
...

By Emma Marsden
Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A Quebec man says he was wrongfully detained and humiliated by the U.S. Coast Guard after an encounter on Lake Champlain led to his boat capsizing and a brief stint in an American jail cell.
Newsweek contacted the U.S. Coast Guard and Customs and Border Protection (CBP) for comment via email on Friday.
Why It Matters
The detention of 60-year-old Edouard Lallemand has prompted outrage from him and his wife and raised questions about enforcement on shared waterways, also highlighting how routine recreational activities near international borders can escalate unexpectedly.
Read More on News
What to Know
Lallemand said he had borrowed a friend's boat and was fishing near Venise-en-Québec, located about 15 kilometres north of the U.S. border at the northern end of Lake Champlain, which links the U.S. and Canada, CTV News reported.
A lifelong fisherman, he insists he was within Canadian waters when U.S. Coast Guard officers approached him and instructed him to shut off his engine, which he said he did.

...
According to Lallemand, the three officers then told him he had crossed into American waters. He denied this, saying he has fished in that area for years.
According to his account, as per CTV News, a visibly emotional Lallemand said he told the officers, "No, I'm very sorry, I'm in Canada. I'm polite enough to talk to you guys but you cannot arrest me. 'You can't come across the border and pick me up.' But they did," he said.
Lallemand said he restarted his engine and suggested continuing the conversation with the officers near the shore. However, the Coast Guard followed him and attempted to steer him into U.S. waters, which he claims led his boat to capsize.
Speaking to CTV News, he appeared to be angry and shocked about what happened, saying that he fell into the water and was "drowning" before eventually being pulled out by the officers, who he said were not taking care of him.
"The first time I went down, coming up with water in my mouth, spitting it out, I said 'throw me a buoy!'" he said.
He was then handcuffed, processed, and turned over to U.S. Customs and Border Protection, where he says officers fingerprinted him, placed him in a jail cell while he was still soaked, and gave him what he described as a "dirty" blanket.
Lallemand is reported to have been held in a jail cell for nearly two hours before being released.
His wife, Darlene Fielding, said, as per CTV News, "we treat our pets better than they treated him," adding that upon her husband's return, he was "like a beaten man."
Customs regulations on Lake Champlain involve specific reporting requirements for boaters, especially those crossing the border, and potential enforcement actions for violations. CBP has designated reporting locations and procedures, including the possibility of phone-in reporting, to facilitate border crossings while ensuring compliance.
The Coast Guard maintains that Lallemand was approximately 65 yards inside U.S. waters and struck their vessel while attempting to flee, leading to the capsize.
What People Are Saying
The U.S. Coast Guard, in a statement to CTV News: "While the Coast Guard's 29-ft response small-boat was alongside the vessel, the operator put the vessel in motion and ignored commands to maintain course and speed for boarding purposes. The vessel then made an abrupt starboard turn and struck the port bow of the Coast Guard small-boat at coordinates 45°00.792'N, 073°10.608'W, approximately 65 yards south of the U.S./Canadian border. The collision caused the vessel to capsize, putting the operator in the water."
What Happens Next
Lallemand said he would like an apology from the U.S. Coast Guard and has warned other Canadian boaters to stay away from the border.
The U.S. Coast Guard has said that "the actions of the operator of the Canadian vessel are currently under investigation."
The incident will likely lead to calls for clearer agreements on maritime enforcement and cooperation along the U.S.-Canada border, with officials possibly looking into better GPS boundary marking and improved communication procedures to prevent future confrontations.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines