A copy of the Shroud of Turin

...

Maria Azzurra Volpe

By Maria Azzurra Volpe

Reporter

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


A newly discovered medieval document has revealed that the authenticity of the Shroud of Turin—14-foot linen cloth that many believe wrapped the crucified body of Jesus—was being called into question perhaps as early as 1355.

The text—analyzed in the Journal of Medieval History—has been dated to between 1355 and 1382 (but most likely was penned after 1370, say researchers.)

It reveals that respected Norman theologian Nicole Oresme (who would became the Bishop of Lisieux, France) dismissed the Shroud as a "clear" and "patent" fake, the result of deceptions by "clergy men".

Read More on Science

His writings, now considered the oldest written rejection of the relic, predate the previous earliest documented criticism by the Bishop of Troyes, Pierre d'Arcis, in 1389.

The bishop also rejected the Shroud as a fraud and reported that a predecessor of his had done likewise in around 1355.

Oresme's document, found by renowned historians Alain Boureau and Béatrice Delaurenti, accuses clergy of fabricating "miracles" to solicit offerings for their churches, citing the Shroud displayed in Lirey, France, as an example.

A copy of the Shroud of Turin

...

"Nicole Oresme did not choose just any venerated object as an example of a fraud orchestrated by the clergy. Oresme chose the claim of the Champenoise (Lirey) shrine to possess the Shroud as a striking example of lies fabricated by the clergy," said paper author and historian Nicolas Sarzeaud of the Université Catholique of Louvain, in Belgium, in a statement.

"What makes Oresme's writing stand out is his attempt to provide rational explanations for unexplained phenomena, rather than interpreting them as divine or demonic. The philosopher even rated witnesses according to factors such as their reliability, and also cautioned against rumour", she said.

Sarzeaud believes that Oresme learned of the Lirey fraud while serving as a scholar and royal counselor in the 1350s. The Shroud had been displayed in Lirey until around 1355, when the Bishop of Troyes ordered its removal following investigations that revealed staged miracles and paid actors.

It remained hidden for decades until Pope Clement VII allowed it to be displayed again under the strict condition that it was to be shown as a "representation" of the original Shroud and not the genuine article.

The Shroud was then formally announced as a fake in a memorandum for Pope Clement VII in 1389. The bishop even asked Charles VI of France to halt further displays of the Shroud, referring to it as "a manufactured cloth, artificially portrayed."

"The Shroud is the most documented case of a forged relic in the Middle Ages, and one of the few examples of a cult denounced and stopped by the Church and clerics," Sarzeaud added.

Bearing a faint image of the front and back of a naked man, consistent with traditional depictions of Jesus after his crucifixion, the Shroud has long been subject to controversy, though many still believe in its authenticity.

Previous radiocarbon dating places its origins at the end of the 13th or 14th century, and a 3D analysis recently published in the journal Archaeometry concluded the cloth had been wrapped around a sculpture, rather than Jesus' body.

Professor Andrea Nicolotti, a lead Shroud expert and Professor of History of Christianity and Churches, at the University of Turin, says that Oresme's document adds "further historical evidence that even in the Middle Ages, they knew that the Shroud was not authentic".

"Oresme's opinion is very important because it comes from a person who was not personally involved in the dispute—and therefore had no interest in supporting his own position", he said.

Do you have a tip on a science story that Newsweek should be covering? Do you have a question about the Shroud? Let us know via science@newsweek.com.

References

Moraes, C. (2025). Image Formation on the Holy Shroud—A Digital 3D Approach. Archaeometry. https://doi.org/10.1111/arcm.70030

Sarzeaud, N. (2025). A New Document on the Appearance of the Shroud of Turin from Nicole Oresme: Fighting False Relics and False Rumours in the Fourteenth Century. Journal of Medieval History. https://doi.org/10.1080/03044181.2025.2546884

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines