Vi Lyles, Charlotte's mayor,

...

Brendan Cole

By Brendan Cole

Senior Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


The mayor of Charlotte, North Carolina, is under fire for her comments about the fatal stabbing of a Ukrainian refugee on public transport in which she referred to the suspect's mental health issues.

Vi Lyles, a Democrat, faced criticism for her statement following the release of surveillance footage which showed Iryna Zarutska on a train on August 22 sitting in front of Decarlos Brown Jr. before she was stabbed.

Newsweek has contacted Lyles' office for comment outside of office hours.

Read More

Exclusive—Ukraine Embassy Responds to Iryna Zarutska Stabbing in Charlotte4 min read

Exclusive—Ukraine Embassy Responds to Iryna Zarutska Stabbing in Charlotte

Charlotte Murder, Violent Crime Rates Compared to Other Major U.S. Cities3 min read

Charlotte Murder, Violent Crime Rates Compared to Other Major U.S. Cities

Why It Matters

Video of the attack on Zarutska went viral. As well as being a tragedy in which a Ukrainian refugee had fled war only to be killed in the U.S., Lyles' statement was condemned for relegating concerns for the victim compared with the attacker.

Lyles' statement about mental health services which did not mentioning the suspect's reported criminal background prompted anger as Democrats seek to push back against President Donald Trump's rhetoric to deploy the National Guard in major, Democrat-run cities.

Vi Lyles, Charlotte's mayor,

...

What To Know

Lyles said Brown Jr., who has been arrested and faces a murder charge, had long struggled with mental health issues and looked likely to have "suffered a crisis."

Her comments that mental health problems must be "treated with the same compassion, diligence and commitment as cancer or heart disease" angered social media users who said this diminished the suspect's accountability.

Zarutska, 23, had fled Kyiv following Russia's full-scale invasion and settled in Charlotte.

Surveillance footage released by the Charlotte Area Transit System on Friday showed the incident from August 22 in which she boarded the train and took a seat in front of Brown Jr.. Local media said he had a history of mental health problems, arrests and convictions.

Brown, 34, pulled out a knife and stabbed his victim three times, including in the throat, according to Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police, WBTV reported.

Video showed Brown Jr. walking through the rail car after the attack, removing his red sweatshirt as blood dripped from him. Zarutska collapsed in her seat and was pronounced dead on the train.

Court records show Brown had been arrested several times, including for robbery with a dangerous weapon, larceny and communicating threats. He served five years in prison for the armed robbery charge, according to WSOC-TV.

In a statement reported by WSOC, Lyles said that first and foremost "thoughts and prayers" were with the victim's family and friends and that the tragic situation highlighted mental health safety nets in the city.

While she did not divulge the details of his medical history, Lyles said the suspect had suffered a long history of mental health illness and that the tragic incident "should force us to look at what we are doing across our community to address root causes."

She said, "we will never arrest our way out [of] issues such homelessness and mental health" and that we should not be "villainizing those who struggle with their mental health or those who are unhoused."

View this post on X

View this post on X

View this post on X

This prompted a lively online debate with X user Ian Miles Cheong who wrote that Lyles "didn't speak about justice" for the victim or for accountability for a repeat offender who had allegedly been arrested 14 times before.

Alec Lace posted that Lyles had knelt for George Floyd, the Black man whose death at the hands of police in Minneapolis in 2020 prompted nationwide protests, but he now urged people "NOT to share the video" and criticized how Lyles did not mention the suspect's name, calling on her to resign.

Co-owner of Trending Politics, Colin Rugg disparaged Lyles for saying that "Americans need to have more 'compassion' for the homeless."

In a video shared by X owner Elon Musk, Kaizen D. Asiedu posted a video in which he took aim at Lyle's comments for not mentioning the suspect's previous arrests, adding "our empathy keeps getting used to excuse evil."

What People Are Saying

Charlotte Mayor Vi Lyles said in a statement: "I am not villainizing those who struggle with their mental health or those who are unhoused. Mental health disease is…a disease like any other than needs to be treated with the same compassion, diligence and commitment as cancer or heart disease."

Media commentator Kaizen D. Asiedu on X: "After the Ukrainian woman was murdered, the mayor issued a statement exclusively defending the homeless and mentally ill. No mention of the killer's 14 arrests and multiple felonies." The post was shared by Musk who wrote, "exactly."

X user Ian Miles Cheong posted: "Vi Lyles, the mayor of Charlotte, didn't speak about justice for Iryna Zarutska."

Lib's of TikTok posted that: "Not only did Charlotte Democrat Mayor Lyles refuse to condemn the…repeat offender who stabbed a woman to death on the train, but she suggested we should actually have compassion for him."

What Happens Next

Brown Jr. has been charged with first-degree murder and a Go Fund Me appeal has raised $74,500 for Zarutska's family. Meanwhile, right-wing influencers have taken up the case, accusing national news organizations of ignoring the crime.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines