years ago. And to some extent, each side needs the other—Mills needs the young progressive vote from southern Maine, and Platner needs the more traditional Democratic vote across the state. I would be very surprised if the race becomes overly divisive,” he said.

Mills has criticized Platner over unearthed social media posts about women and Black people, and the revelation he had a tattoo resembling the Totenkopf, or “death’s head,” a symbol adopted by the SS. Platner has apologized for the posts and previously told Newsweek regarding the tattoo, “I absolutely would not have gone through life having this on my chest if I knew that—and to insinuate that I did is disgusting. I am already planning to get this removed."

Critics have still raised concerns about those posts

“I obviously vehemently disagree with the things he’s been quoted as saying and doing. I obviously vehemently disagree with anybody having an abhorrent tattoo,” Mills said while campaigning in Brunswick in October, reported The Maine Morning Star.

Michigan Senate Primary Also Highlights Party Divisions

Candidates in Michigan’s primary have also begun to exchange critiques over health care.

El-Sayed has criticized McMorrow for supporting a public option instead of Medicare for All.

“It’s wild to call yourself the 'next generation' of Democratic leadership and be running AGAINST Medicare for All in 2026. Wild,” he wrote to X in December.

McMorrow later accused El-Sayed, viewed as the most progressive candidate in the race, of abandoning his position on Medicare for All in a post to X last month in response to a video in which he said he supports allowing people to keep their employer or union-based health insurance to keep it if they are satisfied with it

“On an issue as important as healthcare, you have to be honest about what you’re fighting for–not rewriting definitions to have it both ways. The Medicare for All legislation that you’ve championed completely eliminates private health insurance as it exists today,” she wrote to X. “What you’re describing here is not M4A. It’s a public option. If you agree with me that that’s what we need to get to universal healthcare, you should say so. Then let’s fight to make it happen.”

McMorrow and El-Sayed are “battling for the progressive lane” in the primary, David Dulio, political science professor and director of the Center for Civic Engagement at Oakland University, told Newsweek.

Polls show a tight primary race as well as a competitive general election against Republican Mike Rogers, a former representative who narrowly lost the 2024 Senate election in Michigan.

Candidates also remain divided over issues like Israel. El-Sayed and McMorrow have referred to its actions in Gaza as a “genocide.” Stevens, who is competing in a more centrist lane, has been more supportive of Israel.

It is a challenging issue for Democrats in Michigan, as they must walk a fine line to avoid alienating moderates who hold more pro-Israel views as well as the state’s Muslim American community that has been more concerned about the humanitarian situation in Gaza. Progressive critics pointed to Harris’ support for Israel as a key reason she lost the state in 2024, though the exact reason for her loss remains a point of contention among Democrats.

Dulio said the primary has not become particularly contentious at this point as campaigning has just begun.

“A competitive and nasty primary is never a good thing for that candidate who emerges, especially when the other party has no primary, which is what we have here,” he said. “Mike Rogers is happy to let the three Democrats in the primary go after each other and bloody them up a little bit.”

Texas Senate Primary Becomes Contentious

Perhaps no Senate primary has become as contentious as that in Texas.

Tensions grew after former Representative Colin Allred, who ended his Senate campaign and decided to run for a House seat, said he had learned Talarico told a Black woman he believed he was running against a “mediocre Black man.” Talarico said that was a “mischaracterization of a private conversation.”

"In my praise of Congresswoman Crockett, I described Congressman Allred's method of campaigning as mediocre — but his life and service are not," he said in a statement.

Crockett told The Fort Worth Star-Telegram she understands Allred “felt like it was his responsibility to speak up for himself and speak up for other Black men.” She said she has never heard Talarico “say anything racial” but the Senate race has been “racially charged.”

“There’s been some racial overtones as it relates to podcasts, pundits and things like that,” Crockett told the publication. “And frankly, I do believe that one of the reasons that our country is in the position that it is right now is because of divisiveness.”

The debacle has sparked fierce social media debate. Some Democrats have doubted Crockett’s statewide electability, questioning whether her brand of politics could win over Republican voters. They have pointed to remarks by Crockett that Hispanic Trump voters had a "slave mentality” and referring to GOP Texas Governor Greg Abbott as “Governor Hot Wheels” as potential issues in a general election.

But Crockett supporters have raised concerns that some questioning her electability may be doing so because she is a Black woman.

Mark Jones, fellow in political science at the Baker Institute and political science professor at Rice University, told Newsweek the “electability” argument has a “real tension” to it and could spill over into the general election.

“The fear that some Democrats have is that if Talarico wins based on this electability argument, and an overwhelming majority of Black voters vote for Crockett in the primary, then some Black voters will not return to vote for Democratic candidates in November 2026,” he said.

If Black voter turnout falls in November, that would be “directly felt” by candidates, Jones added.

The Dallas Morning News also reported an outside pro-Talarico group has launched an attack ad stating Crockett is “backed by Republicans” who view her as an easier candidate to beat in November.

What People Are Saying

Roxie Richner, communications director for El-Sayed, wrote to Newsweek: “For too long, our politics has been driven by career politicians awash with corporate money—on both sides of the aisle. The real opponent in this race is an economy that delivers for the ultra-wealthy while leaving the rest of us behind. Abdul’s worker-focused, anti-corruption movement is bringing people together around shared values and shared struggles, across the divides that cynics tell us we can’t breach. That’s how you win a primary, and how we’ll win in November."

Mallory McMorrow wrote in a statement to Newsweek: “Primaries are healthy, and Michigan Democrats want to be the ones who decide their nominee - not Washington. They're how we debate ideas and figure out the best path forward. My campaign is about bringing everyone to the table so we can build that better future together."

James Talarico spokesperson JT Ennis told Newsweek: “The time for unity isn’t after primary day, it’s right now. The only way to end one party rule in Texas is by turning down the temperature and bringing people together across our differences to defeat Republican extremism.”

What Happens Next

The Cook Political Report currently classifies Maine and Michigan’s Senate races as being toss-up but Texas’ race as Likely Republican.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines