
...
By Martha McHardy
US News Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
A growing movement in Eastern Oregon is trying to redraw the map—by moving the state line.
Organizers behind the Greater Idaho campaign say they want to transfer more than a dozen rural Oregon counties into neighboring Idaho, arguing that their communities have little in common with the state’s liberal, urbanized western half.
“Eastern Oregon and Western Oregon are nothing alike,” Matt McCaw, Executive Director of the Greater Idaho Movement, told Newsweek. “The people are different. They want different things for their communities. But they’re forced into sharing this state government that only causes friction.”
Read More on U.S.
A Government That Doesn’t Represent
At the heart of the campaign is a belief that Oregon’s political system no longer represents its rural voters.
As of 2025, approximately 33 percent of Oregon's population resides in rural areas, while about 65 percent live in urban areas, according to the Oregon Office of Rural Health. The remaining 2 percent live in frontier areas.
Eastern and Central Oregon, which make up most of the state’s rural regions, are predominantly conservative. Counties like Malheur, Harney, and Crook consistently vote Republican in statewide and federal elections, and their state legislative representation is largely Republican.
All counties in Eastern Oregon favored Donald Trump by significant margins in the last presidential election. For instance, in Malheur County, Trump secured 70.44 percent of the vote, and in Morrow County, he received 72.02 percent.
Yet, Oregon’s state government is dominated by Democrats. The state has a Democratic governor, and both the state House and Senate are controlled by Democrats.
For McCaw, this is a problem.
“Our system is supposed to represent the people,” he said. “The people of Eastern Oregon are incredibly conservative—about 70 percent voted for Donald Trump—and yet we have a state government that does not represent their values.”

...
A Deep Cultural and Policy Divide
For supporters, the split between east and west is not just political, but cultural. McCaw explained that on almost every major policy issue—guns, abortion, immigration, taxes, drugs—Eastern Oregon and Western Oregon stand in opposition.
“Eastern Oregon is pro–Second Amendment… pro-life… against sanctuary state policies. But those policies get forced onto us from the west side of the state,” he said.
Several eastern Oregon counties, including Umatilla, have passed Second Amendment sanctuary ordinances aimed at limiting enforcement of state gun control laws, though some of these measures were later overturned by the Oregon Court of Appeals. The region has also formally opposed Oregon’s Sanctuary Promise Act, which limits local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. On social issues, Eastern Oregon demonstrates strong pro-life support, with the Diocese of Baker promoting pro-life values through its Respect Life Office and grassroots groups like the Eastern Oregon Pro-Life Advocates providing platforms for local advocacy on life issues from conception to natural death.
McCaw added that the movement is not about taking anything from Western Oregon, but about finding a government that aligns with local values.
“We just want to let it go so we can join a state that better matches our values,” he said.
McCaw described the broader regional differences, noting that the east side of the state has a different economy, culture, and politics from the west, which has long dominated Oregon’s policy decisions.
“The people of Eastern Oregon were…forced into association with Portland…And it's been a problem ever since, for 170 years,” he said.
The Greater Idaho campaign is not the only state independence campaign that believes Republicans are underrepresented in state governments. Other campaigns like New California are trying to create their own breakaway states after years of Democratic supermajorities in state legislatures.
But McCaw emphasized that the effort is not about party politics: “This isn’t about strengthening team red or team blue. This has everything to do with getting people in Eastern Oregon the kind of government that the vast majority actually want.”
‘Lower The Temperature’
McCaw insists that splitting the state could reduce tensions in a political climate that is intensely polarized.
He argues that friction arises when people with different values are forced under a single government.
“Political tension comes when people who don’t share our values are forcing things onto us,” he said. “If Eastern Oregon joined Idaho, that tension would go away.
“We’re too divided for blanket policies that try to cover everyone. Let people govern themselves locally—that’s the only way to lower the political temperature.”
For him, the campaign’s message reflects America’s founding principles: “Government by the people, for the people, with the consent of the people—that’s what this is about.”
Legal and Political Hurdles
But there still exists a big question as to whether the aims of the Greater Idaho campaign are actually feasible.
In recent years, residents in 13 Eastern Oregon counties have voted in favor of ballot measures supporting efforts to explore joining Idaho.
But two counties—Douglas and Josephine—rejected similar measures.
Meanwhile, every citizen-led effort to split or secede from a U.S. state has collapsed in modern history. Texas has repeatedly debated breaking into multiple states, but nothing has come of those discussions.
Legally, changing state borders is rare but not unprecedented. McCaw points to historical examples such as Maine separating from Massachusetts in 1820 and Oregon’s minor border adjustment with Washington in 1958.
“Any state can change its borders. There’s a long legal precedent for that—it’s happened dozens of times in U.S. history,” he said.
Despite these precedents, the proposal faces steep political barriers. Oregon lawmakers have twice refused to hold hearings on studying the idea.
And polls suggest mixed support for the campaign. A 2021 survey by the Oregon Values and Beliefs Center found 38 percent of Oregonians in favor, 42 percent opposed, with higher backing outside the Portland area (44 percent ) versus the metro area (37 percent). On the Idaho side, a Trafalgar Group poll reported that 53 percent of Idahoans believed their state should be prepared to negotiate annexation of Eastern Oregon counties.
Local Pushback
Steve Uffelman, a councilor in the City of Prineville, cited practical and logistical concerns, including strict water rights, the reliance of farms on water from the Deschutes River, and differences in infrastructure and education.
“Hundreds of acres of productive farmland will lose irrigation rights and tremendous value in addition to jobs lost. Oregon has better roads than Idaho as well as a better education system. We would lose out on both fronts,” he told Newsweek.
Uffelman also criticized the portrayal of cultural differences: “Their generalization is too simplistic and there are a great number of people living in Crook County with views similar to mine. The campaign focused on a few extreme issues but failed to give voters clear perspective of our losses as opposed to a few conservative political gains.”
He also questioned the broader impact on national cohesion, warning that the initiative could deepen political polarization.
“Is it just another way to divide America in an already polarized political climate? Yes, I personally believe it is and would not be beneficial to Crook County,” Uffelman said, noting that demographic and cultural shifts, including migration from urban areas and the growth of tech industry employment, are making some traditionally rural counties more politically mixed.
McCaw Confident the Campaign Can Succeed
But McCaw remains optimistic. He said the Greater Idaho Movement has appealed to the Trump administration for support, arguing that it is “not right for a state to hold its own citizens captive against their wishes.”
“We are confident that we will convince Idaho to accept our counties,” he said.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines