
...

By Jack Martinez
Reporter
Share
Newsweek is a Trust Project member
See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.
Jeb Bush was supposed to be the they-come-here-out-of-love candidate in support of immigration reform, but now he's having to defend himself over the use of the controversial term "anchor babies"—what some critics deem an effort on the part of immigrants who entered the country illegally to have children born on American soil as citizens who might then be able to bring relatives into the U.S.
Bush used the term last week, insisting that it was normal parlance. On Monday, he clarified his remarks, telling reporters that the term "anchor babies," for which he'd come under criticism, refers to "organized efforts...more related to Asian people, coming into our country, having children...taking advantage of a noble concept, which is birthright citizenship."
Read More on U.S.
By framing it as an Asian-American issue, Bush opened himself up to new criticism and a jab from Donald Trump, who has used the term without qualification and has suggested that the 14th amendment does not include birthright citizenship.
A frustrated Bush told reporters on Monday that it was "ludicrous for the Clinton campaign and others to suggest that somehow I'm using a derogatory term." Hillary Clinton has publicly equated Bush and Trump when it comes to immigration. Clinton has used comparisons to Trump's positions on key issues to discredit other Republican candidates.
The life cycle of this latest political gaffe is particularly ironic for Bush. Initial headlines focused on his suggestion that people need to "chill out" instead of calling out politicians for politically incorrect language. But the morning after Bush spoke to reporters, the attention turned to his comments on "Asian people." In other words, a statement in which Bush exasperatedly admonished people for focusing on political correctness is now being repeated in headlines because of its lack of political correctness.
"It's not fair to be taken out of context. That's the nature of politics. I just don't think that this is appropriate," Bush said Monday. He told reporters that his statements on "anchor babies" only refer to the specific situation in which foreigners conspire to bring pregnant women into the country, not instances in which undocumented immigrants living permanently in the U.S. have children.
Clinton's criticisms of Bush underscore an apparent political dynamic, one that could affect the outcome of the GOP primaries. Bush's understandable desire to explain and clarify contrasts Trump's strategy of doubling down on any incendiary comments. Whereas Bush's statements make him vulnerable to criticism, Trump's refusal to play nice backs up his message.
The gaffe cycle on television and the Internet also calls attention to the failure of public memory. Just a week ago, it was Trump who raised the eyebrows of Bill O'Reilly for suggesting that his own legal counselors had a take on birthright citizenship that would convince the Supreme Court to overturn earlier rulings without the need for a constitutional amendment. Not so long ago, during the 2012 election cycle, Trump was the symbol of a similar controversy: the birther movement. He never backed off his claims, even after the president released a long-form birth certificate and Republican leaders were eager to drop the matter.
The overarching theme of questioning who qualifies as a true American, legal or documentary evidence notwithstanding, is central to Trump's rhetoric, going back to his original presidential ambitions.
Submit Correction
View Editorial & AI Guidelines