10

Loading video...

Charles Riva

By Charles Riva

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Art is becoming a popularity contest, and the art world is in danger of losing its ability to tell the difference between what deserves attention, and what deserves to endure.

Humanity remembers itself through the medium of art. Its stakes stretch far beyond the theater of auction rooms or the prestige of galleries. Art anchors civilizations, defies political dogma, and captures raw social anxiety, leaving an unvarnished window for the generations to follow.

The work we choose to celebrate today becomes part of the cultural inheritance we leave tomorrow.

Read More on Leadership Insights

Yet right now, that choice is being influenced by an uncomfortable combination of auction prices, social media visibility, celebrity endorsements, and market speculation.

Skagen, Denmark, June 2, 2025. A man sits in the Skagen Art Museum.

...

Every one of us lives downstream of it. Museums hang what the market crowns, textbooks teach what museums hang, and the culture your children inherit gets assembled from whatever survived the selection.

Art is how a society remembers itself, so whoever picks the winners edits our collective memory.

I have watched this shift unfold, and I believe the industry has become dangerously comfortable confusing commercial success with artistic significance.

The 2026 Art Basel and UBS Art Market Report shared that global art sales reached $59.6 billion in 2025, a 4 percent increase from the previous year. Yet post-war and contemporary auction sales fell for the fourth consecutive year, reaching $4.5 billion, while contemporary art alone remained at $1.4 billion.

The market is moving, but its confidence in contemporary production remains uneven.

What's the Problem?

Part of the problem lies in how we have tried to predict the next generation of collectors. The industry spent years courting younger audiences, particularly Gen Z, attempting to anticipate their tastes and manufacture demand around emerging artists.

Galleries adjusted their programs, collectors followed the excitement, and social media accelerated the cycle. Some artists enjoyed extraordinary attention, only to lose their market position almost as quickly.

I can perceive the effects within today’s auction landscape. At recent major sales, I have been struck by how little representation younger contemporary artists receive.

Capital is gravitating towards established names, particularly Impressionist, Modern, and historically recognized contemporary artists.

The psychology is familiar, where uncertainty pushes investors towards assets they believe they can evaluate.

In art, that means an established artist with museum recognition, a documented body of work, and a finite production history can feel like a safer proposition than an emerging name whose reputation is still being formed.

But safety has its price. If everyone invests in what has already been validated, who takes the risk of recognizing what could become important?

The Role of Social Media

I have always believed that an artist’s technical command and originality matter far more than the immediate market response.

An artist who pushes the boundaries of their medium, develops a distinctive visual language, and creates something genuinely compelling has a proposition that extends beyond the next auction cycle.

A high price can tell you what someone was willing to pay. It cannot tell you what a work means.

Social media, of course, has a valuable role. I have discovered interesting emerging artists through Instagram and encountered work I might otherwise have missed. It has made discovery faster and more accessible.

But repeated exposure can manufacture familiarity, and familiarity can easily be mistaken for appreciation. Seeing an artist everywhere does not make the work exceptional.

At some point, collectors must ask themselves a more difficult question: Do I actually like this work, or have I just been persuaded that I should?

Artificial intelligence is adding another dimension to this problem. I often use AI to examine provenance, compare works, assess pricing, and research auction histories.

It can make the market more transparent and competitive, giving buyers access to information that once required extensive professional networks.

Yet there is a danger in allowing a machine to become the final authority on artistic judgement. AI can evaluate available evidence; it cannot replace the human experience of standing before a painting and understanding why it moves you.

Competing Pressures

The art market is currently split between two competing pressures: Genuine artistic discovery and commercial predictability.

On one side, galleries can champion unconventional talent, collectors can exercise independent judgment, and institutions can preserve work that challenges the cultural consensus.

On the other, algorithms increasingly dictate visibility, speculative buying steers creative direction, and proven formulas are repeated until originality is sidelined.

How the industry balances these forces will determine whether it leaves future generations a meaningful cultural record or simply an archive of what sold.

The decisions made by a handful of influential collectors and auction houses can shape which voices enter museums, which stories survive, and which artistic movements receive historical recognition.

The responsibility now sits with those who have the power to change the market. Collectors must buy with conviction. Galleries must take risks on artists whose significance has yet to be commercially established.

Auction houses must recognize their influence beyond the hammer price, and cultural institutions must defend their curatorial independence.

Will This Matter in 50 Years?

I would challenge the industry’s leaders to put one question at the centre of every exhibition and institutional decision: Will this matter in 50 years, or does it simply matter today?

If we cannot distinguish between the two, we are not building an art world. We are curating a marketplace of temporary attention. And future generations will inherit the consequences of that failure.

Your eye is the last curator still working for free. Use it.

Charles Riva is an influential French-Italian art collector, advisor and dealer with galleries in New York, London, and Paris. All views are his own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines