Justice Samuel Alito poses portrait

...

Jenna Sundel

By Jenna Sundel

News Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A group of young climate activists seeking to revive their lawsuit against the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) argued in a new court filing that a legal opinion by Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito bolsters their right to proceed in court.

Attorneys for the plaintiffs cite a dissenting opinion by Alito filed last year, challenging the Court's decision not to hear a case about whether a Wisconsin school district is legally allowed to conceal a student's gender identity from their parents.

"Some federal courts are succumbing to the temptation to use the doctrine of Article III standing as a way of avoiding some particularly contentious constitutional questions," Alito wrote.

Read More

Dan Osborn’s Chances of Beating Republican Pete Ricketts in Nebraska4 min read

Dan Osborn’s Chances of Beating Republican Pete Ricketts in Nebraska

Republican Backs Push to Repeal Part of Trump Bill Days After Voting For It4 min read

Republican Backs Push to Repeal Part of Trump Bill Days After Voting For It

Dozens of Green Card Applicants Sue Trump Admin After Process Derailed5 min read

Dozens of Green Card Applicants Sue Trump Admin After Process Derailed

Why It Matters

Genesis B. v. EPA is one of several cases of environmental litigation involving youth plaintiffs as the debate over United States climate policy continues. The outcome could impact both how courts handle youth-led constitutional climate claims and the EPA's regulatory reach.

The activists' efforts come as federal courts, including the Supreme Court, have increasingly weighed the scope and limits of agency authority over environmental matters.

Justice Samuel Alito poses portrait

...

What to Know

Attorneys for the 18 plaintiffs involved in Genesis B. v. EPA filed their opening brief on July 2, 2025, with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. They called on the court to overturn a previous district court ruling that dismissed their case on the grounds that they lacked standing to sue.

The plaintiffs claim the EPA discriminates against children by undervaluing the long-term benefits of pollution regulations, and that recent Supreme Court precedent strengthens their argument that federal courts have the authority to hear their claims.

U.S. District Judge Michael Fitzgerald first dismissed the lawsuit in May 2024, but allowed the plaintiffs to submit an amended complaint. Fitzgerald cited the plaintiffs' failure to demonstrate how a favorable court ruling would redress their alleged injuries.

Attorneys for the plaintiffs refer to two Supreme Court rulings decided after the lower court's order. In Diamond Alternative Energy v. EPA, the Court ruled that a lower court had improperly blocked a challenge to an EPA waiver that allowed California to set more stringent car pollution rules.

In that case, the Court said that a decline in gasoline sales could hurt fuel producers and that "those monetary costs 'are of course an injury.'"

The second recent case cited by plaintiffs is Gutierrez v. Saenz, a case that dealt with a death-row inmate's right to challenge state laws on DNA testing.

The Supreme Court overturned a lower court's ruling that Gutierrez did not have standing to sue because the courts could not provide him with a remedy. The plaintiffs in Genesis B. v. EPA argued that this shows "they are not required to prove that a favorable decision would result in different regulatory outcomes."

The brief states that it is now "undeniable" that the district court may hear the case.

Attorneys for the plaintiffs said that, if their claims are upheld, the courts possess the power to "redress their unequal treatment and ensuing constitutional injuries."

Youth-led climate litigation has gained attention in recent years, with notable wins in state courts.

For example, in 2023, young plaintiffs in Montana succeeded in obtaining a ruling that climate impacts must be considered before issuing permits for fossil fuel projects. In June, Hawaii agreed to a settlement with young people to decarbonize its transportation system by 2045.

What People Are Saying:

Attorneys for the plaintiffs, in a brief: "The district court erred in denying Plaintiffs standing to seek declaratory and injunctive relief for Defendants' unequal treatment and resulting economic, physical, and mental health harms these constitutional violations cause Plaintiffs personally."

U.S. District Judge Michael Fitzgerald, in a February order: "Plaintiffs failed to present the Court with any authority for the proposition that dealing with a societal problem—albeit one of great magnitude—for a longer period of time transforms a generalized grievance into a particularized harm."

What Happens Next

The federal government is expected to file its own brief in the case by August 4.

Do you have a story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have any questions about this story? Contact LiveNews@newsweek.com.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines