Front view of the Bank of America Tower in Charlotte, North Carolina in 2022

...

Amanda Greenwood

By Amanda Greenwood

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Americans are increasingly turning to AI for help with everyday financial questions, from how much to save for emergencies to how to invest for the future. But a new academic study suggests consumers should be cautious about treating chatbot advice as a substitute for professional financial guidance.

The research, published in the June 2026 edition of the Journal of Financial Planning, examined seven popular generative AI platforms: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Copilot, DeepSeek, Meta AI and Perplexity.

Researchers wanted to determine whether the tools would provide consistent financial advice and whether recommendations changed based on demographic characteristics such as race or gender.

Read More on News

People Are Using AI for Financial Advice

The study comes as more and more consumers are using online tools to answer financial questions, while financial planners are increasingly encountering clients who have already consulted AI chatbots before speaking with a professional.

Researchers said there has been little previous research examining how different AI tools handle financial planning questions. To test this, they created standardized household profiles and asked each platform to provide guidance on three common financial planning topics:

The prompts were identical except for changes to the race or gender of the household head.

The researchers then compared whether the AI tools gave the same advice across different platforms and demographic descriptions.

Where AI Can Be Useful

Stock image: popular AI applications, including ChatGPT, DeepSeek, Gemini, Copilot, Grok, and Claude are seen in 2025.

...

The study found that AI tools often produced recommendations that broadly aligned with conventional financial planning principles.

Retirement withdrawal advice was the most consistent: Most platforms recommended withdrawal rates close to the widely known 4 percent rule, which suggests that retirees can withdraw 4 percent of their retirement savings in the first year of retirement and then adjust that amount for inflation each year thereafter, with a reasonable likelihood that their money will last about 30 years. The researchers found no significant differences among most tools.

Gianni Nicolini, a co-author of the study and professor of banking and finance at the University of Rome Tor Vergata, told Newsweek that AI can be helpful as an initial reference point, rather than a final answer.

"Our evidence is that, for each of these tasks, AI is useful to define a reference point that can be used to start a conversation with a professional financial adviser," Nicolini said.

He compared today's AI tools to the way consumers previously used search engines to research medical symptoms before consulting a physician.

"Like people in the past used Google to figure out the possible cause of their health symptoms, but then kept in touch with a doctor, now financial consumers can do the same with LLMs," Nicolini said. He added that the technology can help people gain a broader understanding of their financial needs and feel more informed before speaking with a financial professional.

The study also found that some tools appeared stronger than others in specific areas.

Investment recommendations varied across platforms, but Nicolini said there was no single overall winner.

"There is not a 'clear winner' in this comparison/competition, but looking at recommendations for investment portfolio composition, Gemini, Claude, and Copilot provided the most reliable recommendations."

Brenda Cude, another co-author of the study and professor emeritus at the University of Georgia, said AI may be most helpful for consumers whose financial lives match common planning scenarios.

"I think AI can be more useful for people whose financial situation is typical of others in the same situation or for those who know how to make the GenAI aware of something unique in their situation, such as grandparents raising grandchildren," she said.

She added that people with stronger financial knowledge may also be better positioned to benefit from AI tools.

"They're more likely to know how to write prompts to get relevant responses and to know how to ask helpful follow-up questions in subsequent prompts," Cude said. "They're also more likely to correctly interpret the responses they receive."

Where Experts Warn Against AI Financial Advice

Despite those potential benefits, the study found major differences in the advice produced by different AI platforms.

The biggest differences emerged in the recommendations made for emergency savings and investment portfolios.

Emergency fund recommendations ranged from approximately $21,000 to $37,500, depending on the AI platform used, despite the same household information being provided.

The researchers found those differences were statistically significant.

Stock image: people walk by the New York Stock Exchange building on Wall Street in Lower Manhattan, New York, in 2019.

...

Investment recommendations also varied substantially. Some AI tools advised far more conservative portfolios than others, with recommended stock allocations ranging from 15 percent to 45 percent. Recommendations for bonds, cash, and alternative investments also differed considerably between platforms.

Researchers also observed potential demographic inconsistencies. While some platforms produced nearly identical recommendations regardless of race or gender, others generated different advice when only the demographic description changed.

DeepSeek showed some of the largest variations in portfolio recommendations between demographic groups. The researchers found it tended to recommend more conservative, lower-risk portfolios to certain groups—including women and some racial or ethnic minorities—while suggesting relatively higher-risk, higher-return investments for otherwise identical investors described as men or members of majority groups.

The researchers said these differences reflected demographic bias rather than legitimate financial considerations. Newsweek has contacted DeepSeek for comment regarding the study's findings on demographic bias.

Cude said that was one of the most-surprising findings.

"The greatest surprise was that, when we changed the race or gender of the household, some of the GenAIs gave a different recommendation than they had for a White household head or a male household head," Cude said. "I'm not a Certified Financial Planner, but I can't think of any reason why the recommendations for the three financial planning situations we used should be different because of race or gender."

She said researchers were also surprised that the tools "rarely asked for any additional information before making a recommendation."

"I would think that most financial planners would want to know much more information than we provided before making recommendations," she said.

The researchers emphasized that AI systems generate responses based on patterns in the data they were trained on and are not bound by the same fiduciary obligations or professional standards that govern financial advisers.

They also noted that AI responses can vary depending on how a question is phrased.

Still, Cude said the researchers didn’t encounter one common AI problem during the study.

"Despite everything we hear about how AI can make up information or hallucinate, we didn't experience that," she said.

What Americans Should Do Going Forward

Stock image: the facade of Bank of America Tower is seen in Charlotte, North Carolina, in 2022.

...

The findings suggest that consumers could receive very different financial guidance depending on which AI chatbot they use.

Someone asking multiple platforms how much they should have in an emergency fund or how to invest their savings might receive conflicting answers, even when providing identical financial details.

Cude said the rise of AI-generated financial advice raises difficult regulatory questions.

"One question might be whether it's too late to regulate AI-generated financial advice," Cude said. "The approach in the U.S., at least, seems to be that if financial planners are using AI, they must use it in a way that is consistent with existing rules and regulations."

She said her focus is on helping consumers understand AI's limitations and use it appropriately "as a complement to more traditional financial advice."

For Americans using AI for financial tasks, that means treating chatbot responses as a starting point rather than a final answer. Consumers should compare information across reputable sources, ask follow-up questions, provide specific details about their circumstances and avoid making major financial decisions based solely on AI-generated recommendations.

They should also be aware that AI tools may not always reflect the latest tax rules, retirement account limits or financial regulations. Decisions involving retirement withdrawals, investment allocations, estate planning, or major purchases should be reviewed with a qualified financial professional.

But AI Financial Advice Is Still Developing

The study's authors noted that AI tools are evolving quickly and that results could change if the study were repeated in the future. They also said different prompts or more detailed household information could lead to different outputs.

For now, the study suggests AI can help consumers better understand financial concepts and prepare for conversations with advisers. But experts warn that it should not be treated as a replacement for professional advice, especially when the stakes involve savings, retirement or long-term investments.

The biggest takeaway is significant: While AI isn't ready to replace professional financial advice yet, it could be a gateway to making general financial information more accessible.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Ben Kelly and James Debens

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines