10
Loading video...

By Ivan Gulas
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Until the mid-20th century, leadership—particularly in matters of war and foreign policy—rested on an implicit understanding: strategy required discretion. Plans were not fully disclosed, intentions were often obscured, and decisions were judged not by their daily appearance, but by their strategic merit, execution, and outcome.
This was not viewed as deception in a negative sense, but as a necessary condition of effective statecraft. Strategy depended on timing, positioning, and the careful management of information. To reveal intentions prematurely was to weaken one's position.

...
Read More on Opinion
Even into the mid-20th century, this assumption largely held. During World War II, Allied leadership—under Winston Churchill—relied extensively on secrecy and deception, particularly in planning D-Day. These efforts required not only concealment, but the deliberate projection of false intentions. Public disclosure would not have enhanced accountability; it would have undermined the effort itself.
The press, for its part, operated within a framework that—while not uncritical—recognized limits, particularly in times of war. The relationship between leadership, media, and the public was shaped by distance—informational and psychological.
That relationship changed.
The Vietnam War marked a turning point—not only in geopolitics, but in how war was experienced by the public. For the first time, the battlefield entered the living room. Advances in media technologies made it possible to deliver images of conflict with unprecedented immediacy.
But the transformation was not simply that the war was seen.
It was that it was felt.
Images carry a different psychological weight than text. They compress complexity, bypass deliberation, and evoke rapid emotional response. The battlefield was no longer described; it was seen—and, more importantly, felt. What had once been processed at a distance became immediate and emotional.
The public did not merely observe the war. It was drawn into it visually and emotionally. Repeated exposure to vivid images of danger, suffering, uncertainty, and contradiction did more than inform. It created a sustained, felt experience.
What followed was not simply a change in opinion, but a shift in emotional relationship to the war itself—fear, anger, moral unease, disillusionment, and urgency. In psychological terms, response is shaped not only by what happens, but by how it is emotionally experienced.
At the same time, these images often appeared to conflict with official narratives, contributing to what became known as the "credibility gap." The result was not merely disagreement about policy. It was a growing mistrust of leadership itself.
This transformation was not driven by media alone. It was enabled—and amplified—by major advances in media technologies and reinforced by financial incentives tied to attention. News organizations compete not only for audience size, but for audience loyalty, often shaping content to attract and retain specific segments. Emotionally engaging coverage draws viewers, drives ratings, and generates revenue—creating pressure to emphasize immediacy, repetition, and emotional intensity.
The speed and reach of social media platforms and live-streaming technologies have further intensified this dynamic. Information now circulates almost instantaneously, often accompanied by real-time visual access that heightens the sense of immediacy and participation. Unlike traditional broadcast media, these environments allow individuals not only to receive content but also to react to, share, and amplify it in real time—transforming audiences from observers into participants. At the same time, content is often encountered within personalized streams that reinforce pre-existing perspectives, creating self-reinforcing cycles of emotional engagement that deepen reactions and accelerate the feedback loop.
The same event is framed in markedly different ways at the same moment, producing sharply divergent emotional responses to a shared reality—reinforcing division and creating opposing expectations of leadership.
The convergence of technology, psychology, and incentive produced a new condition: immersion without distance—and without the emotional buffer that distance once provided.
Earlier generations could know about war; they were not required to feel it continuously. That buffer is now gone.
Under these conditions, events are experienced as continuous rather than episodic. Emotional responses are amplified and sustained. Interpretation increasingly follows feeling, rather than preceding it.
But the most consequential change was not only in how the public experiences events—it is in how those experiences feed back into leadership itself and begin to shape the decisions that follow.
What has emerged is a continuous dynamic loop:
presidential action → media interpretation, amplified through selective "being there" visuals → public emotional experience → public opinion and political pressure → how that pressure is idiosyncratically processed by the leader → presidential response → further media interpretation under the same conditions—sustaining a cycle that continuously reshapes both perception and decision-making
Now, this cycle operates in near real time, eliciting immediate judgments about strategy and generating pressures on the president in opposing directions. Strategy is not only judged before it has fully unfolded; it is subjected to competing demands for response from both sides.
What is presented is not simply what happened, but what is selected, framed, and made to feel immediate—creating a sense of participation rather than observation.
Public pressure does not determine outcomes directly. It must be absorbed and processed by the leader. This places unusual weight on the internal world of the leader.
In earlier eras, this loop existed more weakly and with far greater delay. Leaders had greater latitude to execute strategy before public reaction significantly shaped or constrained it. Strategy could unfold before it was judged.
Now, it unfolds while being judged—and, increasingly, influenced—in real time.
The expectation that leaders disclose intentions and be judged moment by moment is not timeless. It is the product of a convergence: the Vietnam-era erosion of trust, the rise of immersive media, and the technological capacity to transform distant events into immediate emotional experience.
The critical transformation was not informational, but experiential. The public did not simply gain access to events—it became emotionally engaged with them. And what is felt in real time is rarely judged with the patience that strategy requires.
Within a system shaped by attention and incentive, this engagement is reinforced rather than moderated. Emotional response becomes political pressure; political pressure feeds back into decision-making; and strategy itself is shaped while still unfolding.
The central modern change is not simply that leadership is more visible. It is that leadership now operates within a continuous feedback loop in which actions are instantly transmitted, emotionally experienced, politically mobilized, and fed back into presidential decision-making—often before their strategic logic has had time to mature.
Public pressure, however, does not determine outcomes directly. It must be absorbed and processed by the leader. And it is here that a critical shift emerges.
The personality of the leader—their capacity to tolerate, resist, or respond to continuous pressure, and their confidence in their decisions—has never been more consequential than it is now.
That confidence may be grounded and adaptive, allowing a strategy to endure long enough to be meaningfully evaluated. Or it may become rigid or reactive, reinforcing or altering decisions in ways that reflect pressure more than purpose.
The same conditions that lead one leader to adjust course may lead another to hold firm—or intensify it.
Historical judgment requires time. It depends on outcomes, context, and information often unavailable in the moment. Real-time judgment, by contrast, is driven by immediacy, emotion, and incomplete understanding.
The question, then, is no longer simply whether a strategy is sound, how well it is executed, or whether it ultimately succeeds. It is whether it can endure the pressures of real-time emotional judgment long enough for those outcomes to emerge.
At one time, strategy resembled a chess match—given time to unfold, its quality judged by the outcome of the game.
Today, it is judged move by move—by how each action is seen and, more importantly, how it is felt in the moment.
And unlike chess, the players do not always operate under equal conditions. One may be forced to respond under continuous external pressure, while the other proceeds with greater latitude and time.
In such an environment, the issue is no longer only the merit of the strategy itself, but whether it can survive the conditions under which it must now be executed.
The challenge is no longer only to play the game well, but to sustain the game long enough for its outcome to matter.
Dr. Ivan Gulas is a board-certified clinical psychologist and former Harvard Medical School faculty member. He later worked in media and technology and was named one of Wired magazine’s “25 People Reinventing Hollywood.” He is the author of several books on psychology and contemporary social issues.
The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines