10

Loading video...

Jenni Fink

By Jenni Fink

Senior Editor

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


Andrea Faust, a North Carolina mother accused of killing her 3-year-old son and attempting to kill her 2-year-old, wants to pursue an insanity defense, creating the potential for another high-profile mental health case as the Lindsay Clancy case unfolds in Massachusetts.

Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse, has been charged with the murder of her three children. Clancy is currently on trial for their deaths and the case has captured national attention as her defense rests on not guilty by reason of insanity. While the facts of the two cases differ significantly, both have centered on questions about severe mental illness, competency, criminal responsibility, and whether psychiatric disorders can absolve defendants of legal culpability.

Clancy's case has called attention to the lack of adequate maternal health care and the struggles women encounter postpartum. It's possible Faust's case will continue to shed a spotlight on different mental health issues as she heads to trial in October.

Read More on News

"Andrea and Lindsay’s cases are eerily similar, though not entirely the same," Nicole Gallinsky, Andrea's lawyer, told Newsweek. "Both women were known to be loving, doting, responsible mothers who were worried about and caring for their children up until the very-second they decided to kill them."

Newsweek reached out to the prosecutor's office for comment.

Who Is Andrea Faust?

Faust, 41, is a Durham, North Carolina, mother charged with first-degree murder and attempted first-degree murder after authorities said they found her two children unresponsive inside the family's home on February 12, according to court records reviewed by Newsweek.

According to Durham police, officers responded to a home on Chartwell Court after reports of a medical emergency. Both children, Percy and Kenny, were transported to a hospital. Percy later died, while Kenny survived and was expected to recover, according to statements made in court by Faust's husband, Eric Faust.

The case quickly drew widespread attention after Eric described the incident in court as a severe mental health crisis rather than an act that reflected his wife's normal behavior. Eric praised Andrea as a mother and begged her in court not to harm herself for the sake of her family.

Andrea Faust is pictured in a circle insert and Lindsay Clancy, who is on trial for killing her kids, is pictured in the main image.

...

Court records show Andrea allegedly attempted suicide multiple times while in custody, including one incident that resulted in serious injuries requiring surgery. Authorities later said she was found hoarding Tylenol that officials believed she intended to use to harm herself.

In March, a judge ruled Faust was incapable of proceeding to trial and ordered her transferred to Central Regional Hospital in Butner, North Carolina, for inpatient psychiatric treatment and evaluation. The court found she posed a danger to herself and required intensive mental health care before criminal proceedings could continue.

On Tuesday, her attorney, Nicole Gallinsky, indicated they intend to pursue an insanity defense, according to court records reviewed by Newsweek. It signaled that Andrea's mental state at the time of the alleged crimes will likely become a central issue if the case ultimately reaches trial.

The insanity defense is rarely used and succeeds in only a small percentage of criminal cases. Generally, defendants must prove they suffered from a severe mental disease or defect that prevented them from understanding the nature or wrongfulness of their actions at the time the crimes were committed.

Gallinsky said the case can move forward once a psychiatrist from Central Regional Hospital is able to give their opinion on Andrea's state of mind.

How Is Andrea Faust's Case Similar to Lindsay Clancy's

Comparisons between Faust and Clancy have emerged because both cases involve mothers accused of killing or attempting to kill their children while defense teams point to serious mental health conditions.

Clancy's attorneys argue she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and could not appreciate the wrongfulness of her actions. Like Faust, Clancy allegedly attempted suicide after the deaths of her children, leaving her paralyzed from the waist down.

Related Story

Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial: Key Revelations From Wednesday

Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial: Key Revelations From Wednesday

Clancy's defense has specifically focused on postpartum psychosis, a rare psychiatric emergency that can include hallucinations, delusions, paranoia and a loss of contact with reality in the weeks or months after childbirth.

Gallinsky told Newsweek that Faust was suffering from psychosis—not postpartum psychosis like Clancy—at the time she killed her son. She said both women reached out to their own moms to come help because they recognized how terrible their intrusive thoughts had become, and both women didn't feel safe around their children. She said, like Clancy, Faust was having auditory hallucinations and was doing everything in "her power to ignore or make [them] go away."

"Both were psychiatrically hospitalized before the killings happened. Neither woman did this out of the blue. Both were struggling enormously with their mental health. But, like most women and almost-all moms, they were just trying to get through each day, care for their children, be a good mom/wife/employee. Both were seeking help from doctors who weren’t really taking their concerns seriously," Gallinsky said.

Faust was ruled competent to stand trial in May, but a July 29 report from Dr. Adrienne Saxton said at the time of the crime, she was "laboring under defect of reason from disease of the mind," and therefore "incapable of distinguishing right and wrong in relation to her acts."

The state asked the judge to compel a mental health evaluation of Andrea, which they said Gallinsky did not object to.

Both cases raise similar legal questions. Prosecutors in each matter must establish that the defendants were legally responsible for their actions. Defense attorneys, meanwhile, argue that severe mental illness impaired their ability to understand what they were doing or recognize it was wrong.

The broader public debate surrounding the cases has also highlighted concerns about access to mental health care for mothers experiencing psychiatric crises.

Mental health advocates note that postpartum depression, postpartum anxiety and postpartum psychosis exist on a spectrum and require different types of intervention. While postpartum depression affects far more women, postpartum psychosis is considered rare and often requires immediate psychiatric treatment because of the risk of harm to oneself or others.

"Both of these cases highlight the failure in our society to take women and mothers seriously when it comes to their mental health. Both of these women advocated for themselves countless times and—for what? It got them nowhere," Gallinsky said.

Lindsay Clancy Trial Update

The Clancy trial remains ongoing in Plymouth Superior Court in Massachusetts, where jurors are hearing extensive testimony about her mental condition before the deaths of her children.

The defense recently presented testimony from forensic psychologist Dr. Paul Zeizel, who told jurors that Clancy reported hearing a male voice commanding her to kill her children and then kill herself. Zeizel testified that Clancy exhibited symptoms consistent with psychosis, including auditory hallucinations, paranoia, dissociation and fears that others could hear her thoughts.

Related Story

Biggest Moments from Lindsay Clancy Trial Testimony Thursday

Biggest Moments from Lindsay Clancy Trial Testimony Thursday

Defense attorneys argue that those symptoms demonstrate Clancy was suffering from postpartum psychosis and was legally insane at the time of the killings.

Prosecutors have challenged that conclusion, highlighting testimony from medical providers who treated Clancy before the deaths and did not diagnose psychosis. They have also scrutinized the defense's psychiatric experts and questioned whether Clancy appreciated the consequences of her actions.

The trial has featured competing testimony from psychiatrists, psychologists, nurses and forensic experts. Jurors have heard evidence regarding Clancy's medications, treatment history, internet searches, text messages and interactions with health care providers during the weeks leading up to the deaths.

One area of dispute involves whether Clancy repeatedly sought emergency psychiatric help and was unable to obtain adequate treatment. Defense witnesses have testified that she contacted suicide hotlines, participated in treatment programs and desperately sought relief from worsening symptoms.

Related Story

Biggest Bombshells From Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial Tuesday

Biggest Bombshells From Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial Tuesday

The prosecution has countered that extensive medical records show Clancy remained engaged in treatment and was capable of making rational decisions.

The trial entered its defense phase in August, with psychologists and family members taking the witness stand. Proceedings were briefly interrupted this week after a judge dismissed jurors early because of what was described only as an "unforeseen circumstance." Testimony is expected to resume as scheduled.

The case is being closely watched nationwide because its outcome could become one of the most significant modern tests of a postpartum psychosis defense in the United States.

For Faust, that scrutiny arrives as her own legal battle continues to develop. While the facts surrounding the North Carolina allegations differ from those facing Clancy, both cases underscore the difficulties mothers can face when struggling with severe mental illness. As courts consider whether either woman can be held fully responsible for the deaths of children, the Clancy case and possibly Faust's have sparked conversations about the state of mental health services for women.

If you or someone you know is considering suicide, please contact the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by dialing 988, text "988" to the Crisis Text Line at 741741 or go to 988lifeline.org.

Contact Newsweek editors on this story: Gray R. Thomas

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines