10

Loading video...

Elizabeth Hammack

By Elizabeth Hammack

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


California’s insurance market needs a regulatory overhaul that matches the risks Californians actually face.

That urgency is hard to ignore. The California Department of Insurance reported in October that 696,562 homeowner and commercial policies were in the FAIR Plan, the state’s insurer of last resort, as of June 2026. At the same time, 8 homeowners rate filings were under review.

The department has made meaningful progress, including catastrophe modeling and changes to rate review. But these steps are scaffolding around a structure built for another era.

Read More on News

The foundation is Proposition 103, approved by voters in 1988. Its prior-approval system was created to protect consumers from excessive rates and encourage competition. Those goals remain legitimate. The problem is that California is now trying to govern a radically different risk environment with rules designed nearly four decades ago.

Adaptation to a New Environment Needed

Wildfire exposure has changed. Catastrophe modeling has changed. The volume and complexity of insurance data have changed. Regulation has to change with them.

I welcome the recent reforms. Allowing better catastrophe data and more risk-based pricing can help insurers make rational decisions about where and how much coverage they can offer.

The Department of Insurance’s data show 12 homeowner insurance groups expanding in California, compared with none in 2025. That is movement in the right direction. But a soft thaw is not a healthy market.

That matters far beyond the insurance industry. When a homeowner cannot secure coverage, a mortgage can become harder to obtain. When a business cannot insure a building, vehicle, equipment, or employees, expansion can stall. When rebuilding becomes harder to finance, contractors lose work and communities recover more slowly.

Insurance is not a luxury purchased after everything else is secure; it is part of the machinery that allows households and local economies to function.

It is time to stop pretending that every insurance problem begins with an insurer being greedy. Political rhetoric that treats carriers as villains may be useful at election time, but it does not create coverage. When regulation makes it harder to price risk, carriers have fewer reasons to participate. Fewer carriers mean less supply, fewer choices, and ultimately greater pressure on prices.

Litigation Part of This Equation

Litigation is another part of this equation. The Insurance Information Institute has linked third-party litigation funding, attorney advertising, and other forms of legal-system maneuvering to higher claims costs and insurance prices. Its 2025 research notes that states including Indiana, Montana, West Virginia, Kansas, and Georgia have adopted litigation-funding disclosure requirements. California should not wait for a crisis to demand transparency.

California Wildfire in 2018: The state has been hit by multiple instances of damaging wildfires over the last two decades.

...

I learned firsthand how difficult reform can be. I drafted the California Insurance Market Reform Act to address some of the structural problems in the rate-review system, including the role of interveners that can prolong proceedings.

I withdrew the initiative after facing intense opposition and the prospect of a competing measure that could have made the market worse. The experience was frustrating, but it clarified something important: California’s insurance crisis is not merely technical, it's political.

The Importance of Independent Insurance Agencies

That is precisely why independent insurance agencies matter. As the principal and owner of one, I see every day how we sit between a complicated insurance market and the people who must live with its consequences. We are not middlemen. We are advisers, translators, and, in hard markets, shock absorbers.

Our job is not simply to sell a policy. It is to explain what it protects, what it does not, and why coverage can become harder to find when the underlying market breaks.

Policymakers should finish the job. Modernize the rate-review framework. Expand transparent use of credible catastrophe data. Reform litigation funding. And make consumer education part of the solution.

Get those pieces right, and the chain reaction is straightforward: modern rules encourage more carriers to participate; more participation creates competition; competition improves choice and value; and a functioning insurance market supports home sales, rebuilding, lending, businesses, and jobs.

Leave the foundation untouched, and California will keep adding scaffolding while more people stand outside the building.

Insurance reform is not a favor to insurers. It is economic infrastructure. California should treat it that way.

Elizabeth Hammack is an agency principal and head of network and strategic relationships at Panorama Insurance Associates, an insurance intermediary, and was the proponent of a withdrawn 2026 ballot initiative that would have replaced key elements of Proposition 103. The views expressed are the author's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines