10

Loading video...

Mitch Lawrence

By Mitch Lawrence

0

Share

Newsweek is a Trust Project member

See more of our trusted coverage when you search.Prefer Newsweek on Googleto see more of our trusted coverage when you search.


National security is often discussed in terms of technology, infrastructure, and emerging threats. The systems we build, the networks we protect, and the adversaries we track dominate the conversation.

But the people responsible for operating, protecting, and maintaining those systems are just as critical. Without experienced personnel, strong leadership, and knowledge transfer, the most advanced security systems cannot function. They become vulnerable.

I have spent about 45 years in this field. I have seen good people make decisions they were not equipped to make, not because they lacked intelligence or commitment, but because the system moved them into positions before they had developed the depth to understand what they were deciding. The consequences are not abstract.

Read More on Leadership Insights

They are measured in billions of dollars in compromised infrastructure, and in risks that never needed to exist.

Cost of Losing Experience

The root of the problem is a well-intentioned policy. Government agencies rotate personnel roughly every two years to broaden experience and advance careers.

When I was in government, I took advantage of it. I served two overseas tours. But what works for an individual career does not always work for the institution. Without the benefit of the depth of knowledge, there are unfortunate consequences when moving towards your next career assignment.

Stock image of a security guard.

...

According to Government Executive, a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report found that staff cuts at the National Nuclear Security Administration more than erased recent hiring gains, and that the reductions in staff and loss of institutional knowledge have created operational challenges and increased workloads for the staff that remained.

The security office at one location lost about 40 percent of its employees.

The Intelligence Community is feeling the same pressure. In August, The Washington Post found that a historic number of CIA retirements and resignations, combined with staffing cuts at the Office of Personnel Management, has overwhelmed the benefits system. The agency warned employees preparing to retire that they could wait nine months or longer for their first full retirement checks.

It is a loss of expertise that takes decades to build and cannot be replaced by a hiring freeze or a new software platform. GAO found that over 60 percent of selected data that the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) used to oversee the security clearance process was not sufficiently reliable.

ODNI has four recommendations outstanding, including a priority recommendation to develop a process for assessing the reliability of agencies' data.

When Expertise Is Missing

I have watched this play out in my own work on secure facility construction. The Intelligence Community's standard for building and accrediting secure spaces, ICD 705, is precise and technical.

It requires an understanding of physics, construction, and security integration that cannot be acquired in a two-year rotation. Yet too often, the people making decisions about these facilities have not had the time to develop that understanding. I have asked, only half-jokingly, whether they spell physics with an 'F' or a 'Ph'.

The financial stakes are enormous. In my experience, one major aerospace contractor estimated that upgrading its secure facilities would cost approximately $2 billion. That is the construction of new space, because secure facilities cannot be occupied while they are being upgraded.

A decision made without that understanding is not a decision. It is a guess with a budget.

Building Knowledge for the Future

The solution is not complicated, but it requires a different posture. Government agencies should establish dedicated security technology meetings that bring decision-makers and industry experts together. Not separate meetings for security and separate meetings for technology, because that produces two groups who never talk to each other.

One forum, with subgroups for physical security, emerging technologies, construction, and other critical areas. And structured knowledge-sharing and mentoring arrangements with experienced former government personnel and contractors who understand the operational realities.

This is not about abandoning career development or government oversight. It is about ensuring that expertise is not lost in the process. When a relay race is lost, the question is not who dropped the baton.

It is whether anyone was in a position to receive it. Right now, too many experienced professionals are leaving, and too few of their successors have had the chance to learn what they know. The result is a spinning cursor, waiting for something to happen, while the decisions keep coming.

National security is not a technology problem. It is a people problem. But the people who understand it, maintain it, and decide how it is used matter more. Until we treat institutional knowledge as a strategic asset rather than a staffing line item, we will keep making the same mistake. And we will keep paying for it.

Mitch Lawrence is the founder of Lawrence Solutions LLC and a security professional with 45 years of experience protecting classified and sensitive information for U.S. government agencies and industry. The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.

View 0 Comments

Request Reprint & Licensing

Submit Correction

View Editorial & AI Guidelines