
Newsweek/Getty
![]()
By Newsweek Editors
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
For the past several weeks, the chattering class has been captivated by the most tabloid media saga to hit the Beltway since Monica Lewinsky's Oval Office visits with Bill Clinton: an ongoing soap opera featuring rising magazine star Olivia Nuzzi, the vaccine-hating Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Nuzzi's former media power-couple fiancé Ryan Lizza.
The sordid tale has revealed RFK Jr.'s poems about his "harvest," sent more political pundits Googling for "felching" than "turkey recipes" during Thanksgiving, and reminded everyone of former South Carolina governor and Appalachian Trail hiker Mark Sanford.
As one observer put it, the story has had it all: "political corruption, journalistic malpractice, lizards, Dante's Divine Comedy, Malibu, $15,000 worth of Cartier jewelry, shocking press releases, surprise investigations, naked presidential candidates (more than one), Kennedy assassinations (more than one), and also Keith Olbermann for some reason." While it's hard to say there have been any winners in this losers-only tale, Conventional Wisdom's duty is to persevere.
Read More on Opinion
Olivia Nuzzi ⬇
Nuzzi's American Canto was supposed to be her comeback—a chance to control the narrative after losing her job at New York Magazine when her romance with RFK Jr. was revealed. Instead, critics called her book "aggressively awful," "highly uneven and largely forgettable," and a "tell-nothing memoir." The Los Angeles Times called it a "Hate Read" while The New Yorker noted it "refuses chronology and coherence." Sorry, but you can't Joan Didion your way out of a sexting scandal.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. ⬆
However gross the allegations that have emerged from the scandal (which he has denied)—the poems about his "harvest," the ketamine use, the baby-making fantasies—none of it seems to have affected either his job as Health and Human Services Secretary or his marriage to actress Cheryl Hines, who called Nuzzi a "f—ing liar" to friends. For a Kennedy, surviving a sex scandal without losing anything important is as second-nature as a summer idyll at Hyannis Port.
Ryan Lizza ⬆
He'll forever be known as a bitter, amoral jilted ex, but he successfully enacted his revenge strategy on the woman who humiliated him—and got paid for it. Lizza turned his heartbreak into a five-part (so far) Substack series revealing Nuzzi's other affairs and torched whatever was left of her journalism career by accusing her of acting as RFK Jr.'s "private political operative." Media critics called it "revenge porn disguised as journalism" and condemned his "obsessive and violating" posts, but that didn't stop anyone from reading every salacious detail.
Anna Wintour ⬇
The queen of Condé Nast watched the debut of her chosen successor at Vanity Fair, Mark Guiducci, go up in smoke after he bet on hiring Nuzzi as his first big splash. Guiducci had to explain his decision twice to shell-shocked staffers while the book excerpt Vanity Fair published—complete with a nude painting of Nuzzi—was panned and he was caught completely off-guard by Lizza's revelations. Three months after Wintour signed off on bringing Nuzzi aboard as West Coast Editor, she had to sign off on a mutual parting of ways.
Keith Olbermann ⬇
After Lizza mentioned that the former ESPN and MSNBC blowhard had previously dated Nuzzi, Olbermann couldn’t resist leaping into the spotlight by posting a photo of himself dodging bullets Matrix-style. But it only led to a public hashing of how, when he was in his 50s, Olbermann began dating Nuzzi, then in her early 20s, after she left her parents’ home in suburban New Jersey, paid for her college tuition and rent while lavishing her with jewelry and designer clothes. Congratulations, Keith: you're now a creepy side character in someone else's scandal sheet.
David Haskell ⬆
When the New York Magazine's editor and Nuzzi agreed to part ways in October 2024 after the RFK Jr. relationship surfaced, Haskell was criticized for being too harsh. But he now only looks prescient as every other institution that touched this can't-look-away saga looks the worse for it. Meanwhile, Haskell and New York Magazine haven't been mentioned once. As a wise woman once said: "You cannot lose if you don't play."
Originally a staple of Newsweek's print edition, Conventional Wisdom used arrows to track whose stock was rising or falling in the political circus. We're reviving it in the digital age because the problem it lampooned—hyperbole and partisan certainty masquerading as insight—has only intensified.
CW assigns arrows—up, down, or sideways—to the figures and forces shaping current events. The arrows don't predict the future or claim special insight. They capture the prevailing winds of the moment, uncluttered by tribal howling. In an era when partisan media reinforces rather than questions assumptions, CW operates from the center—skeptical of left and right alike, committed to puncturing inflated reputations and recognizing overlooked truths.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines