Katherine Fung

By Katherine Fung

Senior Writer

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Two shootings less than two weeks apart have exposed the difference in how America responds to gun violence, depending on who it targets.

While top executives of multibillion-dollar companies beefed up security and canceled in-person meetings in the wake of the assassination of UnitedHealth CEO Brian Thompson earlier this month in New York City, students and teachers were offered little more than the typical outpouring of "thoughts and prayers" after the latest school shooting this week.

On Monday, a familiar story played out in Wisconsin, where a 15-year-old student opened fire at Abundant Life Christian School, a small nondenominational school in Madison, killing another teenager and a teacher. This time, a second grader made the 911 call that sent police swarming to Abundant Life. By the time they arrived, the shooter, whom officials identified as a 15-year-old girl, was dead of a self-inflicted gunshot wound.

Read More on Politics

Emergency vehicles are parked outside the Abundant Life Christian School in Madison, Wis., following a shooting, Monday, Dec. 16, 2024. The parents of the alleged shooter are not currently being charged over the attack.

...

"My sincere condolences and prayers for all the victims of the tragedy at Abundant Life Christian School," Wisconsin Senator Ron Johnson, a Republican, said on X, formerly Twitter. His Democratic colleague, Wisconsin Senator Tammy Baldwin, wrote that her "heart goes out to all those impacted."

The newest member of the Wisconsin congressional delegation, Representative Tony Wied, who was elected last month in a special election filling the vacancy left by Representative Mike Gallagher, also said he was "devastated by the news" and his "prayers are with the victims and their families" while thanking law enforcement.

It was a recognizable, if rote, reaction to an event that has become almost mundane in America: students and teachers gunned down in their schools—places where they are supposed to be safe.

In stark contrast, the December 4 shooting of Thompson shocked the country and sent corporate America scrambling. The biggest health insurers moved immediately to take down information about their top executives from company websites, temporarily closed headquarters and expanded armed security protection for their C-suites.

Dale Buckner, the CEO of Global Guardian, which received requests from 47 companies for additional executive security in the immediate aftermath of Thompson's assassination, told CNN, "This is a bellwether moment and a shift."

But that tipping point has not yet come to America's schools.

According to an analysis by the gun-violence prevention organization Everytown for Gun Safety, gun violence on K-12 school grounds rose by 31 percent last school year, the second-highest number of incidents since Everytown began tracking gun violence at schools a decade ago, in response to the horrific massacre of elementary-age children at Sandy Hook.

UnitedHeathcare CEO shooting video

...

With lawmakers scheduled to break for the holidays on Friday, it's unlikely that any kind of gun reform will pass before Republicans take control in the new year—nor is it obvious how even stricter gun laws would have stopped either the Thompson or Abundant Life shootings. The UnitedHealth CEO was killed by what police say was unserialized, 3D-printed gun. The firearm used in Madison on Monday is believed to be a legally purchased 9 mm handgun.

For a problem as vexing as school shootings, without the political will in Washington, school administrators and educators will have to continue to do their best with the resources they have to protect themselves and their classrooms from gunfire. Those resources range from active-shooter drills, which many argue do more harm than good, to pressing for bulletproof safe rooms and more armed personnel on school grounds.

View this post on X

"At the end of the day, no one is safe from gun violence in America," said Natalie Fall, the executive director for March For Our Lives, told Newsweek.

"While a select few of us, those with money and power, will try to buy safety the fact is that none of us are truly safe when guns flow freely with few guardrails," Fall said.

"Beefing up security is a mirage, just as 'hardening' schools is. If the Secret Service can't protect the U.S. president from gun violence, armed teachers or guards don't stand a chance at protecting children and private citizens in a nation with far more guns than people."

Nicole Hockley, cofounder and co-CEO of Sandy Hook Promise, called it "heartbreaking" to see another school shooting just two days after commemorating the 12th anniversary of the tragedy in Newton, Connecticut, that shook America.

"There is absolutely no place for gun violence in our schools and we owe it to our children to ensure their safety in schools, homes, and communities. It's crucial that we bring awareness to the fact that school shootings are preventable when we know the warning signs," Hockley, who lost her youngest son, Dylan, in the Sandy Hook Elementary School tragedy, told Newsweek.

15obamaspeech

...

Gun-safety advocates say that Monday's shooting highlights the ongoing need to prioritize safety and preparedness in schools in an America that is armed to its teeth. Ivo Allen, the CEO of notification and security platform 911inform, warned that schools, workplaces and communities need to be able to access resources like the technologies that 911inform deploys in hopes of avoiding tragedies like the one in Wisconsin.

"While there's no one solution that can fully prevent these tragedies, investing in advanced preparedness measures, from mental health resources to safety technology, can make a meaningful difference," Allen told Newsweek on Monday.

Allen said the disparity in resources available to protect perhaps a couple hundred of well-paid executives versus millions of school children "reflects the broader challenge of ensuring every child has access to a safe learning environment."

"It's not a matter of feasibility but of prioritization," Allen said. "Schools often operate with limited funding, making it difficult to implement comprehensive safety measures like corporations may be able to, despite the critical importance of protecting millions of students."

He called for greater investments in grant programs and public-private partnerships, which could help equip schools with the tools and resources needed and ensure that the collective goal of protecting children would be supported at every level.

On Monday, Fall called for Congress to "urgently" address the "lax gun laws that allow dangerous people to carry out acts of violence, no matter the motive or setting."

"These tragedies aren't inevitable—they're the result of choices made by lawmakers who prioritize gun industry profits over our children's lives. It doesn't have to be this way—our children deserve better, they deserve to live," Angela Ferrell-Zabala, the executive director of Moms Demand Action, echoed in a statement.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines