10
Loading video...

By Khaleda Rahman
National Correspondent
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
In a growing number of states across the country, employers are being required to disclose salaries when posting job applications.
Massachusetts is the latest to mandate pay transparency, with Gov. Maura Healey signing a bill into law in late July that requires businesses with more than 25 employees to disclose salary ranges when posting jobs.
Advocates have championed the end of the pay secrecy as a way to level the playing field and reduce wage gaps, especially for women and people of color. Woman are paid about 84 cents for every dollar that a man is paid, according to the U.S. Department of Labor. Meanwhile, Black, Hispanic/Latino and Native American workers earn on average between 73 and 77 cents for every dollar a white worker makes.
Read More on U.S.
But while the laws are seen as a significant step toward wage equality, there can be downsides: companies may be able to hire or retain fewer employees, and transparency could affect morale in the workplace and lower productivity.

...
The trend began with Colorado, where a law went into effect in 2021 that required employers to disclose the hourly or salary compensation in job postings.
Since then, California, Hawaii, Illinois, Minnesota, New York and Washington, as well as the District of Columbia, have passed similar pay transparency laws. Illinois and Minnesota's laws take effect in January 2025.
Connecticut, Maryland, Nevada and Rhode Island have passed laws requiring salary ranges to be disclosed at some point during the job interview process or when applicants request the salary range.
Some cities, including Ithaca in New York, Jersey City in New Jersey and Cincinnati in Ohio, have also passed laws requiring salary ranges be included in job advertisements.
Massachusetts' new law also protects an employee's right to ask their employer for salary ranges when applying for a job or seeking a promotion.
The law "is part of a growing trend, with 13 states and the District of Columbia now requiring employers to disclose pay range information during the hiring process," Vasu Reddy, director of state policy for workplace justice and senior counsel at the National Women's Law Center (NWLC), told Newsweek.
"These laws reflect an understanding that pay disparities thrive in the shadows, and transparency gives workers a valuable tool to ensure they are being paid fairly. This is especially critical for women of color workers, who face the largest wage gaps due to the combined effects of sexism and racism."
Transparency can also "save valuable time during the hiring process by ensuring that applicants' salary expectations align with the position," Reddy said.
Allison Elias, a professor at the Darden School of Business and author of The Rise of Corporate Feminism, told Newsweek that continuing gender and racial pay gaps are driving the push for pay transparency, with the idea being "that greater transparency about salary ranges could lessen gaps in starting salaries."
She said: "We do know that providing more salary information can mitigate gender differences in some aspects of negotiation behavior."
Elias added that providing a salary range "could nudge women to initiate negotiation at the point of hire or possibly to anchor their ask at a higher number than without a stated range."
Tomasz Obloj, an associate professor at Indiana University's Kelley School of Business, told Newsweek that research, including his own, has shown that transparency reduces pay gaps, and the gender pay gap in particular.
"While little is known about the actual effects of salary ranges specifically, we now have quite a bit of evidence about pay transparency more generally," Obloj said. "First, there is unequivocal evidence that transparency reduces pay gaps and gender pay gap in particular. In this sense, it's massively effective."
Posting salary ranges "is also expected to have other beneficial effects, such as applicants (particularly from underrepresented minorities) applying to a more diverse set of jobs and therefore increasing their chances to getting a fairly paid good match," he said.
Outcomes from the earliest pay transparency state laws "show that they are having the desired effect: job postings in states with strong pay transparency laws were more likely to include pay information, including in industries that typically have low rates of pay disclosure," Reddy said.
Pay transparency laws are also having an impact in states that don't have them. An analysis of data from Glassdoor by the NWLC found that some employers were "proactively jumping on the pay transparency bandwagon" and posting salary information in job listings even without a legal obligation.
"More and more businesses are also recognizing the benefits of pay transparency in attracting a diverse pool of high-quality candidates, as polling shows that applicants are more interested in applying to postings that include salary information," Reddy said.
However, pay transparency does come with risks.
Researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis noted that implementing pay transparency policies could be costly for employers if they have to modify existing pay practices to ensure that employee salaries are in line with the pay that will be posted in job advertisements.
And Obloj pointed to research that found pay transparency "could lead to shifting more of the bargaining power towards employers and result in lower wages, on average."
Pay transparency "often results in wage compression," he said, when there is little difference in pay between employees regardless of differences in their knowledge, skills, experience or hierarchical level.
He and Todd Zenger, a professor at the David Eccles School of Business at the University of Utah, wrote in an article for the Harvard Business Review that the "weakened relationship between pay and performance can lead to lower employee productivity—an outcome that seems to depend on what pay transparency reveals (and to whom)."
"While there is nothing inherently worrying about this, it may lead to firms damping incentives and potentially not being able to attract and retain most productive employees," Obloj told Newsweek.
And as with any policy, the "devil is in the details," he said. "When posted ranges are wide (as they often are), it still leaves a lot of room for post-negotiation pay disparities, which would likely result in little being done about wage gaps that the policy aims to close."
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines