10

Loading video...

Hannah Parry

By Hannah Parry

Associate News Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Former President Joe Biden has accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of bending democratic institutions to protect his personal interests, undermining Middle East peace efforts and displaying what he described as "Trump-like tendencies" in a remarkably candid account of their relationship.

In his forthcoming memoir, Promise Me, America, shared with Newsweek, Biden describes years of increasingly strained dealings with Netanyahu, including a heated exchange over Israeli settlements in the West Bank in which the former president refused to get up from his chair and told the Israeli leader: "Bibi, sit down."

"He and I could be direct with each other, but there wasn't a ton of trust," Biden writes of Netanyahu in excerpts reviewed by Newsweek. "I was also worried about Bibi's Trump-like tendencies. He could play fast and loose with the truth, and thought nothing of bending democratic institutions to serve his personal needs."

Read More on News

Biden points specifically to Netanyahu's 2023 push to overhaul Israel's judiciary, writing that despite holding "a thin electoral majority," the prime minister had quickly sought to weaken the Supreme Court "in order to prevent it from looking into his unsavory financial dealings."

Newsweek has reached out to Netanyahu's office for comment.

This combination image shows, from left; President Joe Biden, on March 12, 2020, in Wilmington, Delaware, and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on October 28, 2023, in Tel Aviv, Israel.

...

'Bibi, Sit Down': Biden's Confrontation With Netanyahu

Biden portrays Netanyahu as a political operator who was willing to undermine diplomatic breakthroughs and alienate allies to advance his own political interests.

He recounts a previously unreported confrontation during a trip to Israel while he was vice president, when Netanyahu repeatedly urged him to approach a conference room window to see how close Israeli settlements in the West Bank were to Jerusalem.

"Mr. Vice President, come to the window, let me show you," Netanyahu told him, according to Biden.

But Biden refused to get up.

"Bibi, sit down," he recalls replying. "I've been to the window, I've heard the stories. You have to do what's right, and what's right for Israel is to get back to the peace process and a two-state solution."

Biden also writes that Netanyahu's approval of 5,700 Israeli settlement building permits in the early summer of 2023 dealt a significant blow to his administration's efforts to secure a historic normalization agreement between Israel and Saudi Arabia.

The former president suggests the agreement may have been "only weeks away" before the October 7 attacks derailed the diplomatic initiative.

Biden Says Netanyahu 'Close to Dereliction of Duty' Over October 7

Biden offers a particularly sharp assessment of Netanyahu's leadership following Hamas' October 7 attack, which killed around 1,200 people in Israel and saw approximately 250 others taken hostage.

He writes that Netanyahu had long presented himself as uniquely capable of protecting Israelis from their enemies, a reputation that had helped him survive repeated corruption scandals.

But the attack, Biden argues, exposed a catastrophic failure of that promise.

"Now, he was exposed for failing to do precisely what he had promised," Biden writes. "Even in the earliest minutes, I had a feeling that his response would be overwhelming—to compensate for what was close to dereliction of duty on his part."

Biden also reveals that American intelligence assessments on the morning of the attack described Israel's military as "on its back foot, disoriented and in disarray," while its air defenses were "not at full strength."

Related Story

Five Ways Israel’s Election Results Could Change America’s Future

Five Ways Israel’s Election Results Could Change America’s Future

Related Story

Pro-Palestinian Demonstration Hits NYC On Veterans Day: ‘Day of Rage’

Pro-Palestinian Demonstration Hits NYC On Veterans Day: ‘Day of Rage’

Had Iran and Hezbollah launched a coordinated attack alongside Hamas, Biden writes, "it could have been an existential blow to Israel."

Four days after the attack, on October 11, Biden says he intervened to prevent a potentially much wider regional conflict.

Israeli officials believed Hezbollah was preparing a major cross-border assault from Lebanon, and Israeli fighter jets were already airborne for a pre-emptive strike targeting Hezbollah's leadership, Biden writes.

"I urged Bibi to stand down," Biden writes of his conversation with Netanyahu and Israel's war Cabinet. "'You're guaranteeing a Middle East war if you do this.'"

Netanyahu ultimately took his advice and ordered the aircraft to turn around midair.

"It was the right call, at a precarious moment," Biden writes.

Biden Says Netanyahu Put Political Survival Ahead of Israel

Despite his longstanding support for Israel, Biden writes that his relationship with Netanyahu became increasingly difficult after the prime minister returned to office in late 2022.

Biden recalls occasionally getting into "mild trouble" as a senator for describing himself as a Zionist and taking his family to visit the Dachau concentration camp. But he says his responsibilities as president required him to confront what he increasingly viewed as damaging decisions by Israel's leadership.

"My job as president of the United States was to support America's interests and America's allies. Every democratic country gets to choose its leader, and I work with those leaders," Biden writes.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, right, speaks as he meets with President Joe Biden on October 18, 2023, in Tel Aviv, Israel.

...

"Increasingly, since Netanyahu's return to power at the end of 2022, I felt that the work of protecting Israel meant protecting it both from its enemies and itself."

Biden also criticizes Netanyahu's conduct of the war in Gaza, accusing him of making promises to limit Palestinian civilian casualties that he had no intention of keeping.

"Bibi had no qualms about making promises he had no power—or intention—to keep," Biden writes.

"While I understood that he was working under severe pressures, I was frustrated by his failure to think like a statesman and safeguard Israel's long-term interests, not just his own short-term political needs."

Biden's Complicated Legacy With Israel

Biden's account highlights the increasingly strained relationship between Washington and Netanyahu during the final years of his presidency, even as the United States continued providing Israel with substantial military assistance following the October 7 attacks.

The mounting civilian death toll in Gaza created growing divisions within Biden's own Democratic Party, prompting protests and uncommitted voting campaigns during the 2024 presidential primaries.

Netanyahu also repeatedly resisted American pressure over ceasefire negotiations, humanitarian aid deliveries and plans for Gaza's postwar governance.

In Promise Me, America, Biden presents his approach as an effort to maintain America's longstanding commitment to Israel while confronting what he saw as decisions by Netanyahu that threatened the country's security, democratic institutions and international standing.

The memoir is scheduled for release on Tuesday, by Little, Brown and Company.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Tony Phillips.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines