
...

By Giulia Carbonaro
Senior Reporter
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
California’s gubernatorial candidates clashed Tuesday night over how to tackle the state’s home insurance crisis, as insurers continue pulling back from wildfire-prone areas and premiums rise sharply—an issue now central to the 2026 race.
Several major insurers have restricted coverage or stopped writing new policies in California in recent years, citing escalating wildfire risk, higher repair costs and strict state rules requiring regulators to approve significant rate increases.
The pullback has helped drive what critics describe as a breakdown in parts of the state’s home insurance market, leaving thousands of homeowners uninsured or facing nonrenewals. While regulators are moving to expand coverage and stabilize the system, relief has been slow to reach residents.
Read More on News
The issue took center stage during CBS News’ crowded California gubernatorial debate at Pomona College on Tuesday night, where candidates vying to replace Governor Gavin Newsom were pressed on how they would fix the crisis if elected.
The already contentious debate quickly descended into chaos, as candidates offered differing views on the topic and called each other out on solutions that they say would not be feasible.

...
Where California Governor Candidates Stand on Home Insurance
The debate on Tuesday night at Pomona College’s Bridges Auditorium was attended by half a dozen Democrats and two Republicans.
The Democratic field included progressive candidates Tom Steyer and Katie Porter, more moderate figures Xavier Becerra and Matt Mahan, as well as Antonio Villaraigosa and Tony Thurmond. The Republican candidates were Chad Bianco and Steve Hilton.
Here is what each said on home insurance, and how to fix the ongoing crisis in the state.
Xavier Becerra (D)
Becerra, former U.S. health secretary and California attorney general, said he would freeze home insurance rates if elected, but faced immediate pushback.
CBS News host Julie Watts noted that rates are set under state law and approved by the insurance commissioner, making such a move legally difficult.
Becerra said he would declare a state of emergency and direct the commissioner to freeze rates.
Pressed again on constitutionality, he said: “I’d be willing to go to court to tell you that I can call a freeze even if you’re telling me we can’t,” adding: “I’m calling for a freeze, I’m calling for an opportunity to sit everyone down. I’m calling for an opportunity to review behind the curtain what insurance companies are doing.”
He also said he would open an investigation into insurer practices.
Matt Mahan (D)
San Jose Mayor Mahan rejected Becerra’s proposal, saying it would not work and contributed to the current crisis.
“The government in Sacramento [where Becerra is from] created so many restrictions, including taking over a year to approve any rate changes, prohibiting insurance companies from using climate data to project future costs, that they stopped writing new policies,” he said.
Mahan said the solution is to bring insurers back, increase competition, and allow risk-based pricing, while also reducing wildfire risk through land management and vegetation clearing.
Steve Hilton (R)
Former Fox News commentator Hilton backed Mahan, saying he made the right points, but argued the issue is enforcement rather than new policy.
“The industry needs to be able to take account of future risk, including climate and the cost of reinsurance. That change, to be fair, has already been made by the current insurance commissioner,” he said.
“The point he makes about the speed of approval is exactly right. It does take over a year, but that’s a question of enforcing the law that is already there.”
He added that Proposition 103 includes a rule that rate changes should be approved in 60 days. “We just need to enforce that rule,” he said.
Antonio Villaraigosa (D)
Villaraigosa focused on reforming the California Fair Plan, the state’s insurer of last resort.
“My plan is to make sure that the Fair Plan, which is an unfair plan, not abiding by Prop 103, we got to make it work. Too many people in these fires weren’t compensated enough for their damages,” he said.
“We should bring insurance companies back by making the changes, but then we have to fix the Fair Plan,” he added before being interrupted by Becerra.
Tom Steyer (D)
Steyer said the state must reduce wildfire risk while working with insurers on pricing.
“That means making sure, at the macrobasis, to get rid of dry timber, that we do control burns, and also hardening the houses,” he said.
“We need to help people harden their houses and then we need to go to the insurance companies, the governor needs to go and say ‘This is the risk, we are going to let you make money, but you have to take into account the reduced risk that the government and the people of California have caused to happen.”
Tony Thurmond (D)
Thurmond said the state should restrict rate increases unless insurers continue offering coverage.
He accused companies of failing Californians and said he would use financial pressure to force compliance.
Katie Porter (D)
Porter criticized several rival proposals, calling Becerra’s approach “unconstitutional,” saying Mahan’s plan was already in place, and rejecting Villaraigosa’s Fair Plan expansion idea.
She instead proposed focusing on reinsurance costs.
“There are ways that we can put California state’s dollars at play to bring down the cost of reinsurance which would help more people come back into this market and write more affordable policies.”
Chad Bianco (R)
Riverside County Sheriff Bianco accused the other candidates of failing to address what he called “failed Democrat policies” behind the crisis, calling the Fair Plan an “absolute failure.”
“The insurance companies left because the insurance companies cannot be forced into bankruptcy by the state, they told the state it wasn’t global warming, it was a failed environmental policy that does not allow fire departments to prevent defendable space around our homes, or clear up the brush for 30 years.”
Bianco said he would stop “years of Democrat failure of regulations” in California, but did not specify how.
Which Plan Will Prevail?
The primary election for the gubernatorial race is just over a month away, but the race remains wide open.
The latest polling shows a fragmented field, with different candidates leading depending on the survey.
According to a YouGov poll conducted between April 23 and April 27, Hilton led with 16 percent of the vote, followed by Becerra with 21 percent, Steyer with 17 percent, Bianco with 15 percent, Mahan and Porter with 8 percent, Villaraigosa with 3 percent, and Thurmond with 2 percent.
An IVC media poll run between April 14 and 20 gave Becerra the lead with 23 percent, followed by Hilton with 20 percent, Bianco with 17 percent, Steyer with 14 percent, Porter with 11 percent, Mahan with 4 percent, and Villaraigosa and Thurmond with 1 percent.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines