Photo-illustration by Newsweek/Courtesy of Darren Schwartz

Darren Schwartz

By Darren Schwartz

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


In my 20s, with the assistance of a court-appointed confidential intermediary, I began to look for my birth parents. Those efforts paid off when my birth mother agreed to one anonymous conversation in 1995. I’d grown up in a loving household until things went south when my adoptive mother’s mental state collapsed and my adoptive father died of a heart attack when I was 11. Friends and family stepped in and did an admirable job of providing homes and shepherding me through adolescence, but a sense of disconnection and abandonment persisted. Although she would not reveal her name during that first phone call, hearing the voice of someone I shared DNA with was a profound moment. The type of information she conveyed prevented her unmasking—generalized revelations of what she studied in college, an admission to being married with children, but no names, ages, location. Some basic health potholes to watch out for. As for my father, she acknowledged he knew about the pregnancy, but as a college freshman, starting a family was not in her plans. When I asked the important question, I was thwarted.

“Will you tell me my father’s name?”

“No, I’m sorry I will not.”

Read More on My Turn

My 12-Year-Old Daughter Woke Up As Usual—That Same Day Life Changed Forever7 min read

My 12-Year-Old Daughter Woke Up As Usual—That Same Day Life Changed Forever

I Loved Tanning. 22 Years Later, I’m still Living With the Consequences9 min read

I Loved Tanning. 22 Years Later, I’m still Living With the Consequences

A Stranger Put $250 in My Kid’s Account. Twice4 min read

A Stranger Put $250 in My Kid’s Account. Twice

“Will you tell me your name?”

A long pause. I waited, hopeful.

“No.”

I hung up devastated and wanting more. I had a burning desire to fill the hole left by my adoptive father, Morry. But the trail was cold. My caseworker could not find the man listed in my adoption record and so she could not get permission to reveal his name to me.

Darren Schwartz as a boy with his adoptive father, Morry.

...

Then I thought back to my original conversations with my caseworker years earlier. Back then, she informed me there were two birth fathers named in my file. She explained that during my adoption process, my birth mother had lied to the office about my father’s identity. She was with her own mother at the time and didn’t want to admit she had been with a man she didn’t know well. To her credit, she called back before my birth to provide the second, and seemingly accurate, name. I had forgotten what at the time seemed like an odd tidbit.

The duality created a loophole. Without any other leads, I asked my caseworker to reach out to *Roger, the other man listed, and request he speak with me. I hoped he could provide some valuable direction for my search. I assumed he dated my mother, or at least he knew her. Otherwise, why would he have been chosen as the strawman? He may have even been in on the scheme originally, but now willing to give up the goods and help to find the real guy.

When we spoke, he dropped a bomb. He believed he was my dad. My head spun, trying to wrap my mind around a lifelong riddle that may have been abruptly solved. My heart raced as I listened for tonal similarities in our manner of speech. He described himself—eye color, hair color and height seemed like a match. I learned about him and his life. He even provided me with my mother’s name. Such a simple thing for most kids, but as an adoptee a nugget of gold decades in the making.

He explained that she did inform him of her pregnancy, but three months later, she recanted and said she had made it up. She then dumped him. He took her at her word and assumed the pregnancy never happened. He was devastated then but thrilled now.

Darren Schwartz Baby Photo

...

Roger and I spoke on a regular basis. I went to his home and met him, his wife and my new half-brother. He accepted me and desired to make up for lost years, excited to schedule a fishing trip for us with his father, my newly minted grandfather. However, after decades of dreaming about who the mystery man could be, and inventing unrealistic backstories that would offset the pain of abandonment, I felt disappointment. I wanted someone different—maybe a senator or a musician, some incredible and revered man. Adopted kids rarely fantasize they are the progeny of middle-management, but given no other options I leaned in.

My birth mother got wind that I connected with Roger. She called me, furious at being revealed. It had been three years since our previous conversation. It was strange to hear her voice again. She sounded the same, but anger had replaced genteel resistance.

“You know what? I told the agency Roger was not the right person! What have you done to that man?” she bellowed.

She didn’t grasp yet that contact with Roger began simply as part of my intel mission in lieu of her unwillingness. He believed firmly he was my father, and felt a profound sense of betrayal over lost years with his son. To him, she was the villain who hurt him through lies and mistreatment. Access to his identity was only possible because she provided it. She excoriated me for grasping for the secret we each claimed title to.

My chest pounded at the brow-beating. I squeezed the phone, knuckles white. Once again, I carried the burden of fault for being born, and did not have the right to know where I came from. As if my existence was parenthetical, and I needed to graciously accept whatever scraps the world threw my way. She set these things in motion.

“I gave you life,” she said sternly. “I’m sorry it didn’t turn out the way you wanted.”

It was her biggest trump card. Regardless of any misdirection and reticence, she chose to give me life. One could argue she could lie until her mouth bled, and it would still be outweighed by her decision to let me live.

I again asked for the name of the man who created me if in fact it wasn’t Roger.

She deflected, curious about my plans with him. I was honest, if not a little callous—if she told me the name of my father, then I would have no choice but to break things off with him. Somewhere in my mind a red flag went up foreseeing that uncomfortable and devastating conversation.

Four beats.

Coy, and a little cocky, she said, “Well, if you’re happy with Rocky, then stick with him,” using his nickname, a fond homage to their former relationship.

“I think you owe me the truth,” I said, emboldened.

“I think ‘owe’ is a little over the top,” she snapped. This lady dished some saucy repartee when she wasn’t yelling.

She continued, “I’m sure you sit there and say to yourself, ‘Why is she this way towards me?’”

She was right. Every Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, birthday and holiday, I longed for cards to and from a mom or dad. She held the keys to the kingdom, and all I needed was a name, just a few words said out loud.

“Sometimes I feel like I have no one,” I shared. Honest, but hoping it landed.

She sighed. “I’ll give you the name. And I’m really sorry I’m at a place I can’t say, ‘Darren, come into my life.’”

Her statement floored me. Under different circumstances she might have been open to a relationship.

I waited.

“Toby Miller, and that’s all I can tell you,” she said.

The name!

“Please close the book on me,” she said through tears. “I tried to do the right thing. I couldn’t have given you anything.”

Schwartz as an adult with his own son.

...

From the moment of conception, I may have been a source of anguish. Even post-birth, my potential reemergence had anxiously gestated for 29 years.

I asked her if there was any way it could be Roger. Her voice wavered as she stated her belief it was *Toby, but she wasn’t completely certain. She implored me to tie up loose ends with Rocky and acknowledged in many ways she had been unfair to me.

“And if somehow Roger is the father,” she continued, “which seems impossible, then he has my utmost apologies. Because if I ever thought, even for a second, that it was him, I would never have put you up for adoption.”

I teared up. Hearing the woman I had seen simply as a gateway to truth, and before that a canal to life, express maternal tenderness, hit me hard. I would have kept you. You would not have been cast out.

“Please clear this up with Roger.”

“I will,” I promised.

“Thank you. Have a nice life,” she said softly.

I hung up, dreading the conversation with Roger, but hopeful she had told the truth. Twenty-five years later a DNA testing kit confirmed she had.

As a parent now, I understand how difficult it can be balancing the demands of our children with what we believe is in their best interest, as well as our own. It was not an easy path, but my birth mother came through for me. I hope she is doing well.

*These names have been changed for privacy reasons.

Darren Schwartz is a business executive living in suburban Chicago. He recently completed a memoir and is working on his first novel.

All views expressed in this article are the author's own.

Do you have a personal essay you want to share with Newsweek? Send your story to MyTurn@newsweek.com.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines