Left: Carrie Prejean: Miss California at the time, listens to a question at the Rock Church during services in San Diego Sunday, April, 26, 2009. Right: Vice President JD Vance speaks at the Critical Minerals Ministerial meeting at the State Department, Wednesday, Feb. 4, 2026 in Washington.

...

Jordan King

By Jordan King

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Catholic activist Carrie Prejean Boller has called on JD Vance to speak out after she was removed from Donald Trump's Religious Liberty Commission, saying the vice president is a Catholic "who wants to be president in 2028."

Boller, a model and former beauty pageant titleholder turned conservative activist, was ousted from the commission last Wednesday, after a fiery hearing on antisemitism which commission Chair Texas Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick said Boller "hijacked for her own personal and political agenda."

The hearing turned into a debate about Israel and Zionism, which Boller said she does not embrace because she is a Catholic.

Read More

On Sunday, Boller said in a post on X: "Let’s see if JD Vance, Marco Rubio and Ron DeSantis speak out in defense of my Catholic religious beliefs. after all these are Catholics who want to be president in 2028. Their silence speaks volumes. Are they Israel first or America first?"

Newsweek has contacted Vance's office, via email outside of normal working hours, for comment.

View this post on X

Why It Matters

Boller’s removal highlighted rifts inside the Trump administration’s new Religious Liberty Commission over how criticism of Israel intersects with antisemitism, as well as who has authority to remove commissioners, issues that could shape the panel’s credibility ahead of its spring report to the president.

Her subsequent call for Vance, a Catholic and potential 2028 presidential contender, to speak out underscores a broader fight inside the political right over Israel, antisemitism and religious liberty messaging.

What To Know

When the commission chair Patrick announced Boller’s removal last Wednesday, he said: "No member of the Commission has the right to hijack a hearing for their own personal and political agenda on any issue. This is clearly, without question, what happened Monday in our hearing on antisemitism in America. This was my decision."

While some have praised the decision to remove Boller, including conservative commentator Laura Loomer, others have argued it goes against religious liberty for Catholics.

Catholic podcaster Timothy Gordon wrote on X: "Can you national politicians/commentators who are Catholic PLEASE speak up for religious liberty—since the commission for RL is removing whichever members actually *exercise* their RL (eg Carrie Prejean Boller) by calling out zio-crybullies. I'll start by asking: JD Vance and Jack Posobiec."

This was the post Boller replied to when she called on Vance herself.

The Religious Liberty Commission is a new federal advisory panel created by President Trump in May 2025, tasked with studying the roots and current threats to religious liberty.

Last Monday’s hearing was focusing on the "Religious Liberty Implications of Anti-Semitism."

Boller clashed with several people, including a rabbi and Seth Dillon, CEO of conservative satirical site The Babylon Bee, who was speaking out against what he argued was growing antisemitism on the right.

Boller repeatedly pressed the question of whether anti-Zionism is always antisemitism and defended conservative podcaster Candace Owens, who has long been accused of antisemitism.

What People Are Saying

Carrie Prejean Boller said in a post on X: "If this were truly a Religious Liberty Commission, the moment witnesses and speakers began hijacking the religious liberty in America hearing by equating anti-Zionism with antisemitism, the Chairman Dan Patrick or co-chair Ben Carson should have intervened and corrected the record. Instead, I was silenced, interrupted, and Lt. Governor Dan Patrick attempted to remove me from this Commission.

"Using Zionism as a litmus test and labeling those who do not support it as antisemites is not religious freedom. It is the imposition of a theological or ideological standard that violates freedom of conscience. This only proves my point. The hearing might as well have been called the ‘you better be a Zionist or else’ hearing."

Catholics for Catholics said in a post on X: "Catholics for Catholics Stands Strong Behind Carrie Prejean Boller and announces ‘Catholic Champion Award’ For Her Defense of the Catholic Faith!"

Laura Loomer said: "The White House Religious Liberty Commission has been infested by Islamic terror sympathizers who are actively sabotaging the America First agenda from within.

"Former beauty queen Carrie Prejean Boller Carrie Prejean Boller is a total fraud who hijacked a high-level meeting to harass Jewish panelists while wearing a Palestinian flag pin.

"This woman has zero accomplishments beyond pageants and alleged sex tapes, yet she was allowed to push scripted pro-Hamas talking points while representing the Trump White House.

"She is now crying about being fired and attacking the Trump administration as ‘Israel First’ even though she was the only person at the Committee meeting who was representing foreign interests.

"Personnel is policy, and we cannot allow these shapeshifters to run interference for jihadists on White House boards."

What Happens Next

The commission will deliver a report to Trump this spring—there are two more hearings planned.

Boller’s public challenge to Vance and other Republican figures will likely keep pressure on 2028 hopefuls to define their positions on Israel, antisemitism, and Catholic teaching within the party’s religious liberty agenda, based on ongoing debate captured in the cited reports and posts.

Left: Carrie Prejean: Miss California at the time, listens to a question at the Rock Church during services in San Diego Sunday, April, 26, 2009. Right: Vice President JD Vance speaks at the Critical Minerals Ministerial meeting at the State Department, Wednesday, Feb. 4, 2026 in Washington.

...

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines