4 Women students ca. 1940's with Capt. Mildred Shefreld

Archives picture collection, #13-6-2497. Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library./4 Women students ca. 1940's with Capt. Mildred Shefreld

Anna Rahmanan

By Anna Rahmanan

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


More than half a century after Cornell University pioneered women's studies in American higher education, two women who witnessed its early feminist movement are questioning what has become of the Ivy League institution, how far the status of women on campus has advanced and what its latest sexual assault controversy reveals about that progress.

For Professor Deborah Spitz, who studied at Cornell during the early years of women's studies, the controversy has revived painful memories of her first days on campus, when freshmen had their photographs taken for a directory known as "The Pig Book."

"The knowledgeable girls got dolled up for the photos," she recalled. "Then each of us got a huge white button, 5 inches across, with our name on it, to wear as we walked across and around campus—so that the frat boys could stand on the corners and write down names of pretty girls to invite to fraternity 'teas.'"

Read More on Analysis

"To me, it felt grotesquely like a meat market, and I took off my button and threw it away," she told Newsweek.

Mary Beth Norton, Cornell's first female history professor, helped establish its women's studies program in 1972. She remembers hostile male students, an overwhelmingly male faculty and the struggle to convince colleagues that women's experiences deserved serious academic attention.

Yet Norton sees something in today's controversy that was largely absent when she arrived in 1971: women willing, and increasingly able, to challenge those running the university.

"In the 70s very few screamed about the situation. Now they do," she told Newsweek.

A woman walks past the Stewart Cooperative dormitory at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York, on October 5, 2026, where a banner hangs in response to a lawsuit alleging the 2024 gang rape of a female student at the Chi Phi fraternity house.

...

Spitz is more troubled by what the controversy suggests about universities' willingness to protect women.

"I really do not think that universities take sexual assault seriously. Not Cornell, not other places. It is disheartening," she said.

Their recollections come as Cornell faces a lawsuit alleging that a former student was drugged and sexually assaulted by multiple men at its Chi Phi fraternity house in October 2024. The accused men deny wrongdoing and no criminal charges have been filed.

Nevertheless, the university's Faculty Senate voted 75-50 on November 6 to express no confidence in the administration's ability to address sexual assault.

In response to questions from Newsweek, Cornell emphasized that it investigated the allegations in 2024 and imposed disciplinary sanctions, including expulsions and suspensions. The university also pointed to its longstanding sexual assault prevention programs and more recent measures intended to strengthen campus safety.

'It Felt Grotesquely Like a Meat Market'

Cornell traces the beginnings of its women's studies movement to 1969, when a feminist conference organized by activist Sheila Tobias attracted approximately 2,000 participants.

The following spring, an interdisciplinary course called "The Evolution of Female Personality" drew approximately 400 students and auditors, helping lay the groundwork for the formal program established in 1972.

Spitz remembers the influence of Joy Osofsky, the psychologist who helped develop the pioneering course.

Osofsky, she said, was "innovative, rigorous in her thinking, creative and passionate" and showed students how to advocate through evidence and disciplined reasoning.

"This course opened up the world to students, to enable us to think that we could be and do anything we put our mind to, especially in academia," Spitz said.

Outside the classroom, however, women encountered a different set of expectations.

"It was an era of parietal hours, single-sex dorms and yet at the same time an era of great hope and social change, when feminism was emerging nationally and on campus and there was backlash as well," she recalled.

She also remembers an unspoken competition among women in her dormitory over who received the most fraternity invitations.

"But we never really talked about the meaning of it all," she said.

'Men Taught Courses About History That Never Mentioned Women'

Norton encountered a different form of discrimination when she joined Cornell's history department in 1971.

For five years, she was the only woman among approximately 30 faculty members. She recalls that just one woman held a tenured position in the College of Arts and Sciences when she arrived.

"Men taught courses in sociology about men and called it 'society.' Men taught courses about psychology based on studies of men and assumed that was the universe of what needed to be known and studied," Norton said. "Men taught courses about history that never mentioned women and called it 'history.'"

Related Story

A Love Letter to Thanksgiving: The One Holiday That Belongs to Everyone

A Love Letter to Thanksgiving: The One Holiday That Belongs to Everyone

Related Story

We Need Reparations for SNL’s Sisters

We Need Reparations for SNL’s Sisters

Related Story

I Need Christmas Joy, So Don’t Blame Me for Starting It Before Thanksgiving

I Need Christmas Joy, So Don’t Blame Me for Starting It Before Thanksgiving

Norton joined a small group of female academics, alongside one supportive male colleague, seeking to establish women's studies as a legitimate academic discipline.

"It took several heated hours of debate in the Arts College faculty meetings for the proposers of the program to win a vote allowing it to be established," she recalled.

But the program's establishment did not put an end to the resistance. Male students sometimes enrolled in women's studies courses specifically to disrupt them, Norton said. Although she avoided those incidents, she experienced hostility in her regular history classes.

One student's behavior was so striking that her male teaching assistant told her witnessing it had changed his understanding of sexism.

Norton also recalled hearing accounts of male professors "seducing" female undergraduates and subsequently "abandoning" them, although she stressed that she knew little about sexual interactions between students.

The original women's studies program, she explained, was primarily concerned with correcting women's exclusion from academic subjects, rather than addressing campus sexual misconduct.

'In the 70s Very Few Screamed. Now They Do'

For Norton, the response to the current allegations illustrates how much women's position at Cornell has changed.

"Now women on campus are far more numerous and often hold senior positions on the faculty," she said. "Both female students and female faculty members have found their voices…and learned to use them, loudly."

She pointed to women faculty members' role in the no-confidence debate and the support they received from male colleagues and students.

A message is projected on the side of a Cornell University building in in Washington, D.C., on October 7, 2026.

...

Spitz, meanwhile, questioned whether institutional attitudes toward sexual assault have improved sufficiently.

"Now that there is a lot of publicity, the University is saying politically correct words," she said. "But the behavior of the past few years has not demonstrated anything positive."

She also criticized Cornell President Michael Kotlikoff, saying that, in her opinion, he demonstrates greater concern for his position than for the problem.

Cornell, however, disputed the suggestion that it had failed to respond to sexual misconduct. In its response to Newsweek, the university directed attention to its public account of the Chi Phi investigation, which it says resulted in disciplinary sanctions, including expulsions and suspensions. The Chi Phi chapter was also closed in 2024.

The university pointed to more than four decades of sexual assault prevention efforts, beginning with the establishment of the Cornell Advocates for Rape Education committee in 1984. It said mandatory annual sexual misconduct prevention programming is now required for faculty, staff and incoming students, with additional training for student organization leaders and athletes.

Cornell also said it introduced a new, mandatory in-person sexual violence prevention program for incoming undergraduates this fall, following recommendations from its Presidential Task Force on Campus Sexual Assault.

The university has also announced a broad review of fraternity and sorority life, while an independent investigation led by former Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates examines its handling of sexual misconduct.

For Norton, women's willingness to challenge the administration represents progress that would have been difficult to imagine when she joined Cornell.

Spitz's recollections, though, raise a different question: whether the institution has changed enough in response to the women who have spent decades demanding to be heard.

Norton sees the willingness of women to challenge Cornell's leadership as evidence of how far the university has come. Spitz questions how much that progress means if women still struggle to get institutions to take sexual assault seriously.

Cornell's next test will be what it does with the findings of its independent review because women have gained a voice at the university but whether that voice carries enough weight to change how it responds to sexual assault allegations remains an open question.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines