An Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent stand guard as protestors gather at Delaney Hall which is being used as an ICE detention center in Newark, New Jersey, on May 26, 2026. According to US media reports, demonstrators clashed with federal agents over the holiday weekend over alledged poor living conditions inside the detention facility.

...

Billal Rahman

By Billal Rahman

Immigration Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A federal appeals court has dealt a significant setback to the Trump administration's mass immigration detention strategy, ruling that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) cannot hold certain migrants for more than 90 days without giving them an opportunity to seek release on bond.

The decision could affect thousands of migrants detained in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi under a policy adopted by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in 2025. The policy expanded the use of mandatory detention for noncitizens living in the United States who entered the country without being formally admitted. A bond hearing allows an immigration judge to determine whether a migrant can be released while their case proceeds.

The 2-1 ruling by the New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals arrives as immigration detention has become an increasingly central feature of the Trump administration's enforcement agenda. ICE has expanded arrests across the country and increased detention capacity, while officials have argued that mandatory detention is necessary to ensure migrants appear for immigration proceedings and can be removed if ordered deported.

Read More on News

Newsweek has contacted DHS, which oversees ICE, for comment via email.

An Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent stands guard as protesters gather at Delaney Hall, which is being used as an ICE detention center in Newark, New Jersey, on May 26.

...

Appeals Court Caps Detention at 90 Days

Writing for the majority, Circuit Judge Leslie Southwick said the Constitution's guarantee of due process extends to long-term residents living in the United States, even if they entered the country unlawfully and were never formally admitted. The court concluded that migrants detained under federal immigration law must receive a bond hearing within 90 days if the government wants to continue detaining them.

"The Government may detain aliens under Section 1225(b)(2)(A) for 90 days but no longer without a bond hearing," the court wrote.

The case involved three migrants—two from Mexico and one from Honduras—who had each lived in the United States for more than a decade, had no criminal records and were fathers of U.S. citizen children. They were detained by ICE following traffic stops in Texas and challenged their continued detention through petitions for habeas corpus.

"These three aliens, who many years ago entered this country without inspection and have been residing here for years, who have no criminal history, and who, as far as we have been informed, have not yet been subject to a removal order, would today have been detained by immigration authorities for an unreasonable time absent the district courts' intervention," the court wrote.

ICE Arrests Surge Nationwide

According to The New York Times, federal agents made roughly 10,000 immigration arrests over a five-day period in June as part of an expanded crackdown targeting migrants without legal status.

The ruling marks the latest chapter in a legal battle over the administration's effort to reinterpret immigration law to place a broader category of migrants into mandatory detention. In February, a separate 5th Circuit panel became the first federal appeals court to uphold the administration's interpretation that migrants who entered without inspection remain "applicants for admission" and therefore can be subjected to mandatory detention during removal proceedings.

When the Board of Immigration Appeals endorsed that interpretation, immigration judges across the country began ordering mandatory detention, setting up a legal dispute that the Trump administration has now asked the Supreme Court to resolve.

But Thursday's decision addressed a constitutional question left unresolved by that earlier ruling: whether the Fifth Amendment requires those detainees to receive an opportunity to seek release before an immigration judge.

Court Split on Migrants' Rights

Southwick said Supreme Court precedent makes it clear that due process protections apply to people who have established significant ties inside the United States.

The court stopped short of striking down the detention statute itself. Instead, it held that after 90 days, the government must provide an individualized hearing and explain why continued detention is necessary, citing factors such as danger to the community or risk of flight.

Judge James Graves agreed with the outcome but said the majority did not go far enough. In a separate opinion, he argued that detainees should receive hearings within 30 days and that future detainees should receive greater procedural protections before being held.

Judge Cory Wilson dissented, arguing that Congress has broad authority over immigration matters and that migrants classified as applicants for admission are entitled only to the procedures provided by statute. He said the majority was improperly imposing requirements that Congress had not enacted.

"Today's decision deputizes every district court in our circuit to refashion the removal process as it sees fit, inviting even more chaos into our circuit's overwhelmed immigration dockets," Wilson wrote. "And it unleashes this mischief while admitting that, even under its confected standard, at least two of the three Petitioners' habeas claims should have been denied by the district courts."

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Matthew Robinson and Shakeema Edwards.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines