10
Loading video...

By Tom O'Connor
Deputy Editor, National Security and Foreign Policy
0
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
With international shipping already facing historic strains as a result of the crisis in the Middle East, one set of disruptors has found an opportunity to capitalize.
Piracy off the coast of Somalia has surged to levels not seen since 2013.
Hotspots include the very same waters that constitute a major theater of the U.S.-Iran war, in which Yemen's Tehran-aligned Ansar Allah movement, widely known as the Houthis, has targeted vessels from the other side of the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden, while the Islamic Republic wields leverage over the Strait of Hormuz chokepoint.
Read More on Analysis
Somali pirates don't appear to be taking sides, however. They've targeted vessels from the U.S., Iran and an array of other nations in what appears to be a comeback for a global challenge that once united the world's leading powers.
"Somali piracy is an opportunistic crime," Ken Menkhaus, professor at Davidson College and former special political adviser in the U.N. Operation in Somalia, told Newsweek. "It flourished when piracy was low-risk, high-reward."
"Right now, we've got a perfect storm of factors that are making it lower risk than it had been," he said.

...
Problems from the Persian Gulf to Puntland
One of the key factors Menkhaus identified as fueling the renewed Somali pirate threat was the diversion of naval forces toward addressing maritime threats directly linked to the ongoing Middle East conflict.
"We've got naval patrols in the Gulf of Aden and Indian Ocean that are preoccupied with Houthi threats to shipping lanes in the Gulf of Aden and Red Sea, and as well in the Strait of Hormuz," Menkhaus said. "So, there's international inattention."
At the same time, he pointed out that unrest in northeastern Somalia's semi-autonomous Puntland region that straddles the Horn of Africa is also contributing to the breakdown in order at sea.
Local forces have been stretched thin between engaging in political clashes involving the central government and waging operations against the Somali wing of the Islamic State militant group, also known as ISIS-Somalia, or IS-Somalia.
"The government in Mogadishu has deployed and recruited troops in Puntland, weakening Puntland’s maritime operations," Mohamed Daud Ismail, senior research assistant at the Armed Conflict Location and Event Data (ACLED) monitor, told Newsweek.
"Another reason is Puntland’s counter-insurgency operation targeting the Islamic State of Somalia Province in the mountainous ranges of the Bari region," Ismail said. "Puntland forces have focused more on operations against IS and on resolving disputes with the federal government. As a result, pirates have taken advantage of the security vacuum."
The resulting intensification of Somali piracy, Ismail warned, could serve as "a severe force multiplier for the global maritime industry."
"Because multinational naval coalitions are heavily committed to intercepting drone and missile threats in the Red Sea and managing escalating tensions around the Strait of Hormuz," he said, "reallocating surface combatants and patrol aircraft back across the vast Somali Basin creates dangerous security gaps in both theaters."

...
Where Crises Converge
The Gulf of Aden is not the only link between Somalia and Yemen. Ansar Allah, which now effectively controls the Yemeni side of the Bab el-Mandeb Strait between the Gulf of Aden and Red Sea, has long been suspected of fostering tacit ties with armed non-state actors in Somalia.
Among these groups is Al-Shabab. While the Al-Qaeda-affiliated organization's jihadi Sunni Islamist doctrine directly clashes with Ansar Allah's revolutionary Zaidi Shiite Muslim revivalist ideology, reports have identified some areas of common interest that may tie in the piracy problem as well.
"The Houthis and Al-Shabab have also been linked to efforts to train and supply Somali pirates," Michael DeAngelo, Africa analyst at the American Enterprise Institute's Critical Threats Project, told Newsweek. "Al-Shabab has long-standing ties to piracy networks, and the Houthis may be leveraging their own growing ties to Al-Shabab to support the pirates in disrupting shipping through the Red Sea."
Both factions thrive in chaos. And what DeAngelo described as a spike in "lucrative ransom payouts from hijackings" between 2024 and 2026 in the region may only serve to establish further grounds for collaboration.
Meanwhile, Tehran may stand to benefit as well.
Christopher Hockey, a Kenya-based senior research fellow at the Royal United Services Institute, argued that "the real story right now is the convergence of threat actors in the Gulf of Aden, and the blurring of lines between conflicts in the Horn and those in the Arabian Peninsula—and potentially Iranian influence over it all."
"Al-Shabab, the Houthis, Islamic State, organized criminals, and pirates are all operating in the Gulf of Aden, taking advantage of the same illicit networks—and driven by overlapping interests," Hockey told Newsweek.
Even if the many other divergences in beliefs, objectives and tactics ultimately prevent any true coalescence among these actors, the result may prove the same.
"Whether or not these relationships involve direct coordination is perhaps not significant," Hockey said. "Insecurity in the Gulf of Aden stretches the limited resources available to naval operations also trying to respond to Houthi attacks in the southern Red Sea and to the chaos in the Strait of Hormuz. "
"Ultimately, Iran and its allies are able to disrupt maritime trade across a vast geography and through two of the world's most critical waterways," Hockey said.

...
Short on Solutions
Geopolitical tensions rocking the international order may also serve to prevent the kind of global unity that once helped put an end to the last Somali piracy epidemic.
Beginning in late 2008 and expanding significantly in 2009, deteriorating maritime security conditions off Somalia prompted an unprecedented international counter-piracy effort, bringing together major powers, including the U.S., China and Russia.
To this day, China, India, Japan, Russia and South Korea continue to deploy naval forces in the waters surrounding Somalia, while the European Union maintains its dedicated Operation Atalanta counter-piracy mission. The U.S. also participates in regional counter-piracy operations through Combined Task Force 151, part of the multinational Combined Maritime Forces.
Yet Menkhaus was skeptical that the level partnership achieved in the past could be replicated in today's global security environment.
"I think it's going to be much more difficult now, much more fraught," Menkhaus said.
Rather, he predicted a response would involve greater reliance on armed private security contractors, a practice he credited with likely playing an even more effective role in deterring pirates in the past than warships.
That doesn't mean hired guns will be enough to root out the problem today. Menkhaus identified a threefold combination of extreme poverty, poor governance and an entrenched culture of extracting tolls from land and sea routes that makes Somalia an especially attractive hub for pirates.
Moreover, alternative sources of income are becoming more difficult to come by in Somalia.
"The root causes of piracy in Somalia are primarily local factors related to illegal and unregulated fishing from foreign trawlers off the Somali coast that undermines local livelihoods," Omar Mahmood, senior analyst for Somalia and the Horn of Africa at the International Crisis Group, told Newsweek.
"While pirate groups feed off this dynamic, they are also fundamentally criminal actors that strike when they see opportunity," Mahmood said.
The explosion of insecurity plaguing maritime passageways in the Middle East "provided precisely such an opportunity," he pointed out, with counter-piracy naval patrols redeployed north of Somalia and commercial traffic redirected south toward the pirates' hunting grounds. The result, he argued, "was more targets and less policing, giving the pirate groups an opportunity to revive their trade."
Today, the scale of incidents remains far from their 2011 peak. Somali authorities and international partners have mobilized efforts to contain the outbreak.
Even so, however, Mahmood predicted piracy would persist in the seas off Somalia.
"We should expect episodic attacks to continue, in part because the criminal groups are not fully dismantled and the broader root causes around local fishing livelihoods remain unaddressed," Mahmood said. "Even small cycles of attack, however, can increase insurance premiums while pushing commercial traffic to take longer routes."
"The net effect is to add costs to a shipping industry that is already reeling from restrictions from other crucial maritime passageways," he added.
Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Samantha Beech and Tony Phillips.
View 0 Comments
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines